Teacher Education

Teacher education is the branch of education concerned with how teachers themselves are made: how they are recruited, what they are taught, how they are trained to teach, and how they are judged competent.

14 frameworks, from 1600 to today · Education · Social Sciences

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Teacher education is the branch of education concerned with how teachers themselves are made: how they are recruited, what they are taught, how they are trained to teach, and how they are judged competent1. It matters because almost every other educational reform passes through the teacher. A curriculum, a method, or a policy only reaches children if a teacher can carry it, and so the question of what teachers know and how they came to know it has been contested for as long as there have been schools. The history of the field is a long argument between two poles: teaching as a craft learned by imitation in the presence of a master, and teaching as a profession grounded in codified knowledge taught in institutions. Most of the story is the attempt to reconcile them.

Apprenticeship and the Craft Model

For most of human history, teachers were not trained at all. A person who could read, reckon, or play an instrument taught others by taking them on, and the learner acquired the practice by watching, copying, and being corrected. This apprenticeship model — learning a practice by working alongside someone who already performs it — was the default for scribes, artisans, and the tutors who taught the children of the wealthy. Its logic is that teaching is a craft, and crafts are transmitted through supervised practice rather than through formal instruction in a school of education. The model never disappeared. It survives in student teaching, in mentoring, and in the conviction, still voiced, that teachers are made in classrooms rather than in lecture halls1.

The Monitorial System and the Problem of Scale

The first great rupture came with mass schooling. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, as states and churches tried to educate large numbers of poor children with almost no money and few trained adults, the monitorial system emerged. Associated with the English Quakers Joseph Lancaster and the Anglican Andrew Bell, it worked by having one adult teach a body of older pupils, the monitors, who then drilled younger children in large halls. A single schoolmaster could oversee hundreds of children. The method spread internationally through missionary and philanthropic networks in the early 1800s. Its significance for teacher education is that it made the teacher's role primarily organizational: the master managed a system rather than taught individuals. It also exposed the problem that would drive the next century — that scaling up schooling required some deliberate way of preparing the people who would run it.

Normal Schools and the Invention of Teacher Training

The answer was the normal school, an institution dedicated to preparing teachers2. The name comes from the French école normale, a school that establishes a norm or model23. The first was founded in Paris in 1794–95 during the French Revolution, and the model spread across Europe and North America through the nineteenth century: state normal schools in the United States from the 1830s onward, and similar institutions in Prussia, where teacher seminaries had been established earlier. The normal school taught the elementary subjects the future teacher would teach, plus a dose of pedagogy and, characteristically, practice teaching in a model school attached to the institution. Its achievement was to make teacher preparation a public responsibility rather than a private arrangement. Its limitation was status: normal schools were usually below the university in prestige, and the knowledge they transmitted was often practical rather than theoretical.

Herbartian Pedagogy and the Science of Instruction

In the later nineteenth century, teacher education acquired its first systematic body of pedagogical theory. The German philosopher Johann Friedrich Herbart (1776–1841) had argued that instruction should proceed through defined stages that build ideas in the mind in an orderly way, and his followers formalized this into a sequence of steps — commonly presented as preparation, presentation, association, generalization, and application. Herbartianism entered teacher training worldwide, especially in the United States through the normal schools and the new university departments of education around the turn of the twentieth century. Its importance is that it gave teacher education a teachable method: a prospective teacher could be given a procedure and told to follow it. The reaction against this — the charge that it made teaching mechanical — set up much of the twentieth-century debate.

Progressive and Child-Centered Teacher Education

The progressive movement, strongest in the United States in the early twentieth century and associated above all with John Dewey, attacked the idea that teaching was the application of a fixed method45. Dewey argued that education should grow from the child's experience and inquiry, and that teachers therefore needed to understand children and subject matter deeply enough to judge situations rather than follow recipes. Progressive teacher education pushed preparation toward psychology, observation of children, and laboratory schools where practice could be studied. The tension it introduced — between training teachers in technique and educating them as reflective professionals — has never been resolved, and it recurs in nearly every later reform.

Process–Product Research and the Behavioral Turn

From the 1950s into the 1970s, a different ambition took hold: to make teacher education scientific by identifying which teacher behaviors produced which student outcomes. This was process–product research — the "process" being what the teacher does in the classroom, the "product" being student achievement — and it fed directly into competency-based teacher education, which specified teaching as a list of observable skills to be mastered and assessed. Programs were built around modules and demonstrated competencies rather than courses and credit hours. The approach was attractive because it was concrete and measurable, and it aligned with the behavioral objectives then dominant in instructional design. Its weakness was that the links between specific teacher behaviors and learning proved weaker and more context-dependent than hoped, and the movement faded in the later 1970s.

Pedagogical Content Knowledge and the Reflective Turn

Two ideas reshaped the field in the 1980s. The first was Lee Shulman's concept of pedagogical content knowledge, introduced in 1986: the special understanding a teacher needs of how a particular subject is learned and taught — knowing, for instance, the misconceptions students bring to fractions or the analogies that make them click6. This distinguished the teacher's knowledge from the subject specialist's, and it gave teacher education a defensible intellectual core. The second was reflective practice, drawing on Donald Schön's work on how professionals think in action7. Schön argued that competent practitioners reflect on their practice while doing it, and teacher education took this up as a mandate to produce teachers who examine their own teaching rather than merely execute techniques. Together these ideas moved preparation away from behavior lists and toward the development of professional judgment.

Professionalization, Standards, and the Accountability Regime

The later twentieth century saw teacher education pressed toward professionalization: raising entry requirements, extending preparation, and creating institutions that joined universities with schools. The professional development school, modeled on the teaching hospital, placed trainee teachers in partnership schools where university and school faculty shared responsibility for preparation. Running alongside this was a countervailing movement of standards and accountability. From the 1980s onward, governments increasingly set explicit standards for what teachers should know and be able to do, tied program accreditation and teacher licensing to them, and used test scores and evaluation systems to judge teachers and, by extension, the programs that prepared them. The two impulses — professional autonomy and external accountability — coexist uneasily today.

Alternative Routes and School-Based Preparation

Dissatisfaction with university-based preparation produced a parallel tradition. Alternative certification routes, expanding from the 1980s, allowed graduates to enter teaching through shortened programs, often while working in schools, and school-based preparation shifted more of the training into the workplace itself. These routes claimed to attract capable people who would not enroll in conventional programs and to ground preparation in real classrooms. Critics argued they shortened the theoretical grounding and pedagogical judgment that the profession required. The debate is unresolved, and most systems now run conventional and alternative routes side by side.

Practice-Based Teacher Education and Self-Study

In recent decades the field has turned back toward practice, but with a difference from the old craft model. Practice-based teacher education does not simply apprentice novices to a classroom; it decomposes teaching into named practices — leading a discussion, eliciting student thinking, modeling — that can be taught, rehearsed, and analyzed before being performed with children. At the same time, the self-study of teacher education practices emerged as a research tradition in which teacher educators systematically study their own practice, treating their own teaching of teachers as an object of inquiry. Both developments reflect a field that has stopped assuming its methods work and begun to examine them.

Comparative and International Teacher Education

Finally, teacher education has become a global policy field. Comparative studies of how different countries recruit, prepare, and retain teachers — and of why some systems produce consistently strong teaching — now inform reform everywhere, and international organizations track teacher supply and quality across nations. The field's central open questions remain the ones its history keeps returning to: how much of teaching can be codified and taught, how much must be learned in practice, and how to prepare teachers who are both competent in technique and capable of judgment.

References

  1. Teacher education (introduction, Supervised field experiences, Induction of beginning teachers), Wikipedia
  2. Normal school, Wikipedia
  3. List of normal schools in the Philippines, Wikipedia
  4. Herbartianism, Wikipedia
  5. John Dewey, Wikipedia
  6. Lee Shulman (Pedagogical content knowledge), Wikipedia
  7. Reflective practice (History and background), Wikipedia

The frameworks of Teacher Education

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1600-Present
  2. 1790-1850
  3. 1794-1950
  4. 1860-1910
  5. 1900-1950
  6. 1950-1978
  7. 1983-Present
  8. 1983-Present
  9. 1983-Present
  10. 1986-Present
  11. 1986-Present
  12. 1990-Present
  13. 1995-Present
  14. 2005-Present

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Apprenticeship and the Craft ModelMonitorial SystemNormal schoolHerbartianismProgressive educationProcess–Product Research and Competen…Alternative teacher certificationReflective PracticeStandards and Accountability RegimePedagogical Content KnowledgeProfessional Development SchoolSelf-Study of Teacher Education Pract…Comparative and International Teacher…Practice-Based Teacher Education

Beyond the field

Where Teacher Education's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 39 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Teacher Education is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 14 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Teacher Education

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Education

See where Teacher Education sits on the Map of Human Knowledge