Art Criticism

Art Criticism: A History Art criticism is the practice of describing, interpreting, and judging works of art in writing, and of arguing in public about what art should be and do.

16 frameworks, from 380 BCE to today · Visual Arts · Arts & Architecture

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Art Criticism: A History

Art criticism is the practice of describing, interpreting, and judging works of art in writing, and of arguing in public about what art should be and do. It is not the same as art history, though the two share methods: the historian asks what a work was and meant in its own time, while the critic asks what it means, and is worth, now—and often tries to shape what artists make next. What is at stake is the value of images and objects in a society: who gets to say a work is good, what standards justify that judgment, and whose experience counts. The history of criticism is therefore a history of changing answers to a simple question—by what right does anyone tell the rest of us what art is?

Ancient Foundations: Rules, Imitation, and the Power of Images

Criticism begins in the ancient world as a branch of philosophy and rhetoric. Plato, in the Republic, distrusted the visual arts as copies of copies, twice removed from truth, and worried about their power to shape character. Aristotle's Poetics answered with a more analytic approach to imitation (mimesis), and although it concerns drama, its method—classifying genres and explaining how a work produces its effects—became the template for later writing on the visual arts.

The most consequential ancient text for the visual arts is the Natural History of Pliny the Elder (first century CE), which recounts anecdotes about Greek painters and sculptors: contests over illusion, a painter fooling birds with grapes, a rival pulling the veil from a painted curtain. These stories established the themes that would dominate criticism for centuries—lifelikeness, invention, the rivalry between artists—and the idea that a work can be judged by how completely it deceives the eye.

Renaissance and Baroque: Biography, Rules, and the Rise of the Connoisseur

The modern discipline takes shape in the Italian Renaissance. Giorgio Vasari's Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects (first edition 1550, expanded 1568) combined biography with a theory of progress: art had declined after antiquity and was reborn with Giotto, matured with Leonardo and Raphael, and reached perfection with Michelangelo. Vasari's criteria—disegno (drawing as the intellectual conception behind a work), grace, and judgment—set the terms of praise for generations.

In the seventeenth century, criticism became a matter of doctrine. The French Academy, founded in 1648, debated the relative merits of drawing and color and codified rules derived from classical antiquity and from Nicolas Poussin. The "quarrel of the ancients and moderns" at the end of the century asked whether contemporary achievement could rival antiquity at all. Meanwhile, the rise of collecting created the connoisseur: an expert who attributes works to hands by close attention to handling, style, and detail. Connoisseurship was systematized in the eighteenth century by Johann Joachim Winckelmann, whose History of the Art of Antiquity (1764) treated Greek sculpture as the embodiment of "noble simplicity and quiet grandeur," and by later cataloguers such as Giovanni Morelli, whose method of reading minor anatomical details—ears, hands—to identify a painter became a model of forensic attribution.

The Enlightenment: Public Judgment and the Birth of Taste

The eighteenth century moved criticism out of the academy and into the public sphere. In Paris, the Salon exhibitions of the Royal Academy gave rise to a new genre: the review of a temporary exhibition addressed to a general reading public. Denis Diderot's Salons (written 1759–1781, published in the Correspondance littéraire) are the founding examples—vivid, opinionated, sometimes fictionalized accounts that judged paintings by their moral and emotional effect as much as their technique. Diderot praised Jean-Baptiste Greuze's domestic scenes for their sentiment and attacked the frivolity of François Boucher's mythologies; in doing so he invented the idea that the critic's task is to speak for the viewer's experience.

In Britain, Joseph Addison's essays in The Spectator (1712) and later Joshua Reynolds's Discourses (delivered to the Royal Academy from 1769) treated taste as something that could be cultivated and taught. Reynolds argued that the painter should generalize from particular appearances to ideal form, subordinating mere copying to intellectual conception—a neoclassical program that dominated academic training into the nineteenth century.

Kant and the Autonomy of Aesthetic Judgment

Immanuel Kant's Critique of Judgment (1790) gave criticism its most durable philosophical foundation. Kant argued that a judgment of beauty is subjective—it rests on a feeling of pleasure—yet claims universal agreement: when we say a rose is beautiful, we speak "with a universal voice," expecting others to agree even though we cannot prove it by concepts1. This "free play" of imagination and understanding, disinterested and independent of desire or utility, made taste a matter of reflective judgment rather than rule-following1. The consequence for criticism was profound: the critic could no longer simply apply academic rules, but had to articulate a judgment that others could be persuaded to share. Kant's framework—disinterestedness, the autonomy of the aesthetic—remained the background against which almost all later criticism defined itself, whether by accepting or rejecting it.

The Nineteenth Century: Morality, Modern Life, and the Critic as Advocate

The nineteenth century multiplied the critic's roles. In Britain, John Ruskin became the most influential art writer of the age. Modern Painters (1843–1860) defended J. M. W. Turner against charges of formlessness by arguing that truth to nature—especially to the subtle facts of atmosphere and geology—was the highest aim of art. Ruskin's later work turned criticism into moral and social argument: The Stones of Venice (1851–1853) read Venetian architecture as evidence of the spiritual condition of its makers, and Unto This Last (1860) attacked the political economy of his day. For Ruskin, a society's art was a direct index of its justice.

In France, Charles Baudelaire invented the criticism of modern life. His essay "The Painter of Modern Life" (1863) celebrated the artist as a flâneur—a strolling observer of the city—who extracts the eternal from the fleeting. Baudelaire defended Delacroix's imagination and championed the etcher Constantin Guys as a recorder of fashion and crowds. His advocacy established a model of criticism as partisanship: the critic does not merely judge finished works but identifies and defends the new.

The same decades saw the rise of the independent critic as a professional voice. Émile Zola's defense of Édouard Manet and the Impressionists (from the 1866 Salon onward) argued that the academy's standards were exhausted and that the future belonged to painters who registered contemporary light and life. The critic as champion of the avant-garde—later exemplified by Félix Fénéon's coining of "Neo-Impressionism" in 1886—became a fixture of the modern art world.

Formalism: Significant Form and the Defense of the New

The early twentieth century produced the first fully developed formalist criticism. In Art (1914) and Vision and Design (1920), the British critic Roger Fry argued that what matters in a work is not its subject or its moral message but its "significant form"—the arrangement of lines, shapes, and colors that provokes aesthetic emotion. Fry's advocacy of Cézanne and the Post-Impressionists (his 1910 exhibition in London, "Manet and the Post-Impressionists," introduced them to Britain) used this theory to defend art that seemed crude or distorted to a public expecting finish. Clive Bell, Fry's associate, gave the doctrine its slogan in Art (1914). Formalism's strength was that it explained why a work could move viewers who knew nothing of its subject; its weakness was that "significant form" was hard to define without circularity.

Greenberg and the American Century

The most influential critic of the mid-twentieth century was Clement Greenberg, whose essay "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" (1939) and later "Modernist Painting" (1960) defined a program. Greenberg argued that modernism was the self-criticism of culture: each art should purify itself by attending to what was unique to its medium. Painting's distinctive property was flatness, so the history of advanced painting was a progressive acknowledgment of the flat surface—from Manet through Cubism to the Abstract Expressionists, whom Greenberg championed in the 1940s and 1950s. His criticism was both descriptive and prescriptive: it told artists what to do next and told collectors what to buy.

Greenberg's formalism was contested from within. Harold Rosenberg's essay "The American Action Painters" (1952) described the canvas as "an arena in which to act," treating the painting as a record of the artist's encounter with the material rather than a self-contained object23. Where Greenberg saw optical purity, Rosenberg saw existential drama; the two accounts of Abstract Expressionism competed for decades. Meanwhile, the critic and historian Leo Steinberg offered a different account of the 1960s, arguing in "Other Criteria" (1972) that the "flatbed picture plane" of Rauschenberg and others had replaced the vertical window of Renaissance painting with a horizontal surface of information—a shift Greenberg's medium-specific story could not accommodate.

The Institutional Turn and the Critique of the Critic

The 1960s and 1970s undermined the assumptions on which formalist criticism rested. The minimalist artists and their defenders argued that the meaning of a work lay not in its internal relations but in the situation of its viewing. The philosopher and critic Arthur Danto's essay "The Artworld" (1964), prompted by Andy Warhol's Brillo Boxes, argued that something becomes art only within an "artworld"—a context of theory and institutions that makes it intelligible as art4. George Dickie developed this into the "institutional theory of art" (1974), holding that a work is art because the artworld confers that status on it4. The critic's authority was thus revealed as itself institutional: the power to include or exclude.

This recognition fueled a wave of criticism that asked whose interests the institution served. Feminist art criticism from the late 1960s onward—exemplified by Linda Nochlin's essay "Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?" (1971)—argued that the canon of "greatness" reflected the conditions of access and training rather than innate genius, and that the very standards of judgment were gendered. Critics such as Griselda Pollock and Rozsika Parker extended the analysis to the ways art history and criticism had constructed the category of the artist. Postcolonial and decolonial criticism, from the 1970s and 1980s, made a parallel argument about geography: the story of modern art centered on Paris and New York was a provincial narrative presented as universal, and the critic's task was to expose its exclusions and recover the art it had marginalized.

Theory-Driven Interpretation

From the 1970s, criticism absorbed the vocabulary of continental theory—structuralism, semiotics, psychoanalysis, Marxism, and later post-structuralism. The critic's job became interpretation in a strong sense: to read a work as a symptom of ideology, desire, or language. This "theory-driven" criticism was powerful but also provoked resistance. The 1980s "culture wars" in the United States and Britain turned on whether criticism should judge works by aesthetic or political criteria, and the debate over the canon—which works and which voices belong in the story of art—became a public controversy. The critic's authority, once grounded in taste or expertise, was now contested from every direction.

Criticism in the Present: Material, Ecological, and Labor Perspectives

The most recent turn in criticism has been toward the material and the planetary. Critics have attended to the substances of art—pigments, solvents, stone, and the supply chains that deliver them—and to the ecological costs of making and displaying objects. Labor criticism asks who made the work, under what conditions, and who profits; it connects the studio to the factory and the museum to the gig economy. These approaches descend from the social criticism of Ruskin and the institutional critique of the 1970s, but they extend the question of value beyond the object to the systems that produce it.

Today, art criticism is plural and unsettled. The major approaches coexist: connoisseurship survives in attribution and the art market; formalist attention to medium persists in writing about painting and sculpture; feminist, postcolonial, and institutional critique are embedded in academic and museum discourse; and the newer material and ecological criticism is still being defined. The questions that remain open are the oldest ones in new form: whether judgment can be justified to anyone beyond the already convinced, whether the critic speaks for a public or only for a profession, and whether criticism can keep pace with art that no longer looks like art at all.

References

  1. Aesthetics (Aesthetic judgments and taste), Wikipedia
  2. Harold Rosenberg, Wikipedia
  3. Action painting (Background), Wikipedia
  4. Theory of art (Institutional), Wikipedia

The frameworks of Art Criticism

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 380 BCE-1700

    Mimetic and Rhetorical Criticism

    How does art imitate nature and move the viewer?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1435-1800
  3. 1550-1850

    Academic Doctrine and the Connoisseur

    Who can reliably judge the quality of a work?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1712-1800
  5. 1764-Present

    Connoisseur

    How can we attribute a work to its maker?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1790-Present

    Critique of Judgment

    How can a judgment of beauty be universal?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1843-1900

    Moral and Social Criticism

    What does art reveal about society's health?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1863-Present
  9. 1910-1970

    Significant form

    What formal qualities make art aesthetically valuable?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1939-1970

    Greenbergian Modernism

    What is unique to each art medium?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1952-1975
  12. 1964-Present
  13. 1970-Present

    Theory-Driven Interpretation

    How does theory shape our interpretation of art?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  14. 1971-Present

    Feminist Art Criticism

    How does gender shape art and its criticism?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  15. 1978-Present

    Postcolonial and Decolonial Criticism

    How does colonialism shape art and its histories?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  16. 2005-Present

    Material, Ecological and Labor Criticism

    How is art entangled with materials and labor?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Mimetic and Rhetorical CriticismClassical and Neoclassical Art TheoryAcademic Doctrine and the ConnoisseurEnlightenment Taste and Public Judgme…ConnoisseurCritique of JudgmentMoral and Social CriticismCriticism of Modern Life and Avant-Ga…Significant formGreenbergian ModernismAction Painting and Existential Criti…Institutional Theory of ArtTheory-Driven InterpretationFeminist Art CriticismPostcolonial and Decolonial CriticismMaterial, Ecological and Labor Critic…

Beyond the field

Where Art Criticism's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 81 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Art Criticism is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 16 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Art Criticism

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Visual Arts

See where Art Criticism sits on the Map of Human Knowledge