- Atlas
- Natural Sciences
- Natural Resource Management
Natural Resource Management
Natural resource management is the practice of deciding who may use the living and material wealth of the land and water—timber, fish, game, forage, soil, water, minerals—and how much of it may be taken without destroying the source.
16 frameworks, from 1750 to today · Environmental Science · Natural Sciences
- Sustained-Yield Forestry 1750-1970
- Progressive Conservation 1890-1960
- Large-Scale Water Development 1902-1980
- Maximum Sustainable Yield 1930-Present
- Wildlife management 1933-1980
- Soil and Water Conservation 1935-Present
- Land Ethic 1949-Present
- Tragedy of the Commons 1968-Present
- Environmental Impact Assessment 1969-Present
- Ecological resilience 1973-Present
- Adaptive Management 1978-Present
- Community-based management 1980-Present
- Geospatial and Model-Based Assessment 1980-Present
- Sustainable Development 1987-Present
- Ecosystem-Based Management 1990-Present
- Governing the Commons 1990-Present
Overview
Natural resource management is the practice of deciding who may use the living and material wealth of the land and water—timber, fish, game, forage, soil, water, minerals—and how much of it may be taken without destroying the source1. Its central problem is that most of these resources are shared: a forest, a fishery, or an aquifer serves many users at once, and each user's private incentive to take more collides with everyone's long-term interest in leaving enough behind. The field's history is a long argument about how to resolve that collision—through science, through law, through markets, through communities, or through some combination—and about what "enough" even means when the resource itself keeps changing.
Early State Forestry and the Idea of Sustained Yield
Systematic management of natural resources emerged in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries alongside the centralized state. European rulers, dependent on timber for shipbuilding, fuel, and construction, faced the problem of forests being cut faster than they regrew. The response was the science of forestry, developed most influentially in German-speaking lands. Its core concept was sustained yield: the principle that a forest should be harvested no faster than it grows, so that the annual cut can continue indefinitely23. Foresters divided woods into compartments, measured growth, and scheduled harvests on rotations—sometimes over a century long—so that each year's felling matched each year's increment.
This was a genuine intellectual achievement: it turned a forest into a measurable, budgetable system. But it also narrowed the forest to its timber. Sustained-yield forestry typically favored single, commercially valuable species planted in even-aged stands, and it treated everything else—understory plants, dead wood, wildlife, water yield—as incidental. The approach spread worldwide through colonial forest services, which imposed German-style management on Indian, Southeast Asian, African, and North American forests, often overriding local uses that had sustained those landscapes for generations.
Progressive Conservation and the Gospel of Efficiency
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a broader movement took shape, especially in the United States, that came to be called progressive conservation. Its leading figure was Gifford Pinchot, the first chief of the U.S. Forest Service, who framed conservation as "the greatest good of the greatest number for the longest time." The movement's logic was that resources should be developed efficiently and scientifically under expert state control, rather than exploited by private interests or locked away untouched.
The great contest of this era was over water and land in the American West. John Wesley Powell had argued as early as the 1870s that the arid West could not be settled on the humid-East model of small farms and should be organized by watershed. The Reclamation Act of 1902 instead launched large-scale water development: federal dams, canals, and irrigation projects that would, in the era's phrase, "make the desert bloom." The same decades saw the great dams of the twentieth century—Hoover, Grand Coulee, and later the Aswan High Dam and the dams of the Tennessee Valley Authority—built on the conviction that engineering could master rivers for irrigation, hydropower, flood control, and navigation. These projects delivered real benefits and also produced the field's classic failures: salinized soils, displaced communities, silted reservoirs, and rivers cut off from their floodplains.
The Birth of Game Management and Wildlife Science
A parallel strand concerned living resources that move. In North America, unregulated market hunting had driven species such as the passenger pigeon to extinction and reduced deer, turkey, and waterfowl to remnants. The turning point was the work of Aldo Leopold, a forester turned wildlife scientist, whose 1933 textbook Game Management founded the field. Leopold's insight was that wildlife could be managed like a crop—by manipulating habitat, controlling harvest through seasons and bag limits, and understanding population dynamics—rather than merely by protecting animals from hunters.
Leopold later moved beyond this production model. In A Sand County Almanac (1949), published shortly after his death, he argued for a "land ethic": that people should treat the whole community of soils, waters, plants, and animals as something owed respect, not merely as a stock to be harvested. This shift—from game as a yield to ecosystems as a moral and ecological whole—prefigured much of the field's later development.
Soil and Water Conservation After the Dust Bowl
The 1930s brought a hard lesson in what happens when land management fails. The Dust Bowl on the North American southern plains—caused by plowing fragile grassland during drought—blew millions of tons of topsoil away and displaced hundreds of thousands of people. The response institutionalized soil and water conservation: contour plowing, terracing, shelterbelts, check dams, and the creation of the U.S. Soil Conservation Service in 1935 under Hugh Hammond Bennett. Similar programs followed worldwide. The lesson was that resource management had to address the working landscape of farms and ranches, not only forests and parks, and that erosion was a slow catastrophe that could be measured and fought.
Maximum Sustainable Yield and the Fisheries Problem
After the Second World War, resource management became increasingly quantitative. The most influential idea was maximum sustainable yield (MSY): the notion, drawn from population biology, that a harvested population grows fastest at some intermediate size, so there is a harvest level that yields the largest catch year after year without depleting the stock4. The concept was formalized in fisheries science in the 1930s and 1950s and was written into international fisheries law in the 1980s4.
MSY was elegant and it was widely adopted—and it repeatedly failed in practice. Real fish populations fluctuate with ocean conditions, are hard to measure, and are caught by fleets with political weight. Setting a single "maximum" target left no margin for error, and the target was routinely exceeded. The concept's troubles taught the field that a number computed from a model is only as good as the model's assumptions and the institutions that enforce it.
The Tragedy of the Commons and Its Critics
In 1968, the biologist Garrett Hardin published "The Tragedy of the Commons," arguing that when a resource is open to all, each user gains by taking more while the cost of depletion is shared, so rational users will inevitably overexploit it. The essay became one of the most cited in the field and shaped a generation of policy: the presumed cure was either privatization or state regulation.
The essay's central claim was then challenged by empirical work. The political economist Elinor Ostrom, studying irrigation systems, forests, and fisheries around the world, documented many communities that had governed shared resources successfully for centuries through their own rules—boundaries, monitoring, graduated sanctions, and conflict-resolution mechanisms. Her 1990 book Governing the Commons showed that neither the market nor the state was the only answer, and that self-governance could work under identifiable conditions. Ostrom received the Nobel Prize in economics in 20095. The debate reframed the field's central question from "who owns it?" to "what institutions make shared use sustainable?"
Environmental Impact Assessment and the Rise of Sustainable Development
The 1960s and 1970s brought environmental law and a demand for foresight. The U.S. National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 required federal agencies to prepare environmental impact assessments (EIAs)—systematic statements of a project's likely environmental effects, alternatives, and mitigations—before acting. The model spread to most countries and to international lenders. EIA institutionalized the practice of predicting harm before it happened, though critics noted that assessments were often done late, by consultants paid by project sponsors, and that predicted impacts were rarely checked against actual ones.
In 1987 the Brundtland Commission's report Our Common Future popularized sustainable development: development that meets present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet theirs. The phrase reconciled the development ambitions of poorer nations with the environmental concerns of richer ones, and it became the organizing frame for international resource policy—enshrined at the 1992 Rio Earth Summit and later in the Sustainable Development Goals. Its breadth was both its strength and its weakness: it could mean almost anything, and critics charged that it often meant business as usual with better language.
Ecosystem-Based Management, Resilience, and Adaptive Management
By the 1990s, the field had learned that managing single resources in isolation—one species, one timber type, one water use—created new problems elsewhere. Ecosystem-based management emerged as the response: manage the whole system, including its human users, across its full range, rather than piece by piece6. It drew on ecology's recognition that ecosystems are connected, dynamic, and often unpredictable.
Two related ideas reshaped practice. Resilience, developed by the ecologist C. S. Holling in the 1970s, described an ecosystem's capacity to absorb disturbance and still retain its basic structure—and warned that highly optimized, tightly managed systems can be brittle. Adaptive management, articulated by Holling and Carl Walters, proposed treating management as an experiment: act, monitor, learn, and adjust7. The approach was intellectually compelling but hard to sustain, because it requires institutions willing to admit uncertainty and revise course—qualities rare in agencies built around fixed mandates.
Geospatial and Model-Based Assessment
The late twentieth century also transformed how resources were measured. Satellite remote sensing, geographic information systems, and computer models allowed managers to map land cover, track deforestation, estimate biomass, and simulate water flows and fish stocks at scales no field survey could reach. These tools made possible global assessments of forest loss, agricultural productivity, and groundwater depletion. They also introduced a new dependence: on models whose uncertainties are often invisible to the people using their outputs.
Community-Based Management and the Return of the Local
Alongside these technical developments, a countercurrent emphasized local control. Community-based natural resource management (CBNRM) held that people who live with a resource have both the knowledge and the incentive to manage it well, if given secure rights and a share of the benefits. Programs in southern Africa that devolved wildlife management to communities, and joint forest management arrangements in South Asia, were prominent experiments. Results were mixed: some succeeded in building local stewardship and income, while others were captured by elites or undermined by weak tenure. The approach nonetheless shifted the field's default assumption—from the expert state as sole manager toward plural, negotiated arrangements.
The Present: Integration, Uncertainty, and Unfinished Questions
Today's natural resource management draws on all of these strands at once. Practitioners routinely combine quantitative stock assessment with ecosystem-level modeling, satellite monitoring, and institutional design; they work through impact assessment, adaptive management plans, and community agreements, often in the same project. The field's dominant frameworks—ecosystem-based management, resilience thinking, and the governance lessons of Ostrom—descend directly from the debates above.
The open questions are the old ones in new form. How should management cope with climate change, which makes historical baselines unreliable and pushes ecosystems into states with no precedent? How can the interests of distant beneficiaries and future generations be represented in decisions made by present users? And how much of the field's confidence in measurement and modeling survives when the systems being measured are changing faster than the models can be updated? These remain live arguments, and the history of the field is largely the record of how each generation has answered them—and been corrected.
References
- Natural resource management, Wikipedia
- Sustainable yield, Wikipedia
- Sustainable development (Development of the concept), Wikipedia
- Maximum sustainable yield (introduction, History), Wikipedia
- Elinor Ostrom, Wikipedia
- Ecosystem-based management, Wikipedia
- Adaptive management (History), Wikipedia
The frameworks of Natural Resource Management
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1750-1970
- 1890-1960
Progressive Conservation
How should experts develop resources for the public good?
- 1902-1980
Large-Scale Water Development
Can engineering make arid rivers serve farms and cities?
- 1930-Present
Maximum Sustainable Yield
What harvest gives the largest catch year after year?
- 1933-1980
Wildlife management
How can wild animal populations be harvested sustainably?
- 1935-Present
Soil and Water Conservation
How can farms be kept from washing or blowing away?
- 1949-Present
- 1968-Present
- 1969-Present
Environmental Impact Assessment
How can we predict a project's environmental harm beforehand?
- 1973-Present
Ecological resilience
Why do ecosystems sometimes not return to balance?
- 1978-Present
Adaptive Management
How should we manage resources when we cannot predict them?
- 1980-Present
Community-based management
Can local users govern their own shared resources?
- 1980-Present
Geospatial and Model-Based Assessment
How can maps and models guide resource decisions?
- 1987-Present
Sustainable Development
How can development meet present needs without ruining the future?
- 1990-Present
Ecosystem-Based Management
How should whole ecosystems, not single species, be managed?
- 1990-Present
Governing the Commons
What rules let communities share resources without ruin?
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Land Ethic grew out of Wildlife management
Leopold's own shift from managing game as a harvestable crop to treating the whole land community as morally considerable produced the land ethic, published in A Sand County Almanac. The land ethic grew directly out of his earlier wildlife-management work.
Carried by Aldo Leopold; A Sand County Almanac (1949).
Governing the Commons reacted against Tragedy of the Commons
Ostrom's Governing the Commons was written as a direct empirical rebuttal to Hardin's claim that shared resources must be privatized or state-regulated; she documented communities that governed commons successfully by their own rules.
Carried by Elinor Ostrom; Governing the Commons (1990).
Adaptive Management grew out of Ecological resilience
Adaptive management grew out of C.S. Holling's resilience work: if ecosystems do not return to a single equilibrium, management must be treated as an experiment whose results are monitored and fed back into policy.
Carried by C. S. Holling.
Progressive Conservation influenced by Sustained-Yield Forestry
German sustained-yield forestry, taught at schools like those Pinchot attended, supplied progressive conservation with its core method: expert-managed, scientifically scheduled harvest of state forests for continuous public yield. Pinchot carried this forestry training directly into the U.S. Forest Service.
Carried by Gifford Pinchot.
Maximum Sustainable Yield influenced by Sustained-Yield Forestry
Maximum sustainable yield generalized the sustained-yield principle from forestry to harvested animal populations: take no more than the stock regenerates. Fisheries scientists formalized the idea in population-biology terms in the 1930s.
Wildlife management influenced by Progressive Conservation
Leopold was trained as a forester in the Pinchot tradition of scientific, state-managed resource use, and his game management applied that conservationist production logic to wildlife. His career began in the U.S. Forest Service before he moved to game research.
Carried by Aldo Leopold; Game Management (1933).
Environmental Impact Assessment influenced by Large-Scale Water Development
Environmental impact assessment arose partly in response to the environmental damage of large dams and federal development projects, requiring prediction of such harms before approval.
Carried by National Environmental Policy Act (1969).
Adaptive Management reacted against Maximum Sustainable Yield
Adaptive management defined itself against single-target policies such as maximum sustainable yield, insisting that uncertain stocks require probing, monitored harvests rather than a fixed optimum.
Carried by C. S. Holling.
Community-based management influenced by Tragedy of the Commons
The tragedy-of-the-commons debate set the question community-based management answered: whether local user groups can avoid overexploitation through their own institutions rather than external regulation.
Carried by Elinor Ostrom.
Ecosystem-Based Management influenced by Ecological resilience
Ecological resilience supplied ecosystem-based management with its rationale for managing whole systems and their disturbance regimes rather than single species or yields.
Carried by C. S. Holling.
Ecosystem-Based Management influenced by Adaptive Management
Adaptive management's iterative, monitored, experimental approach became a standard operating component of ecosystem-based management plans for large landscapes and marine systems.
Ecosystem-Based Management influenced by Land Ethic
Leopold's land ethic, treating soils, waters, plants and animals as one community owed respect, supplied moral grounding for later calls to manage whole ecosystems rather than single resources.
Carried by Aldo Leopold.
Sustainable Development influenced by Environmental Impact Assessment
Environmental impact assessment institutionalized systematic prediction of a project's environmental effects, a practice the sustainable-development framework absorbed into project and policy appraisal.
Ecosystem-Based Management influenced by Geospatial and Model-Based Assessment
Geospatial and model-based assessment tools gave ecosystem-based management the mapping and modeling capacity to define ecosystem boundaries and simulate whole-system outcomes.
Beyond the field
Where Natural Resource Management's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 126 links.
Sustained-Yield Forestry led to Multiple-Use Management in Forestry
Multiple-use management grew out of sustained-yield forestry by extending the perpetual-yield principle from timber to forage, water and recreation.
Sustained-Yield Forestry influenced Colonial State Forestry in Forest Management
Sustained-yield forestry was the doctrine colonial forest services imported: European-trained foresters applied the allowable-cut principle to colonial reserves, making sustained yield the governing aim of colonial state forestry.
Sustained-Yield Forestry led to Multiple-Use Management in Forest Economics
Multiple-use management grew directly out of sustained-yield forestry, extending its single-product yield regulation to a set of outputs; the sustained-yield statutes and the Multiple-Use Sustained-Yield Act of 1960 carried the transition.
Carried by Multiple-Use Sustained-Yield Act (1960).
Sustained-Yield Forestry influenced Utilitarian Conservation in Forestry
Utilitarian conservation took sustained-yield forestry as its model, extending the principle of perpetual yield from timber to water, soil and range resources.
Carried by Gifford Pinchot.
Sustained-Yield Forestry replaced by Criteria and indicators of sustainable forest management in Forest Management
Criteria and indicators replaced sustained-yield forestry as the working definition of forest sustainability, keeping yield as one criterion among ecological and social ones.
Maximum Sustainable Yield influenced by Population dynamics of fisheries in Marine Biology
Population dynamics of fisheries, especially the logistic growth and surplus-production models, provided the mathematical basis for computing maximum sustainable yield.
Tragedy of the Commons provoked Property Rights and Individual Transferable Quotas in Resource Economics
Hardin's tragedy-of-the-commons essay framed open access as requiring either privatisation or state control, and ITQ schemes were advanced as the privatisation answer. The quota literature is a direct response to Hardin's diagnosis.
Carried by Garrett Hardin.
Tragedy of the Commons provoked Governing the Commons in Public Goods Theory
Governing the Commons defined itself against Hardin's 1968 tragedy of the commons, arguing that self-governance can avert the predicted overuse.
Carried by Elinor Ostrom; Garrett Hardin.
Environmental Impact Assessment led to Strategic Environmental Assessment in Environmental Risk Assessment
Strategic environmental assessment is a tier of environmental impact assessment, developed by applying EIA methods to plans and programmes rather than single projects. The NEPA-era EIA framework supplied the procedural model that SEA practitioners generalised upward.
Carried by National Environmental Policy Act (1970).
Environmental Impact Assessment influenced Social Impact Assessment in Environmental Assessment
Social impact assessment arose as an extension of environmental impact assessment under the US National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, which mandated consideration of social as well as biophysical effects. Resource-management agencies adopted SIA within their EIA procedures.
Carried by National Environmental Policy Act (1969).
Environmental Impact Assessment led to Cumulative effects in Environmental Assessment
Cumulative effects assessment developed as a refinement of environmental impact assessment under the US National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, extending its project-level review to combined effects across projects and time. Resource-management agencies adopted it within EIA procedures.
Carried by National Environmental Policy Act (1969).
Ecological resilience influenced Resilience Engineering in Reliability Engineering
Ecological resilience, introduced by C. S. Holling in 1973, supplied the core distinction between resilience and stability that resilience engineering took up and applied to engineered and socio-technical systems.
Carried by C. S. Holling.

Natural Resource Management is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 16 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Natural Resource ManagementRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Forestry 10 links
- Restoration Ecology 9 links
- Forest Management 9 links
- Resource Economics 6 links
- Biodiversity And Conservation Law 6 links
- Environmental Assessment 5 links
- History Of Conservation 5 links
- Environmental Science 5 links
- Silviculture 5 links
- Conservation Biology 4 links
- Soil Conservation 4 links
- Irrigation Management 3 links
More in Environmental Science
- Biogeochemistry
- Conservation Biology
- Earth System Science
- Ecosystem Science
- Environmental Chemistry
- Environmental Risk Assessment
- Environmental Science
- Environmental Toxicology
- Restoration Ecology
- Sustainability Science
See where Natural Resource Management sits on the Map of Human Knowledge