Returns To Education

Returns to education is the part of economics that asks a deceptively simple question: what does a person get back from going to school?

9 frameworks, from 1960 to today · Education Economics · Economics

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Returns to education is the part of economics that asks a deceptively simple question: what does a person get back from going to school? The "return" is usually measured in money—how much more a worker earns for each additional year of schooling or for a degree—but it also includes things money does not buy directly: better health, a longer life, more stable employment, and the satisfaction of a more interesting job. The question matters because education is one of the largest investments a family or a government ever makes. If schooling reliably raises productivity and earnings, then subsidising it can be both fair and efficient1. If the extra earnings mostly reflect something else—raw talent, family connections, or a credential that merely sorts people—then the case for spending public money on it looks different1. Almost every debate in this subfield is a version of that tension.

Classical economists and the early idea of human capital

The idea that skills are a form of capital is old1. Adam Smith, in The Wealth of Nations (1776), argued that the "acquired and useful abilities" of a country's inhabitants are a real part of its capital stock, and that the cost of acquiring them is repaid with profit. For most of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, though, economists treated labour as a fairly homogeneous input and education as consumption or a public good rather than an investment. The tools to measure returns did not yet exist, and the data—large surveys linking schooling to earnings—were scarce.

The human capital revolution of the late 1950s and 1960s

The modern subfield begins with a cluster of work that turned education into an investment problem. Theodore Schultz's 1961 article "Investment in Human Capital" argued that spending on schooling, health, and training is capital formation, and that the rapid growth of economies could not be explained by physical capital and labour alone. Gary Becker's 1964 book Human Capital gave the theory its systematic form: individuals weigh the costs of schooling (tuition plus forgone earnings) against the stream of higher earnings it produces, and invest up to the point where the marginal return equals the cost of funds. Becker also distinguished general training, useful to any employer, from firm-specific training, useful only to the current one—a distinction that explained why firms pay for some training and workers for other kinds.

The empirical breakthrough came from Jacob Mincer1. His 1958 paper and especially his 1974 book Schooling, Experience, and Earnings produced what became the workhorse of the field, the Mincer earnings function: a regression of the logarithm of earnings on years of schooling and years of work experience (usually entered as a quadratic to capture the fact that earnings rise steeply early in a career and then flatten). The coefficient on schooling approximates the percentage increase in earnings from one more year of school2. In practice, researchers found returns of roughly 5 to 10 percent per year in many countries—a figure that has proved remarkably stable across decades and places. The Mincer equation's appeal was that it needed only three variables and could be estimated on any household survey, which is why it spread around the world and became the standard way to compare returns across countries.

The sorting problem: ability bias and signalling

Almost as soon as returns were being estimated, critics pointed out a flaw. People who stay in school longer differ from those who leave early in ways that also raise earnings—ability, motivation, family background. If the able both stay in school and earn more, the Mincer coefficient overstates what schooling itself does. This is ability bias, and it set the agenda for decades. Early responses tried to control for measured ability using IQ scores or sibling comparisons; the estimates typically fell but did not vanish.

A deeper challenge came from signalling theory13. Michael Spence's 1973 paper "Job Market Signaling" argued that education might raise earnings without raising productivity at all: if more able workers find it cheaper to obtain a degree, the degree can serve as a credible signal of ability to employers, who then pay more for it. In the extreme version, schooling is pure sorting. The screening hypothesis, developed by Kenneth Arrow and others around the same time, made a related point from the employer's side: firms use credentials to screen applicants, so the private return to a degree can exceed its social return. These theories did not deny that skills matter; they insisted that the observed earnings gap bundles together productivity gains and information about workers, and that the two cannot be separated by looking at earnings alone.

The credibility revolution

The decisive change came from a shift in method. From the 1990s onward, economists stopped trying to control statistically for unobserved ability and instead looked for situations where schooling changed for reasons unrelated to a person's talent—natural experiments. The approach became known as the credibility revolution, because a study's claim to causal knowledge now rested on a credible source of exogenous variation rather than on a long list of control variables4.

Several designs did the work. In the United States, Joshua Angrist and Alan Krueger (1991) used the fact that men born in different quarters were subject to different compulsory-schooling and child-labour laws, and that those born earlier in the year could leave school at a younger age; the resulting variation in schooling was used to estimate returns. In the UK, researchers exploited a 1947 school-leaving-age reform. In Indonesia, Esther Duflo (2001) used a massive school-construction programme to estimate the return to an extra year of schooling, finding returns around 7–9 percent. In the 2000s, a series of studies used changes in compulsory schooling laws across European countries—often associated with the work of Philip Oreopoulos—and consistently found returns in the range of 5 to 15 percent, with larger effects for disadvantaged students. The general finding was that the Mincer estimates were not wildly inflated: schooling does raise earnings, though the causal effect is often somewhat smaller than the naive correlation.

A parallel literature used twin studies, comparing identical twins with different amounts of schooling, to difference out family and genetic background; these too generally found positive returns, though with wide uncertainty.

The college wage premium and skill-biased technological change

While the microeconometric work was refining the return to a year of school, a macro-level puzzle emerged. From the late 1970s, the earnings gap between college graduates and high-school graduates in the United States widened sharply, even as the supply of college graduates grew. If returns were falling with supply, the premium should have narrowed. The explanation that took hold was skill-biased technological change: new technologies, especially computing, raised the demand for skilled workers faster than the education system could supply them. The canonical statement is the 1992 paper by Lawrence Katz and Kevin Murphy, "Changes in Relative Wages, 1963–1987," which showed that the college premium rose when the growth of the college-educated workforce slowed. The framework was later extended to account for the polarisation of the labour market, in which middle-skill jobs were automated away while both high-skill and low-skill service jobs grew.

This line of work tied the returns literature to the economics of inequality. If technology keeps raising the demand for skill, then the return to education depends on how many people get educated—a race between technology and schooling. It also helped explain why returns differ so much across countries and over time: they reflect the balance of supply and demand in each labour market, not a fixed law of nature.

Heterogeneity and marginal returns

A further refinement was the recognition that "the" return to education is an average that hides enormous variation. Returns differ by field of study, by institution, by gender, by family background, and by the level of schooling. The marginal return—the return to the next year of school for a particular person—is what should guide individual and policy decisions, and it can differ sharply from the average. The classic statement is the "ability bias" debate's successor: the heterogeneous returns literature associated with James Heckman and others, which used econometric models of selection to estimate returns for people at different points in the distribution. A recurring finding is that returns are often higher for those who would otherwise have dropped out—the marginal student—which strengthens the case for policies that keep disadvantaged students in school.

The local average treatment effect framework, formalised by Guido Imbens and Joshua Angrist in 1994, clarified what the natural-experiment estimates actually measure: the return for the "compliers," those whose schooling changed because of the instrument. This is a real return, but it is not necessarily the return for everyone, and interpreting it requires knowing who the compliers are.

Non-pecuniary returns

Alongside the earnings literature, a body of work has measured what schooling does beyond wages. Better-educated people report better health, live longer, are less likely to be unemployed, and are less likely to commit crimes. Some of this reflects the same selection problem—healthier people may also stay in school—but studies using the same natural experiments have found causal effects of schooling on health behaviours and on civic participation. The non-pecuniary returns matter for policy because they mean that earnings-based estimates understate the full social return to education.

The present

Today the field works with a mature toolkit. The Mincer equation remains the standard descriptive device, used to compare returns across countries and to track the college premium over time. Causal estimates from compulsory-schooling reforms, school-construction programmes, and lottery-based admissions are the benchmark for how much schooling actually raises earnings. The signalling and human-capital interpretations coexist, and a growing literature tries to separate them by looking at what employers actually learn about workers and what students actually learn in school. The heterogeneity agenda has moved to the centre: researchers now ask not whether education pays but who it pays for, at what margin, and in what field. Open questions remain about the returns to specific skills and credentials, the role of non-cognitive traits, the returns in low- and middle-income countries where data are thinner, and how automation and artificial intelligence will reshape the demand for skill in the coming decades.

References

  1. Human capital (Background, Criticism, introduction, History), Wikipedia
  2. Mincer earnings function, Wikipedia
  3. Signalling (economics), Wikipedia
  4. Credibility revolution, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Returns To Education

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1960-Present

    Human capital

    Is spending on schooling an investment in capital?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1970-Present

    Ability Bias and Selection Models

    Does schooling raise earnings or just pick able people?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1973-Present

    Signalling and Screening Theory

    Can a degree raise pay without raising skill?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1974-Present

    Mincer Earnings Function

    How much more do workers earn per year of school?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1990-Present
  6. 1990-Present

    Non-Pecuniary Returns

    What does schooling give besides higher pay?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1991-Present

    Credibility revolution

    Does schooling really cause higher earnings?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1992-Present
  9. 1994-Present

    Local Average Treatment Effect

    Whose return does an experiment actually measure?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Human capitalAbility Bias and Selection ModelsSignalling and Screening TheoryMincer Earnings FunctionHeterogeneous Returns and Marginal Re…Non-Pecuniary ReturnsCredibility revolutionSkill-Biased Technological ChangeLocal Average Treatment Effect

Beyond the field

Where Returns To Education's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 24 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Returns To Education is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 9 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Returns To Education

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Education Economics

See where Returns To Education sits on the Map of Human Knowledge