Desistance And Reentry

Desistance is the process by which people who have committed crimes stop doing so and rebuild lives that no longer revolve around offending.

13 frameworks, from 1790 to today · Criminology · Social Sciences

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Desistance is the process by which people who have committed crimes stop doing so and rebuild lives that no longer revolve around offending. Reentry is the practical and social passage back into ordinary life after prison or other punishment1. The two are entangled: reentry is the institutional doorway, desistance the long, uneven walk through it. What is at stake is large. Most people imprisoned anywhere in the world will one day be released, and whether they reoffend depends less on the walls that held them than on what happens afterward—work, housing, family, identity, and the way they are treated by the state and their neighbours. The history of this subfield is the story of how criminologists, practitioners, and formerly incarcerated people themselves came to see release not as an ending but as a beginning, and how ideas about why people stop offending moved from moral reform, to prediction and control, to a psychology of change, and finally to a broader account of social reintegration.

The Penitentiary and the Reform Ideal

Modern thinking about reentry begins with the penitentiary itself. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, reformers in Europe and North America replaced corporal and capital punishment with confinement, and confinement was justified as reform. The Pennsylvania system, developed at Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia from the 1820s, held prisoners in solitary cells so that silence and reflection would produce repentance—hence "penitentiary." The rival Auburn system in New York, from the 1820s onward, congregated prisoners by day under strict silence and isolated them at night. Both assumed that the prison could remake the person, and both were exported widely, including to Europe and Latin America.

The reformatory idea extended this to young adults. The Elmira Reformatory in New York, opened in 1876 under Zebulon Brockway, combined indeterminate sentences, education, and trade training with early release for good behaviour. The mark system, developed earlier by Alexander Maconochie on Norfolk Island and by Walter Crofton in the Irish prison system in the mid-nineteenth century, let prisoners earn remission of sentence through labour and conduct—an early mechanism linking behaviour inside to release outside. These institutions made release conditional and gradual, and in doing so created the ancestor of modern parole2.

Parole, Prediction, and Follow-Up Research

Parole—supervised early release—spread through the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, and with it came a question: who should be released, and who will succeed3? The answer was sought in prediction. Ernest Burgess, at the University of Chicago, published in 1928 a study of 3,000 parolees in Illinois that assigned points to factors such as employment history and offence type to forecast success. Sheldon and Eleanor Glueck followed with longitudinal studies of released prisoners and delinquents, most famously 500 Criminal Careers (1930) and later Unraveling Juvenile Delinquency (1950), tracking people over years rather than judging them at a single moment. The Gluecks' work introduced the idea that offending and its cessation are shaped by long-run personal and social histories, and their prediction tables became a template for risk scoring.

This was also the era of the rehabilitative welfare model in community corrections. From roughly the 1920s to the 1970s, probation and parole officers in many countries combined supervision with casework, connecting released people to jobs, housing, and treatment. The model assumed that crime was a symptom of social or psychological need and that the state's job was to address that need. It was optimistic, professionalising, and—critics later charged—poorly evaluated.

Nothing Works and the Deterrence Turn

The optimism collapsed in the 1970s. Robert Martinson's 1974 article "What Works?—Questions and Answers About Prison Reform," reviewing evaluations of rehabilitation programmes, concluded that few had demonstrable effects. The phrase "nothing works" became a slogan, though Martinson himself later qualified it. The wider turn was toward deterrence and incapacitation: if programmes did not reform people, then the point of punishment was to make offending costly and to keep dangerous people confined45. Indeterminate sentencing gave way to fixed sentences and mandatory minimums, especially in the United States, and prison populations rose sharply from the 1970s onward. Reentry, in this climate, was largely an afterthought; release was a date, not a programme.

Risk, Need, and the Cognitive Turn

The reaction against "nothing works" produced one of the subfield's most durable frameworks. In Canada, researchers at what became the firm of Andrews and Bonta developed the Risk-Need-Responsivity model, set out systematically in Don Andrews, James Bonta, and Robert Hoge's work from the late 1980s and in Bonta's later writings. Its three principles: match the intensity of intervention to the person's assessed risk (risk); target the factors that actually predict offending, such as antisocial attitudes and associates, rather than unrelated needs (need); and deliver treatment in ways the person can respond to, such as cognitive-behavioural methods (responsivity). The model's central claim was that well-designed, well-targeted programmes do reduce reoffending—a direct rebuttal of "nothing works"—and it became the organising logic of correctional practice in Canada, the United Kingdom, and beyond.

Its companion was actuarial risk assessment: the use of statistical instruments, rather than clinical judgement alone, to estimate the probability of reoffending. Instruments such as the Level of Service Inventory, developed by Andrews and Bonta in the 1990s, scored static and dynamic factors to place people in risk bands. Actuarial tools spread widely and provoked a long debate about accuracy, fairness, and the ethics of predicting behaviour from group statistics. The debate sharpened when the American tool COMPAS became the subject of a widely reported 2016 investigation by ProPublica into racial disparities in its error rates.

Labeling, Shaming, and the Social Reaction

A parallel tradition asked not what is wrong with the offender but what the response to offending does to them. Labeling theory, developed by Frank Tannenbaum in the 1930s and elaborated by Edwin Lemert, Howard Becker, and others in the 1950s and 1960s, argued that being publicly defined as a criminal can push a person toward a criminal identity—the "secondary deviance" that follows the label. This implied that reentry policy should avoid stigmatising ex-prisoners. John Braithwaite's Crime, Shame and Reintegration (1989) refined the idea: shame can be destructive when it is stigmatising and exclusionary, but reintegrative when it condemns the act while welcoming the person back into the community. The theory, developed in Australia, influenced restorative justice practices worldwide and gave reentry a vocabulary for thinking about how communities receive returning people.

Developmental and Life-Course Criminology

The most important shift in the study of desistance came from asking how offending changes across a life. Sheldon and Eleanor Glueck's longitudinal work was an early landmark, but the modern field crystallised in the 1980s and 1990s. Robert Sampson and John Laub, reanalysing the Gluecks' data, published Crime in the Making (1993), which combined control theory with a life-course view: childhood bonds shape early offending, but adult turning points—marriage, employment, military service—can redirect trajectories. Their age-graded theory of informal social control argued that desistance is driven by new attachments and obligations that raise the cost of offending. Terrie Moffitt's 1993 distinction between adolescence-limited and life-course-persistent offenders gave the field a developmental typology, and the broader school of developmental and life-course criminology—associated with David Farrington's Cambridge Study in Delinquent Development, begun in 1961, and with researchers such as Marc Le Blanc and Rolf Loeber—established that offending and desistance must be studied over decades, not snapshots.

Identity, Narrative, and the Good Lives

From the 1990s, a psychological account of desistance took shape. Shadd Maruna's Making Good (2001), based on interviews with persistent offenders in Liverpool, found that those who desisted told a different story about themselves—one of redemption rather than condemnation, in which their past became a resource for a valued future. This narrative identity approach, developed alongside work by Peggy Giordano and others on cognitive transformation, argued that desistance requires a change in how a person sees themselves, not just in circumstances. The Good Lives Model, developed by Tony Ward and colleagues from the early 2000s, offered a related framework for treatment: rather than only managing risk, help people pursue the primary human goods—relationships, work, autonomy, meaning—that offending had been a distorted attempt to obtain. It became a major alternative to purely risk-focused practice.

Gender, Race, and the Reentry Policy Framework

Feminist criminologists pressed the field to notice that most desistance research studied men6. Feminist pathways research, developed from the 1980s onward by scholars such as Kathleen Daly and later by Beth Richie and others, traced how histories of abuse, addiction, and poverty shape women's offending and their routes out of it, and how the reentry system—designed around male prisoners—often fails women. Gendered desistance research showed that relationships, motherhood, and victimisation play different roles in women's lives, and that the "turning points" identified for men do not transfer neatly.

At the same time, reentry became a policy field in its own right. The growth of mass incarceration in the United States made release a visible social problem, and the collateral consequences of conviction—bars to employment, housing, public benefits, voting, and parental rights—were catalogued and challenged. Legal scholars and advocates documented how these "invisible punishments" extend the sentence long after release, and reentry programmes, reentry courts, and "ban the box" employment reforms followed. The framework spread internationally, though its shape varies with each country's welfare state and penal culture.

The Present

Today the field combines several strands. Risk-need-responsivity and actuarial assessment remain the backbone of correctional practice in many jurisdictions, though they are increasingly paired with strengths-based and Good Lives approaches. Developmental and life-course research continues through long-running cohort studies. Desistance research has turned toward the lived experience of the process—how people narrate change, how identity and social context interact, and how structural barriers such as housing and employment shape what is possible. Feminist and critical scholars keep asking whose desistance is being studied and whose reentry is being served. The open questions are substantial: how to measure desistance when it is a process rather than an event; whether risk prediction can be made fair; how much of reentry success is individual psychology and how much is the welfare state and the labour market; and how communities, not only corrections agencies, can become the setting in which people stop offending and stay stopped.

References

  1. Prisoner reentry, Wikipedia
  2. Reformatory, Wikipedia
  3. Parole, Wikipedia
  4. Deterrence (penology), Wikipedia
  5. Incapacitation (penology), Wikipedia
  6. Feminist school of criminology, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Desistance And Reentry

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1790-1900

    Reformatory

    Can confinement reform the offender?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1920-1975

    Rehabilitative Welfare Model

    Should the state treat offenders' social needs?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1928-1970
  4. 1938-Present
  5. 1974-1995

    Nothing Works and Deterrence Turn

    Do rehabilitation programmes reduce reoffending?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1985-Present
  7. 1987-Present

    Risk-Need-Responsivity Model

    Which interventions best reduce reoffending?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1990-Present

    Actuarial Risk Assessment

    Can statistics predict who will reoffend?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1993-Present
  10. 1993-Present
  11. 1996-Present
  12. 2001-Present
  13. 2002-Present

    Good Lives Model

    Should treatment build a good life?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

ReformatoryRehabilitative Welfare ModelPrediction and Follow-Up ResearchLabeling and Reintegrative Shaming Th…Nothing Works and Deterrence TurnFeminist Pathways and Gendered Desist…Risk-Need-Responsivity ModelActuarial Risk AssessmentAge-Graded Theory of Informal Social …Developmental and Life-Course Crimino…Collateral consequences of criminal c…Narrative Identity and Cognitive Tran…Good Lives Model

Beyond the field

Where Desistance And Reentry's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 52 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Desistance And Reentry is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Desistance And Reentry

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Criminology

See where Desistance And Reentry sits on the Map of Human Knowledge