- Atlas
- Humanities
- Critical Theory
Critical Theory
Critical theory is the practice of asking how culture—films, advertisements, pop songs, news reports, slang, shopping centres, family arrangements—helps keep unequal social arrangements in place, and how it might help loosen them.
21 frameworks, from 1935 to today · Cultural Studies · Humanities
- Benjaminian media aesthetics 1935-1980
- Frankfurt School 1937-1975
- Authoritarian personality research 1950-1970
- Marcusean one-dimensionality critique 1955-1975
- Culturalism 1957-1985
- Habermasian Public Sphere Theory 1962-Present
- Simulation and spectacle theory 1967-1995
- Situationism 1967-1990
- Interpellation 1968-1985
- Cultural hegemony 1970-Present
- Screen Theory 1972-1990
- Encoding/Decoding 1973-Present
- Feminist Cultural Studies 1975-Present
- Foucauldian Discourse Analysis 1975-Present
- Subcultural Theory 1975-1995
- Orientalism 1978-Present
- Postcolonial critique 1978-Present
- Decolonial and subaltern thought 1980-Present
- Simulation Theory 1981-2000
- Diaspora and Black Atlantic Theory 1987-Present
- Decoloniality 1992-Present
Overview
Critical theory is the practice of asking how culture—films, advertisements, pop songs, news reports, slang, shopping centres, family arrangements—helps keep unequal social arrangements in place, and how it might help loosen them1. Its practitioners read ordinary cultural material for the work it does: whose interests it serves, what it makes seem natural, who is invited to identify with it and who is not1. What is at stake is the question of how domination reproduces itself without anyone ordering it to, and what resources culture offers for refusing it. The subfield as it exists in cultural studies was assembled from several distinct inheritances—German philosophy, French theory, British adult education, anti-colonial and Black radical thought—and the story of how those inheritances were fused, argued over, and revised is the story of the field.
The Institute for Social Research: Reason Turned Against Itself
The phrase "critical theory" comes from the Institut für Sozialforschung in Frankfurt, founded in 1923 and re-established after the Nazi seizure of power by exiles, above all in New York and Los Angeles23. Its leading figures—Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, Herbert Marcuse, Leo Löwenthal, Erich Fromm—set out a program Horkheimer announced in 1937 as "traditional" versus "critical" theory: traditional theory described the world; critical theory aimed at the emancipation of human beings from conditions of domination, and treated its own concepts as part of the social world it studied. To the Marxist expectation that economic crisis would produce revolution they opposed a hard puzzle: why had the exploited in the industrial West embraced fascism or settled into consumer contentment instead1?
Their answer, in Dialectic of Enlightenment (1947), was that instrumental reason—reason used as a tool of calculation and control—had turned against its own promise of freedom14. In a widely cited chapter on the culture industry, Adorno and Horkheimer argued that mass-produced film, radio and popular music had standardized experience, making audiences passive even as they were offered "choice."5 Their colleague Walter Benjamin had already, in the 1936 essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," pressed a different case: that technologies of reproduction—photography and above all film—eroded the "aura" of the unique, authentic artwork, and might open culture to politics. Where Adorno heard in popular music only standardization, Benjamin saw in cinema new modes of collective attention. The disagreement matters because it is the template for a lasting argument in the field: is mass culture a machine for stupefaction or a terrain of possibility?
After the war the Institute returned to Frankfurt3. Adorno's Minima Moralia (1951) and his studies of authoritarianism, including the co-authored The Authoritarian Personality (1950), gave the critique an empirical side. That book, produced with Berkeley psychologists, developed the "F-scale," a questionnaire measuring susceptibility to fascist attitudes, and linked such susceptibility to family upbringing and rigid thinking6. It was widely debated—critics pressed the difficulty of measuring a personality trait across populations—but it established that the Frankfurt vocabulary of domination and repression could be operationalized in surveys6.
Marcuse's One-Dimensional Man (1964) carried the argument into the affluent 1960s: advanced industrial society, he wrote, absorbed opposition by satisfying needs it had manufactured, leaving people free in the choices of consumer goods but not in the choice of a life7. Its suggestion that the "great refusal" might come from outside the system—students, the marginalized—made Marcuse a reference point for protest movements on both sides of the Atlantic78.
Hegemony: The Question of Consent
A second line of descent runs through the Italian communist Antonio Gramsci, who wrote in Mussolini's prisons in the late 1920s and 1930s9. Gramsci rejected the idea that ruling classes hold power mainly by force9. They also rule by hegemony: by winning consent, so that their worldview becomes common sense and subordinate groups accept the terms of their own subordination109. For Gramsci hegemony is never complete—it is contested in what he called the "war of position," the slow struggle of civil society—and the intellectual's task is to help build a counter-hegemony. This concept transformed cultural analysis because it gave culture an active political role rather than that of a decorative superstructure, and it made consent, not coercion, the central question.
The Birmingham Centre and the Turn to Ordinary Culture
In Britain a quite different tradition greeted it. From the late 1950s, Richard Hoggart's The Uses of Literacy (1957), Raymond Williams's Culture and Society (1958) and E. P. Thompson's The Making of the English Working Class (1963) had treated working-class life and its culture as a serious object, against an older Leavisite criticism that policed a canon of "good" literature against mass civilization. Williams's culturalism—the claim that "culture is ordinary" and is a whole way of life, not a set of distinguished texts—was the breakthrough. In 1964 Hoggart founded the Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies at Birmingham; Stuart Hall became its director in 1968.
Birmingham's innovation was to combine Williams's attention to lived culture with Gramsci's and the French theorist Louis Althusser's questions about power. Ideology on Althusser's account is not merely false belief but the lived, material relation through which people experience their conditions; his notion of interpellation—ideology "hailing" individuals so that they recognize themselves as subjects—explained how social order is reproduced in everyday life, as when advertising addresses "you" as a certain kind of person1112. Birmingham case studies used such ideas directly. Policing the Crisis (Hall et al., 1978) traced how a moral panic over mugging in 1970s Britain helped knit consent around a harder state; The Empire Strikes Back (1982) did similar work on race. Dick Hebdige's Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979) showed punks' safety pins and torn clothing as a "bricolage" that recombined ordinary objects into a refusal, and Paul Willis's Learning to Labour (1977) followed working-class boys who expected factory work and produced, through their own resistance, the conditions of their own subordination.
Hall's most portable contribution is the encoding/decoding model (1973)1314. It argued that television messages are encoded by producers within one meaning-structure and decoded by audiences within another; audiences could take a dominant, a negotiated, or an oppositional reading15. This broke with the idea of a passive audience and made reception a scene of struggle, influencing fandom studies and audience research worldwide.
Language, Power and the Poststructuralist Wave
Meanwhile in France, from the 1960s, Foucault's studies of madness, the clinic and the prison argued that power is not something held by rulers but circulates through discourse—systems of statements that define what can be said, by whom, about what—and through institutions that classify and discipline bodies. His history of sexuality and his concepts of the disciplinary society and "governmentality" gave cultural studies a way to analyse the ordinary management of populations: schooling, health inspection, statistics, architecture. The advantage over Althusser was a more flexible, decentred model of power; the risk, critics said, was a power everywhere and therefore nowhere resistible.
The French poststructuralists were exported to the English-speaking world, especially through the journal Screen in 1970s Britain, where film theory, psychoanalysis and ideology critique were fused in debates over spectatorship. At Birmingham and elsewhere, feminist cultural studies then insisted that these questions of power were gendered. The Centre's Women's Studies Group produced Women Take Issue (1978); Angela McRobbie wrote on girls' magazines; the Screen critics Laura Mulvey and others theorized the gaze. Feminist work also pressed the field on class: its early analyses of work, family and consumption showed how the private sphere was a site of power, not an escape from it.
Simulation, Spectacle and the Critique of the Image
Two French writers supplied a grammar for the age of ubiquitous images. Guy Debord's The Society of the Spectacle (1967) described a world in which "all that was once directly lived has become mere representation"—social life organized around images that separate people from their own activity. Jean Baudrillard pushed further: in Simulacra and Simulation (1981) he argued that signs had detached from any real referent, producing "hyperreality."1617 His example is the map that precedes the territory; his target is a culture saturated with copies so that the distinction between real and simulated collapses17. For cultural studies these arguments provided powerful tools for studying advertising, television, theme parks and later the internet, even while many practitioners regarded Baudrillard's claims as too sweeping to test.
From Empire to the Black Atlantic
The last major wave came from the colonized world and its diasporas. Edward Said's Orientalism (1978) showed how Western scholarship had produced "the Orient" as an object of knowledge and rule, giving cultural studies a model of how representation constitutes the Other18. From the Caribbean and its diaspora, Stuart Hall (drawing on the Martinican writer Frantz Fanon) and Paul Gilroy developed the idea of culture as diasporic: identity formed through displacement, mixture and "routes" as much as "roots." Gilroy's The Black Atlantic (1993) treated the Atlantic as a single cultural unit and Black modernity as a counter-culture to Enlightenment racism. Drawing on Gramsci and on the work of the Subaltern Studies group of Indian historians, postcolonial and subaltern critics asked how the colonized could speak at all within languages shaped by empire; Homi Bhabha's concepts of hybridity and mimicry, and Gayatri Spivak's essay "Can the Subaltern Speak?" (1988), became central. Latin American decolonial thinkers such as Aníbal Quijano extended the argument to the coloniality of knowledge and power persisting after formal independence.
Later, the Habermasian strand offered an alternative to domination critique1. Jürgen Habermas's The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962) traced how a bourgeois public sphere of reasoned debate emerged in eighteenth-century Europe and then declined under mass media and commercial pressure. His theory of communicative action (1981) holds that language carries an inherent orientation toward mutual understanding, which can ground a critique of systems—markets and bureaucracies—that colonize the "lifeworld." Cultural studies practitioners often found his account of rational consensus too idealized; but it supplied the vocabulary for debates about media, democracy and deliberation.
The Present: Diffuse, Digital, Contested
Today critical theory is less a school than a set of habits shared across the humanities and social sciences: reading culture for power, refusing to treat meaning as innocent, attending to race, gender, class and coloniality together. Its descendants include digital cultural studies, which applies encoding/decoding and ideology critique to platforms and algorithms; ecocriticism, which asks how culture imagines nature and crisis; and a continuing argument over whether ideological critique should aim at "demystification" or at describing how people actually use culture. The open questions are the old ones in new forms: whether audiences are now producers, whether algorithmic recommendation has replaced the culture industry, and how a critique that has learned to distrust universal reason can still justify its own claims.
References
- Critical theory (introduction, Adorno and Horkheimer, Overview, Habermas), Wikipedia
- Frankfurt School, Wikipedia
- University of Frankfurt Institute for Social Research (introduction, History), Wikipedia
- Dialectic of Enlightenment, Wikipedia
- Culture industry, Wikipedia
- The Authoritarian Personality, Wikipedia
- One-Dimensional Man, Wikipedia
- Herbert Marcuse, Wikipedia
- Antonio Gramsci, Wikipedia
- Cultural hegemony, Wikipedia
- Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses, Wikipedia
- Interpellation (philosophy), Wikipedia
- Encoding/decoding model of communication, Wikipedia
- Reception theory, Wikipedia
- Audience reception (Origins), Wikipedia
- Simulacra and Simulation, Wikipedia
- Hyperreality (introduction, Origins and usage), Wikipedia
- Orientalism (book), Wikipedia
The frameworks of Critical Theory
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1935-1980
Benjaminian media aesthetics
How does mechanical reproduction change art and politics?
- 1937-1975
- 1955-1975
Marcusean one-dimensionality critique
How does industrial society absorb opposition?
- 1957-1985
- 1962-Present
Habermasian Public Sphere Theory
How does public communication sustain democracy?
- 1967-1995
- 1967-1990
- 1968-1985
- 1970-Present
- 1972-1990
- 1973-Present
- 1975-Present
Feminist Cultural Studies
How is gender produced and contested in culture?
- 1975-Present
Foucauldian Discourse Analysis
How does discourse shape what can be said?
- 1975-1995
- 1978-Present
- 1978-Present
- 1980-Present
Decolonial and subaltern thought
Can the subaltern speak within colonial knowledge?
- 1981-2000
- 1987-Present
Diaspora and Black Atlantic Theory
How do diasporic cultures form across the Atlantic?
- 1992-Present
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Authoritarian personality research grew out of Frankfurt School
The Authoritarian Personality (1950) was produced by Adorno with Berkeley psychologists as an empirical extension of the Institute's critique of domination and repression, operationalizing its vocabulary in the F-scale.
Carried by Theodor W. Adorno; The Authoritarian Personality (1950).
Marcusean one-dimensionality critique grew out of Frankfurt School
Marcuse's One-Dimensional Man (1964) extends the Institute's critique of instrumental reason and the culture industry into an analysis of advanced industrial society absorbing opposition.
Carried by Herbert Marcuse; One-Dimensional Man (1964).
Encoding/Decoding grew out of Culturalism
Hall's encoding/decoding model (1973) grew directly out of the Birmingham Centre's culturalist attention to lived culture, turning it toward the analysis of how audiences make meaning from media messages.
Carried by Stuart Hall; Encoding/Decoding (1973).
Simulation Theory grew out of Simulation and spectacle theory
Baudrillard's Simulacra and Simulation (1981) developed out of the spectacle theory of Debord, pushing the detachment of signs from lived experience into hyperreality and the precession of simulacra.
Carried by Jean Baudrillard; Simulacra and Simulation (1981).
Orientalism grew out of Foucauldian Discourse Analysis
Said's Orientalism (1978) applied Foucauldian discourse analysis to Western representations of the East, showing how a body of statements constituted the Orient as an object of knowledge and rule.
Carried by Edward Said; Orientalism (1978).
Postcolonial critique grew out of Orientalism
Postcolonial critique grew directly out of Said's Orientalism and the work of the Subaltern Studies group, extending the analysis of colonial discourse to the legacies of empire and the agency of the colonized.
Carried by Edward Said; Subaltern Studies.
Decoloniality grew out of Decolonial and subaltern thought
Decoloniality was formulated by the Latin American modernity/coloniality group, building on subaltern and decolonial thought to argue that colonial power relations persist in modern knowledge and culture.
Carried by Aníbal Quijano; Walter Mignolo.
Habermasian Public Sphere Theory reacted against Frankfurt School
Habermas's Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962) grew out of the Frankfurt School but rejected Adorno and Horkheimer's totalizing critique of instrumental reason, reconstructing a communicative rationality instead.
Carried by Jürgen Habermas; The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962).
Feminist Cultural Studies grew out of Culturalism
Feminist cultural studies emerged within the Birmingham Centre, with the Women's Studies Group's Women Take Issue (1978) and McRobbie's work extending culturalism's attention to lived experience to gender and the private sphere.
Carried by Women Take Issue (1978); Angela McRobbie.
Subcultural Theory grew out of Culturalism
Hebdige's Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979) applied the Centre's culturalist and semiotic approach to youth styles, reading punk bricolage as a refusal of dominant meanings.
Carried by Dick Hebdige; Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979).
Screen Theory influenced by Interpellation
Screen theory in 1970s Britain fused Althusser's interpellation with psychoanalysis to analyse how cinema positions spectators as subjects.
Carried by Screen; Louis Althusser.
Encoding/Decoding influenced by Interpellation
Hall's encoding/decoding model drew on Althusser's account of ideology and interpellation to explain how media messages address and position audiences.
Carried by Stuart Hall; Louis Althusser.
Foucauldian Discourse Analysis reacted against Interpellation
Foucauldian discourse analysis offered a decentred model of power through discourse, developed partly against Althusser's more structuralist account of ideology and interpellation.
Carried by Michel Foucault.
Feminist Cultural Studies influenced by Cultural hegemony
Feminist cultural studies drew on Gramscian hegemony to analyse how gendered consent is produced in everyday culture, as in the Centre's Women's Studies Group work.
Carried by Women Take Issue (1978); Antonio Gramsci.
Subcultural Theory influenced by Cultural hegemony
Subcultural theory at Birmingham used Gramsci's concept of hegemony to read youth styles as counter-hegemonic struggles over meaning.
Carried by Dick Hebdige; Antonio Gramsci.
Feminist Cultural Studies influenced by Screen Theory
Feminist film theory, developed in and around Screen, took up Screen theory's psychoanalytic account of spectatorship to critique the gendered gaze, as in Mulvey's work.
Carried by Laura Mulvey; Screen.
Feminist Cultural Studies influenced by Encoding/Decoding
Feminist cultural studies used Hall's encoding/decoding model to study how girls and women negotiate media messages, extending reception analysis to gender.
Carried by Angela McRobbie; Stuart Hall.
Decolonial and subaltern thought grew out of Postcolonial critique
Decolonial and subaltern thought emerged from postcolonial critique, with the Subaltern Studies group and later Latin American decolonial writers extending its questions to the global South and the coloniality of knowledge.
Carried by Subaltern Studies; Aníbal Quijano.
Diaspora and Black Atlantic Theory influenced by Postcolonial critique
Paul Gilroy's Black Atlantic theory drew on postcolonial critique and diaspora thought to analyse the hybrid cultures formed by the Atlantic slave trade and their circulation.
Carried by Paul Gilroy; The Black Atlantic (1993).
Culturalism influenced by Frankfurt School
Birmingham cultural studies took from the Frankfurt School the question of how mass culture secures domination, though it rejected its elitism in favour of attention to ordinary culture.
Carried by Stuart Hall; Raymond Williams.
Subcultural Theory influenced by Encoding/Decoding
Subcultural theory drew on the Centre's encoding/decoding and semiotic approach to read style as a negotiated or oppositional reading of dominant culture.
Carried by Dick Hebdige; Stuart Hall.
Beyond the field
Where Critical Theory's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 163 links.
Benjaminian media aesthetics influenced Ideological Constructivism in Photography Theory
Benjamin's essays on technological reproducibility and the optical unconscious supplied the central vocabulary for ideological constructivism in photography theory. Writers such as John Tagg and Allan Sekula drew on his account of aura and reproduction when arguing that photographic meaning is politically constructed.
Carried by Walter Benjamin; The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction (1935).
Culturalism influenced British cultural studies in Sociology Of Culture
The culturalist strand in critical theory, rooted in Williams and Hoggart, was the direct intellectual foundation of British cultural studies at Birmingham.
Carried by Raymond Williams; Richard Hoggart.
Culturalism influenced Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies in Cultural Production
The Birmingham Centre took its founding approach from culturalism, with Hoggart's The Uses of Literacy and Williams's work as its models.
Carried by Richard Hoggart; Raymond Williams.
Culturalism led to Birmingham Cultural Studies in Cultural Studies
Birmingham Cultural Studies grew directly out of the culturalism of Hoggart's The Uses of Literacy (1957) and Williams's Culture and Society (1958); Hoggart founded the CCCS in 1964 and Hall developed its programme from that base. Culturalism is the parent formation of the Birmingham school.
Carried by Richard Hoggart; The Uses of Literacy (1957); Raymond Williams.
Habermasian Public Sphere Theory influenced Public Sphere Critique in Public Art Theory
Habermas's theory of the public sphere supplied public art critique with its central concepts of rational-critical debate, publicity and the bourgeois public sphere. Critics applied and contested Habermasian publicity when judging public art's democratic claims.
Carried by Jürgen Habermas.
Screen Theory grew out of Apparatus Theory in Film Theory
Apparatus theory, developed by Baudry and Metz, supplied Screen Theory with its account of the cinematic dispositif and the spectator positioned by the camera and projector. Screen Theory's psychoanalytic account of the subject in cinema grew directly out of this apparatus-theoretical work.
Carried by Jean-Louis Baudry; Christian Metz.
Encoding/Decoding grew out of Cultural Studies in Visual Communication
Hall's encoding/decoding model was developed within the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies as a refinement of cultural studies' concern with how meaning is produced and contested. It grew directly out of the cultural studies project and became one of its central methods.
Carried by Stuart Hall; Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies.
Feminist Cultural Studies grew out of British cultural studies in Sociology Of Culture
British cultural studies, centred on the Birmingham school, is the direct parent of feminist cultural studies, which arose within it as a critique of its neglect of gender.
Carried by Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies.
Feminist Cultural Studies grew out of Birmingham Cultural Studies in Cultural Studies
Feminist cultural studies grew directly out of the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, where the Women's Studies group and its 1978 volume Women Take Issue turned the school's class analysis toward gender.
Carried by Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies; Women Take Issue (1978).
Feminist Cultural Studies grew out of Cultural Studies in Visual Communication
Feminist cultural studies is a branch that grew out of cultural studies, extending its attention to class and ideology to the question of gender from the mid-1970s.
Carried by Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies.
Foucauldian Discourse Analysis influenced Critical Discourse Analysis in Discourse Analysis
Foucault's archaeological and genealogical work on discourse, power and knowledge supplied CDA with its central concept of discourse as constitutive of social reality. Fairclough drew directly on Foucault when formulating his three-dimensional model of discourse in Language and Power (1989).
Carried by Michel Foucault; Norman Fairclough; Language and Power (1989).
Foucauldian Discourse Analysis grew out of Post-structuralism in Sociological Theory
Foucauldian discourse analysis is a branch of post-structuralist theory as received in sociology, applying Foucault's concepts of discourse and power to empirical research.
Carried by Michel Foucault.

Critical Theory is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 21 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Critical TheoryRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Cultural Studies 10 links
- Visual Culture 6 links
- Literary Theory 6 links
- Sociological Theory 6 links
- Cultural Production 5 links
- History Of Ideologies 5 links
- Political Philosophy 5 links
- Film Theory 4 links
- Literary Studies 4 links
- Continental Philosophy 4 links
- Visual Culture Studies 3 links
- Photography Theory 3 links
More in Cultural Studies
See where Critical Theory sits on the Map of Human Knowledge