Constitutional Change

A constitution is designed to outlast the people who write it, yet no constitution survives unchanged.

13 frameworks, from 1789 to today · Constitutional Theory · Law

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

A constitution is designed to outlast the people who write it, yet no constitution survives unchanged. Constitutional change is the study of that paradox: how foundational law is amended, reinterpreted, replaced, suspended, or quietly hollowed out, and who has the authority to decide which of these has happened. The stakes are immediate. A clause requiring a two-thirds majority for amendment, a court declaring that a legislature cannot alter the "basic structure" of the constitution, a military decree suspending the document entirely—each is a claim about how constitutional order legitimately transforms. Constitutional theory has produced competing answers, and those answers have shaped real constitutional orders from Philadelphia to Pretoria to Budapest.

Amendment as the Paradigm: Formal Procedure Analysis

The modern field began with the written constitution itself. When the United States Constitution took effect in 1789, it contained Article V, a procedure for its own amendment: proposals by two-thirds of Congress or a convention of states, ratification by three-quarters of the states. The framers thereby posited a distinction that has organized the field ever since—between constituent power (the authority that makes a constitution) and constituted power (the ordinary authority a constitution creates). Amendment sits awkwardly between them: it is a legal procedure that touches the foundational document.

For much of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, scholars treated formal amendment as the whole of constitutional change. The dominant tradition was textual and procedural: identify the article governing amendment, apply its rules, and the result is a valid constitutional change. This remains a living approach, and its practitioners have generated a rich comparative literature on amendment difficulty—the observation, associated with the political scientist Donald Lutz and later formalized by researchers such as Rosalind Dixon and Tom Ginsburg, that very rigid constitutions tend to be circumvented by informal means while very flexible ones offer little protection. The concrete case is familiar: the United States Constitution has been amended only twenty-seven times in over two centuries, while some state constitutions are amended dozens of times per decade. Formal procedure analysis explains the mechanics but struggles with the fact that most constitutions change without any amendment at all.

The People Behind the Text: Constituent Power Theory

The decisive turn came from the French Revolution. In What Is the Third Estate? (1789), Emmanuel Sieyès argued that the nation—the people as a collective—possesses an original, pre-legal power to constitute government. The constitution is the nation's creation; the nation is never bound by it. This pouvoir constituant (constituent power) is distinct from the pouvoir constitué (constituted powers) that the constitution establishes. The idea gave revolutionaries a vocabulary for legitimate rupture: a people may rightly replace a constitution that no longer serves it.

Constituent power theory received its most influential modern restatement from Carl Schmitt in Verfassungslehre (1928). Schmitt argued that the constitution's identity lies not in its text but in the concrete political decision of the sovereign people about the form of its existence. This had a dark implication: if the people's existential decision is prior to all law, then the limits a constitution places on its own change are not truly binding. Schmitt's Decisionism—the view that sovereignty is the power to decide on the exception, including the suspension of the legal order—grew from this seed12. His argument that the Weimar Constitution's "eternity" clauses were political commitments rather than legal constraints troubled contemporaries and remains a reference point for debates on whether a constitution can entrench itself.

The tradition's most careful reconstruction came from Andreas Kalyvas, whose Democracy and the Politics of the Extraordinary (2008) recovered constituent power as a democratic, not authoritarian, idea: the extraordinary moment of founding as the source of all ordinary politics. The persistent problem is institutionalization—how a people exercises constituent power without a procedure to do so, and who can credibly claim to speak for them.

The Brief Moment: Constitutional Moments Theory

In We the People: Foundations (1991), the Yale legal scholar Bruce Ackerman proposed that American constitutional change has occurred in three great "constitutional moments": the Founding, the Reconstruction amendments (1865–1870), and the New Deal (1932–1938). In each, a mobilized electorate, acting through sustained political struggle, ratified a fundamental transformation that courts subsequently recognized. Ackerman's concept of a "moment" is dualist: normal politics is ordinary lawmaking, but during a moment the people act as a higher lawmaker, and their achievement deserves recognition as constitutional despite the absence of formal amendment.

The theory solved a genuine puzzle: how to explain that the New Deal's constitutional revolution—the expansion of federal regulatory power—was never formally amended into the text. It also generated sharp debate. Critics argued that the criteria for what counts as a constitutional moment are vague and potentially self-serving; once one abandons the text, what stops a court or scholar from declaring any favored political victory constitutional? Conservative originalists in particular saw in it a license for judges to ratify contemporary politics. The debate sharpened the field's sensitivity to the difference between legitimate and illegitimate extra-textual change.

Judges as Amenders: The Basic Structure Doctrine

The most concrete institutional answer to illegal constitutional change emerged outside Europe. In Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973), the Supreme Court of India held, by a narrow majority, that Parliament's amending power under Article 368 could not destroy the "basic structure" or essential features of the Constitution. The case arose from constitutional amendments passed by Indira Gandhi's government3. The doctrine established judicial review of constitutional amendments themselves: a court may invalidate an amendment that, though procedurally perfect, alters the constitution's fundamental identity.

The doctrine's logic descends from a German idea, the Ewigkeitsklausel (eternity clause) of the Basic Law of 1949, Article 79(3), which forbids amendments touching human dignity, the democratic order, or federalism. "Eternity clause constitutionalism" more broadly is the practice of entrenching certain commitments beyond any amendment. But India's basic structure doctrine went further than the German model: it did not rely on a textually enumerated list of unamendable principles. The court identified structure from the constitution as a whole. The doctrine was later adopted in various forms by courts in Bangladesh, Kenya, and elsewhere, and it became a reference point for scholarship on unamendability—Yaniv Roznai's Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments (2017) surveys the global practice. Its defenders see it as a bulwark against elected autocrats; its critics see it as judicial supremacy over the people's representatives with no textual anchor.

The Constitution as Organism: Evolutionary and Living Constitutionalism

Alongside the amendment debates, a different tradition described change as continuous adaptation. The term "living constitution" is associated with the American progressive era and with the jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.'s remark in Missouri v. Holland (1920) that the Constitution must be interpreted in light of the "growth" of the nation. In The Living Constitution (1927), the historian Howard McBain's earlier work and later scholars such as Bruce Ackerman and David Strauss developed the view that constitutional meaning evolves through judicial interpretation, custom, and popular practice rather than formal amendment alone.

European "evolutionary constitutionalism" was a related but distinct strand. In Die Verfassung des Deutschen Reichs (1871) and later work, the German public lawyer Georg Jellinek described constitutional change that occurs through the silent transformation of constitutional practice—Verfassungswandel, the "change of the constitution" without change of its text. The concept is indispensable to any account of how, for example, the office of the British prime minister or the American president gained powers the text never granted. The evolutionary view makes possible a realistic account of long-lived constitutions, but it raises the control problem: if meaning evolves, who governs the evolution, and how is an illegitimate evolution distinguished from a legitimate one?

Constitutionalism Under Pressure: Authoritarian and Post-Sovereign Accounts

The twentieth century produced a counter-tradition that asked whether constitutionalism could survive the sovereignty of the exception. Carl Schmitt's decisionism, formulated in Politische Theologie (1922), contended that the sovereign is whoever decides the exception—the situation in which the legal order is suspended2. For Schmitt, the liberal constitution, with its procedural constraints, was an illusion; the real question was always who holds power in the emergency. This is no mere historical curiosity: scholars of "authoritarian constitutionalism" study how regimes retain constitutions while concentrating power—through amendment, emergency powers, and the strategic use of legality. The Hungarian constitution of 2011, rewritten under Viktor Orbán's supermajority and repeatedly amended, is a frequently studied case of constitutional change used to entrench a governing party's advantage.

A contrasting response came with the postwar order. Global constitutionalism, associated with scholars such as Jürgen Habermas, Anne Peters, and the constitutional pluralism of Neil Walker and Nico Krisch, holds that constitutional principles increasingly operate beyond the state—in international human rights regimes, the European Union's legal order, and transnational courts. "Post-sovereign constitutionalism," developed in work by Stephen Gardbaum and others on postwar constitutions, describes arrangements that deliberately fragment or limit sovereign power: entrenched rights enforced by constitutional courts, supranational constraint, and, in the European Union, the coexistence of national and Union legal orders without a final arbiter. The European Union's own development—the European Court of Justice's assertion of supremacy and direct effect in the 1960s, and its subsequent accommodation of national constitutional courts—is the paradigm case of constitutional change happening through intercourt dialogue rather than formal amendment.

Decentering the Canon: Critical and Postcolonial Constitutional Theory

From the late twentieth century, a further challenge asked whose experience the field had been theorizing. Postcolonial constitutional theory examined how constitutions in Africa, Asia, and Latin America were shaped by imperial legacies and by the need to build legitimacy after independence; critical constitutional theory, drawing on Marxist, feminist, and critical race approaches, asked how constitutional change reproduces existing power. The South African Constitution of 1996—negotiated rather than imposed, with a transformative mandate and a Constitutional Court empowered to review amendments—became a central example of constitutional change designed with historical injustice in view. Scholars such as Karin van Marle and Dennis Davis, and comparative work by Sujit Choudhry, traced how the South African experience both borrowed from and departed from European and American models. The critical turn has reshaped the field's agenda: constitutional change is now routinely studied as a question of whose interests an amendment or a doctrine serves, and whose voices were excluded from the founding.

The Present Field

Today the study of constitutional change is plural but integrated around a few problems. Formal amendment analysis remains foundational and has grown more sophisticated through empirical work on amendment rates and design4. Constituent power theory and constitutional moments theory continue to frame the question of legitimate rupture and extra-textual change, with debate centering on institutionalization and the risk of self-serving recognition. The basic structure doctrine and eternity clauses are now a global research program on unamendability5. Evolutionary and living-constitution accounts supply the vocabulary for informal change6. Post-sovereign and global constitutionalism describe the vertical and horizontal diffusion of constitutional authority, while authoritarian constitutionalism and critical theory keep the field alert to change that consolidates rather than disperses power.

Open questions persist. Can constituent power be formalized without being captured? Do courts that review amendments protect the constitution or substitute their own politics? How should the field treat constitutional change that happens through erosion—the gradual dismantling of checks by a government that never formally abandons the text? And whose constitutional experience should count as the paradigm? These questions are not merely academic; they determine how theorists and citizens judge the legitimacy of the next constitutional order to emerge, and of the one they inhabit now.

References

  1. Decisionism, Wikipedia
  2. State of exception, Wikipedia
  3. Minerva Mills v. Union of India, Wikipedia
  4. Constitutional amendment, Wikipedia
  5. Entrenched clause, Wikipedia
  6. Living Constitution, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Constitutional Change

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1789-Present

    Constituent Power Theory

    Who has the authority to make a constitution?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1789-Present

    Formal Amendment Procedure Analysis

    What procedures make a constitutional amendment valid?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1871-Present

    Verfassungswandel (Evolutionary Constitutionalism)

    How does a constitution change without its text changing?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1920-Present

    Living Constitution

    Should constitutional meaning evolve with society?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1922-1985

    Decisionism

    Who decides when the legal order is suspended?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1949-Present

    Entrenched clause

    Can a constitution protect some commitments from amendment?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1973-Present

    Basic Structure Doctrine

    Can courts invalidate constitutional amendments?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1980-Present

    Critical Constitutional Theory

    Whose interests does constitutional change serve?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1990-Present

    Global Constitutionalism

    Can constitutional principles transcend the nation-state?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1990-Present

    Postcolonial Constitutional Theory

    How do postcolonial states remake inherited constitutions?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1991-Present

    Constitutional Moments Theory

    When does political struggle count as constitutional change?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  12. 1995-Present

    Post-Sovereign Constitutionalism

    Can constitutional authority be shared beyond the sovereign state?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  13. 2000-Present

    Authoritarian Constitutionalism

    How do constitutions enable authoritarian rule?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Constituent Power TheoryFormal Amendment Procedure AnalysisVerfassungswandel (Evolutionary Const…Living ConstitutionDecisionismEntrenched clauseBasic Structure DoctrineCritical Constitutional TheoryGlobal ConstitutionalismPostcolonial Constitutional TheoryConstitutional Moments TheoryPost-Sovereign ConstitutionalismAuthoritarian Constitutionalism

Beyond the field

Where Constitutional Change's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 78 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Constitutional Change is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Constitutional Change

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Constitutional Theory

See where Constitutional Change sits on the Map of Human Knowledge