Kinship And Relatedness

Kinship is the study of how people reckon who is connected to whom, and what those connections oblige them to do.

15 frameworks, from 1865 to today · Anthropology · Social Sciences

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Kinship is the study of how people reckon who is connected to whom, and what those connections oblige them to do1. It matters because in most of the world's societies, the ties of birth and marriage—not the state, the market, or the individual—have organized who lives with whom, who inherits what, who may marry whom, who owes whom help, and who is a stranger. Anthropology made kinship one of its founding problems, and for roughly a century it was the discipline's most technical and most prestigious field. Its history is a story of increasingly precise formal tools being built, then challenged by the discovery that the tools had smuggled in assumptions about what kinship is.

Descent, marriage, and the invention of the genealogical method

Nineteenth-century anthropology was an armchair enterprise: scholars in Europe and North America assembled reports from missionaries, colonial officials, and travellers and arranged them into grand sequences of social evolution. Kinship entered through the puzzle of "primitive marriage." John Ferguson McLennan argued in Primitive Marriage (1865) that early humans practiced bride-capture and that exogamy—marrying outside one's group—preceded endogamy. Lewis Henry Morgan, working partly from his own fieldwork among the Iroquois and from a worldwide questionnaire, published Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family (1871) and Ancient Society (1877). Morgan's lasting contribution was the genealogical method: he asked informants to translate their terms for relatives into a standard grid of relationships, so that a Hawaiian term covering both "father" and "father's brother" could be compared with an English term that separates them. From this he built a typology of kin terminologies—classificatory versus descriptive systems—and argued that terminology revealed stages of social evolution, with communal marriage at the origin. His evolutionary scheme is now rejected, but the method of eliciting genealogies became the backbone of ethnographic fieldwork.

Fieldwork and the classificatory puzzle

Bronislaw Malinowski's fieldwork in the Trobriand Islands during the 1910s produced the decisive ethnographic shock. A Trobriand child, he reported, was said to inherit from and resemble its mother's brother, not its father; the father was a nurturing outsider. This could not be squared with biological paternity as Europeans understood it, and it forced anthropologists to ask whether kinship terms described biology, social roles, or something else. A. R. Radcliffe-Brown, drawing on the Andaman Islanders and later African societies, argued that kinship systems were about jural rights and duties—who holds authority over whom—rather than about blood. His comparative essays on "joking relationships" and on the mother's brother showed that the same structural position could carry opposite emotional charges in different societies, and that what mattered was the relation between relations.

Structural-functionalism and descent theory

Between the 1920s and 1950s, British social anthropology made kinship the core of social structure. Structural-functionalism treated society as a system of institutions whose function was to maintain an ordered whole; kinship was the framework of that order in societies without states. Descent theory held that the key unit was the corporate descent group—a lineage or clan whose members traced common ancestry, held property, and acted collectively. E. E. Evans-Pritchard's The Nuer (1940) showed a society organized without rulers through a segmentary lineage system: nested groups of agnates (relatives through males) that fused against outsiders at each level of conflict, so that "we" and "they" shifted with the scale of the dispute. Meyer Fortes and Evans-Pritchard's edited volume African Political Systems (1940) made descent the basis for comparing political order. Fortes's work on the Tallensi distinguished descent (corporate, jural, enduring) from filiation (a person's link to parents) and from complementary filiation—the tie to the parent who does not transmit group membership, which still carried ritual and emotional weight.

Alliance theory and the elementary structures

A rival account came from Claude Lévi-Strauss2. In Les structures élémentaires de la parenté (1949; English 1969), he argued that the fundamental fact of kinship was not descent but exchange: marriage as a transaction between groups, in which women (and the alliances they carried) circulated. His alliance theory distinguished elementary structures, where rules prescribe whom one must marry (notably cross-cousin marriage, with the child of a parent's opposite-sex sibling), from complex structures, where rules only prohibit certain partners. The incest prohibition, he held, was the founding act that turned biological families into social ones by forcing them to give and receive spouses12. The debate between descent and alliance theorists—corporate groups versus marriage exchange—dominated the field for a generation, and each side could point to societies the other explained poorly.

Formal analysis and the terminology problem

Alongside these debates ran a technical project: making kin terminologies rigorous. Alfred Kroeber (1909) had argued that terms classify relatives by several independent criteria—generation, sex, affinity, collaterality, and so on—rather than by a single evolutionary logic. In the 1940s and 1950s, George Peter Murdock's Social Structure (1949) and the cross-cultural files he built at Yale allowed statistical comparison of residence and descent patterns. The most ambitious formalization was Floyd Lounsbury's and A. Kimball Romney's componential analysis in the 1960s, which treated a terminology as a set of semantic features and tried to derive each term by rule. Harold Scheffler and Floyd Lounsbury's A Study in Structural Semantics (1971) pushed this to its limit. The approach produced real insight—showing, for instance, that many systems are consistent once you specify the rules of extension—but it also revealed how much depended on the analyst's decisions about what a term "really" meant.

Process, transaction, and practice

By the 1960s the static, jural picture of descent groups came under attack. Edmund Leach's Political Systems of Highland Burma (1954) had already shown that Kachin lineages were not fixed structures but outcomes of ongoing political maneuvering, with people shifting between gumlao (egalitarian) and gumsa (hierarchical) arrangements. Processual and transactionalist approaches, associated with Fredrik Barth and others, treated kinship as something people do—claim, negotiate, and manipulate—rather than something they simply are. Barth's work on Pathan society showed individuals choosing among competing genealogical accounts to serve present interests. Practice theory, most influentially Pierre Bourdieu's Outline of a Theory of Practice (1972; English 1977), went further: kinship rules, he argued, are not instructions people follow but post-hoc accounts of dispositions learned in the habitus. His analysis of Kabyle Berber marriage showed that the "preferred" parallel-cousin marriage was a strategic ideal invoked after the fact, not a rule that generated behavior. Marshall Sahlins's Islands of History (1985) later made a related point about how structures are transformed by events.

Feminist anthropology and the critique of kinship

From the 1970s, feminist anthropologists asked where the women were in these systems—and found that descent and alliance theory had largely treated women as objects exchanged between groups. Michelle Rosaldo and Louise Lamphere's Woman, Culture, and Society (1974) and Sherry Ortner's essay "Is Female to Male as Nature Is to Culture?" (1974) opened the question of how kinship and gender were co-produced. Gayle Rubin's "The Traffic in Women" (1975) named the "sex/gender system" and argued that kinship was where the social organization of sexuality and gender happened. Eleanor Leacock, Mona Etienne, and others showed how colonial and capitalist transformations had reshaped kinship and women's positions together. The critique did not just add women; it changed what counted as kinship, drawing attention to domestic groups, households, and the everyday labor that formal descent models had ignored.

The new kinship studies and the turn to relatedness

The decisive rupture came with David Schneider's American Kinship: A Cultural Account (1968) and A Critique of the Study of Kinship (1984)1. Schneider argued that anthropological kinship theory rested on a folk assumption of Euro-American culture—that kinship is "blood" plus "marriage"—and that the whole comparative apparatus was built on this unexamined premise1. If kinship was not a universal domain defined by biology, then the discipline's central concept dissolved1. The response was the new kinship studies of the 1990s, which took up exactly the cases that broke the old model: new reproductive technologies (in-vitro fertilization, surrogacy, donor gametes), adoption, and gay and lesbian families. Marilyn Strathern's After Nature (1992) and Reproducing the Future (1992) showed how English kinship was being rethought as nature itself became a matter of choice and information. Janet Carsten's work on a Malay fishing village, published as The Heat of the Heart (1997), found that relatedness there was made through shared food, co-residence, and everyday care rather than given at birth—so that strangers could become kin and kin could become strangers. Carsten proposed relatedness as a broader term than kinship: the ways people make and recognize connections, whether through blood, feeding, residence, or choice1. This reframing, developed with Sarah Franklin in Cultures of Relatedness (2000), moved the field from a fixed grid of positions to an open question of how connections are made, sustained, and dissolved.

Genes, DNA, and the present

The final strand is genetic. Where Morgan had inferred relatedness from terms, and descent theorists from jural rules, contemporary anthropologists can now compare social claims with genetic data. Genetic genealogy—the use of Y-chromosome and mitochondrial DNA to trace ancestry—became a mass phenomenon with commercial testing in the 2000s, and anthropologists have studied it as a cultural practice: how people interpret percentages, build origin stories, and reconcile DNA results with family knowledge. Peter Wade's work on Race, Nature and Culture (2002) and the broader literature on genetic ancestry examine how genetic information is folded into older ideas of blood and race. At the same time, the study of fictive kinship, godparenthood, and chosen kin has shown that biological connection is only one way people make families3. The field today is split between those who continue formal comparative analysis of terminologies and descent, those who work ethnographically on how relatedness is made in practice, and those who study the new genetic and reproductive technologies as sites where nature and society are remade together. The open question is the one Schneider raised and no one has fully answered: whether "kinship" names a real cross-cultural domain or a Western category that anthropology has now learned to do without1.

References

  1. Kinship (introduction, Alliance (marital exchange systems), Recognition of fluidity in kinship meanings and relations, Schneider's critique of genealogical concepts, Post-Schneider), Wikipedia
  2. Alliance theory, Wikipedia
  3. Fictive kinship, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Kinship And Relatedness

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1865-1900
  2. 1871-Present

    Genealogical method

    How can we record and compare kin terms?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1920-1960

    Structural-functionalism

    How does kinship maintain social order?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1940-1970

    Descent theory

    What role do descent groups play?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1940-1990
  6. 1949-1980

    Alliance theory

    How does marriage exchange create alliance?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1949-1980
  8. 1954-1985
  9. 1956-1980

    Componential analysis

    What semantic features define kin terms?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1960-Present

    Fictive kinship

    How are kinship ties made rather than given?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1972-2000

    Practice theory

    How do rules relate to actual practice?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  12. 1974-Present
  13. 1990-Present
  14. 1997-Present
  15. 2000-Present

    Genetic genealogy

    How can DNA trace ancestry and kin?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Evolutionary kinship theoryGenealogical methodStructural-functionalismDescent theoryKin terminology typologyAlliance theoryCross-cultural statistical comparisonProcessual and transactionalist appro…Componential analysisFictive kinshipPractice theoryFeminist anthropology of kinshipNew kinship studiesRelatednessGenetic genealogy

Beyond the field

Where Kinship And Relatedness's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 48 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Kinship And Relatedness is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 15 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Kinship And Relatedness

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Anthropology

See where Kinship And Relatedness sits on the Map of Human Knowledge