Serious Games And Gamification
Serious games are games made for a purpose beyond entertainment—training, teaching, persuading, healing, planning.
13 frameworks, from 1824 to today · Game Studies & Design · Games
- Kriegsspiel and Wargaming 1824-Present
- Classroom Simulation Games 1960-Present
- Policy games 1960-1985
- Simulation-Gaming 1960-Present
- Educational entertainment 1980-2000
- Modelling and simulation for training 1990-Present
- Game-Based Learning 2000-Present
- Serious Games Movement 2002-Present
- Critical Serious Games 2010-Present
- Evidence-based serious games 2010-Present
- Gamification 2010-Present
- Pointsification Critique 2010-Present
- Serious Games Evaluation 2010-Present
Overview
Serious games are games made for a purpose beyond entertainment—training, teaching, persuading, healing, planning1. Gamification is the related but distinct practice of borrowing game elements (points, badges, leaderboards, challenges, feedback loops) and applying them to activities that are not games2. The two are often discussed together because they share a question: can the mechanics of play be turned toward work, learning, and civic life without losing what makes play worth doing? That question is older than either term. Its history runs from nineteenth-century Prussian war games through Cold War simulation, the edutainment boom and bust, the corporate "gamification" wave of the 2010s, and today's evidence-minded, sometimes critical, design research.
War Games and the Birth of Simulation Training
The deepest root is the Kriegsspiel, a Prussian military training game developed in the early nineteenth century34. Its most influential version was published in 1824 by Georg von Reisswitz, a Prussian artillery officer, building on his father's earlier design. Units were represented by blocks on a map at a fixed scale, moved on a gridded terrain, with dice and a rulebook adjudicating combat. The problem it solved was concrete: officers could practice decision-making and staff coordination without the cost and risk of live maneuvers. The game spread through European armies, and its descendants—rigid and "free" Kriegsspiel variants, then the map-and-counter wargames of the twentieth century—established the core idea that a game could be a model of a real situation, run to learn something about it.
That idea matured into professional simulation. Mid-twentieth-century military and aviation training built increasingly elaborate simulators, and the Cold War brought systems thinking into the mix: the RAND Corporation and similar institutions used game-like exercises to explore strategy and policy. "Policy games" and "simulation-gaming" became a recognizable practice in the 1960s and 1970s, used in government, business schools, and international relations. The key move was to treat a game as a model—a simplified, manipulable representation of a system—so that players could experience consequences and test decisions. The American management scholar Richard Duke's Gaming: The Future's Language (1974) argued that games were a serious communication medium for complex planning, not a toy.
Simulation-Gaming in Education and the Edutainment Boom
From the 1960s onward, educators adapted these techniques. Classroom simulation games had players take roles in historical, civic, or economic scenarios—a mock United Nations, a trading game, a city-planning exercise—and learn by inhabiting a system rather than memorizing facts. The field's own journal, Simulation & Gaming, was founded in 1970, a sign that practitioners saw themselves as a community with methods to debate. The underlying claim was that direct experience of a dynamic system produces learning that lectures cannot.
The arrival of cheap personal computers in the late 1970s and 1980s shifted the center of gravity. "Edutainment" named the hope that education and entertainment could be fused in software. The 1980s and 1990s produced landmark products: The Oregon Trail (originally developed in 1971 and widely distributed in schools from the 1980s), Where in the World Is Carmen Sandiego? (1985), and SimCity (1989), which many teachers used to teach urban systems despite being designed as entertainment. The problem these products exposed was that fun and learning did not automatically reinforce each other; a game could be engaging and teach little, or teach well and bore. The edutainment label also acquired a reputation for low production values and thin pedagogy, and by the late 1990s the commercial market had cooled.
The Serious Games Movement and the Serious Games Initiative
The modern term "serious games" is usually traced to Clark Abt's book Serious Games (1970), but it was relaunched as a movement around 2002, when Ben Sawyer and David Rejeski founded the Serious Games Initiative at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington. The initiative's purpose was to connect the games industry with government, education, health, and defense buyers, and to argue that games were a serious medium for serious problems. The timing mattered: military training was investing heavily in game-based simulation, and the U.S. Army's America's Army (released 2002) became a famous—and contested—example of a game serving recruitment and training goals.
The movement's practitioners built a recognizable repertoire: games for health and rehabilitation, for corporate and military training, for civic engagement and social change, and for science communication. The field's flagship conference, the Serious Games Summit, began in 2004, and academic programs and journals followed. The central design problem was stated early and never fully solved: how to make a game that is genuinely a game—with meaningful choices, feedback, and goals—while reliably delivering the intended learning or behavioral outcome.
Gamification and the Pointsification Critique
Around 2010 the vocabulary shifted again. "Gamification" was popularized by the designer Nick Pelling (who coined it around 2002) and then by industry evangelists; the analyst Gartner's mid-2010s hype cycle made it a boardroom word. The promise was that adding game elements to non-game contexts—fitness apps, workplace productivity tools, loyalty programs, education platforms—would boost engagement. Early implementations leaned heavily on points, badges, and leaderboards, sometimes called the "PBL" triad.
This drew a sharp critique, often labeled "pointsification": the argument that stripping games down to extrinsic rewards captures the shell of games while discarding what makes them motivating—voluntary participation, meaningful challenge, autonomy, and the pleasure of play itself. The critique drew on a longer psychological literature on motivation, especially the distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation associated with Edward Deci and Richard Ryan's self-determination theory5. The practical lesson was that reward systems can crowd out genuine interest, and that "gamifying" a task is not the same as designing a good game. The critique reshaped the field: later gamification research and practice moved toward user-centered design, motivational psychology, and context-sensitive frameworks rather than one-size-fits-all reward layers.
Evidence, Evaluation, and the Present
The most consequential recent turn is toward evidence. Early serious-games claims rested on enthusiasm and case studies; the field increasingly demanded rigorous evaluation—controlled studies, validated learning measures, and attention to whether gains transfer outside the game. Researchers have built frameworks for evaluating serious games and for matching game mechanics to learning objectives, and the literature now includes systematic reviews and meta-analyses of educational and health games, with mixed but informative results. The field has also absorbed lessons from game studies: that players are not passive recipients of a designed message, and that a game's meaning emerges from play, not just from its rules.
Today the main approaches coexist. Simulation and training games remain strong in defense, medicine, and aviation, where fidelity and measurable outcomes matter. Game-based learning is a mature research area in education, with attention to curriculum integration and assessment. Gamification persists in industry and health behavior change, now usually framed through motivational theory rather than points. Alongside these sits a critical strand that asks who serious games serve, what values they encode, and whether "serious" and "game" are ever fully reconciled. The open questions are the ones the history keeps returning to: how to demonstrate that a game teaches or changes behavior, how to design for intrinsic motivation rather than against it, and how to tell when a game is the right tool at all.
References
- Serious game, Wikipedia
- Gamification, Wikipedia
- Kriegsspiel, Wikipedia
- Military exercise (History), Wikipedia
- Self-determination theory, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Serious Games And Gamification
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1824-Present
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming
How can a game model a real military situation?
- 1960-Present
Classroom Simulation Games
Can role-play in a simulated system teach better than lectures?
- 1960-1985
- 1960-Present
- 1980-2000
- 1990-Present
Modelling and simulation for training
How can simulation faithfully train real-world performance?
- 2000-Present
Game-Based Learning
How can games be integrated into curricula to teach?
- 2002-Present
Serious Games Movement
Can games be a serious medium for serious problems?
- 2010-Present
- 2010-Present
Evidence-based serious games
Do serious games actually teach or change behavior?
- 2010-Present
- 2010-Present
Pointsification Critique
Do points and badges destroy genuine motivation?
- 2010-Present
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Pointsification Critique reacted against Gamification
The pointsification critique arose directly against early gamification's points-badges-leaderboards implementations, arguing they capture the shell of games while discarding voluntary participation, meaningful challenge and intrinsic motivation.
Classroom Simulation Games grew out of Kriegsspiel and Wargaming
Classroom simulation games adapted the Kriegsspiel idea of a rule-governed model of a real situation in which players make decisions and see consequences, transferring it from military staff training to civic, historical and economic scenarios.
Carried by Simulation & Gaming (1970).
Policy games influenced by Kriegsspiel and Wargaming
Cold War policy games at RAND and similar institutions took the wargame's method of modeling a strategic situation as a playable system so decision-makers could test choices, applying it to government and international relations.
Simulation-Gaming grew out of Kriegsspiel and Wargaming
Simulation-gaming generalized the Kriegsspiel premise that a game is a manipulable model of a system, extending it from military map exercises to business schools, planning and education.
Carried by Richard Duke.
Educational entertainment influenced by Classroom Simulation Games
The edutainment boom carried the classroom simulation game's claim that direct experience of a dynamic system teaches better than lectures into consumer software, as in The Oregon Trail and SimCity used in schools.
Carried by The Oregon Trail; SimCity (1989).
Game-Based Learning grew out of Simulation-Gaming
Game-based learning grew out of the simulation-gaming tradition's core claim that games model systems and produce learning through play, reframing it for digital educational games and curriculum research.
Serious Games Movement revived Simulation-Gaming
The Serious Games Initiative relaunched Clark Abt's 1970 term and the simulation-gaming tradition's premise that games are a serious medium, connecting it to the games industry and government, health and defense buyers.
Carried by Ben Sawyer; David Rejeski; Serious Games Initiative (2002).
Game-Based Learning reacted against Educational entertainment
Game-based learning defined itself partly against edutainment's reputation for thin pedagogy and low production values, insisting on curriculum integration and measurable learning rather than fun as a delivery vehicle.
Serious Games Movement influenced by Modelling and simulation for training
Heavy military investment in game-based simulation training in the early 2000s, exemplified by America's Army, gave the serious games movement its flagship cases and its argument that games are serious training tools.
Carried by America's Army (2002).
Critical Serious Games reacted against Serious Games Movement
Critical serious games arose as an attack on the movement's instrumental framing, asking who serious games serve and what values they encode rather than assuming a game reliably delivers a designed message.
Evidence-based serious games reacted against Serious Games Movement
The evidence-based turn defined itself against the movement's early reliance on enthusiasm and case studies, demanding controlled studies and validated learning measures for serious games.
Simulation-Gaming rival of Policy games
Policy games and simulation-gaming emerged together in the 1960s as overlapping but competing practices for using game models in government and management training, with different emphases on strategy versus experiential learning.
Serious Games Movement rival of Game-Based Learning
Game-based learning and the serious games movement arose as overlapping contemporaries, one anchored in education research and the other in industry and institutional buyers, competing to frame how games serve learning and training.
Gamification influenced by Serious Games Movement
The serious games movement's success in arguing that game elements belong in non-game contexts helped prepare the ground for the corporate gamification wave, which borrowed its vocabulary of applying games to work and learning.
Beyond the field
Where Serious Games And Gamification's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 54 links.
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to Hex-and-counter wargaming in Turn Based Strategy
Commercial hex-and-counter wargaming grew directly out of the nineteenth-century Prussian Kriegsspiel tradition of map-based conflict simulation, which supplied the idea of resolving combat on a gridded map with pieces and rules. Charles Roberts's Tactics (1954) and the Avalon Hill line carried that inheritance into the hobby market.
Carried by Charles S. Roberts; Tactics (1954).
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to Wargame and Simulation Design Tradition in Game Design
The professional wargame and simulation design tradition descends from Kriegsspiel: its conventions of hidden information, umpires and after-action review were carried into twentieth-century military and commercial simulation design.
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to Board wargame in History Of Board Games
The hobby board wargame grew out of the Kriegsspiel-derived wargaming tradition that professional and amateur designers carried into the twentieth century; Roberts's Tactics and Avalon Hill commercialised that lineage.
Carried by Charles S. Roberts; Tactics (1954).
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to Simulation and wargame modeling in Game Studies
Modern simulation and wargame modeling grew directly out of nineteenth-century Kriegsspiel practice, keeping its map-and-counter apparatus and umpired adjudication while adding operations-research methods after the Second World War.
Carried by Kriegsspiel (1824).
Game-Based Learning grew out of Educational game in Game Design
Game-based learning grew directly out of the educational-game tradition of the 1970s onward, keeping its core premise that a game can be designed to teach. Later work in the field reframed and generalised that tradition under the new label rather than replacing it.
Serious Games Movement grew out of Educational game in Game Design
The serious games movement took the educational game tradition and broadened it beyond schooling to training, health and policy, adopting its assumption that games can serve non-entertainment purposes. The 2002 Serious Games Initiative framed this wider programme on that earlier base.
Carried by Serious Games Initiative (2002).
Critical Serious Games grew out of Cultural and critical game studies in Game Studies
Critical serious games grew out of cultural and critical game studies, taking its tools for reading games as ideological artefacts and applying them to games made for learning, health and persuasion. The later work turns the critical apparatus of game studies onto the serious games movement itself.
Gamification influenced by Player Psychology and Motivation Design in Game Design
Gamification's core claim, that game elements can be transplanted to non-game contexts to motivate behaviour, rests on player psychology and motivation design, particularly self-determination theory and flow. Proponents cited this motivational research to justify points, badges and feedback loops.
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming provoked Critical wargaming in Wargames
Critical wargaming takes the Kriegsspiel and wargaming tradition as its object of critique, examining how its assumptions about conflict, command and modelling shape what players learn.
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to SSI hex wargames in Turn Based Strategy
SSI's wargames belong to the Kriegsspiel-derived wargaming tradition, taking its model of resolving conflict on a map with rules and pieces and moving it to the computer. The lineage runs from Prussian military simulation through hobby board wargames to SSI's software.
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming influenced Adventure and Puzzle Design in Game Design
The wargaming tradition supplied the referee, map and scenario apparatus that early adventure game design adapted; Dungeons & Dragons emerged from the Chainmail wargame circle and kept the referee-run scenario structure.
Carried by Gary Gygax; Dave Arneson; Chainmail (1971).
Kriegsspiel and Wargaming led to Board wargame in Modern Board Games
The serious-games account of Kriegsspiel and the board wargame share the same descent: nineteenth-century Prussian officer training by simulated battle passed through the miniature wargaming hobby into Avalon Hill's 1954 board games. The board wargame carried Kriegsspiel's assumption that a game can model conflict for instruction and analysis.
Carried by Charles S. Roberts; Avalon Hill.

Serious Games And Gamification is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Serious Games And GamificationRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Game Design 19 links
- Game Studies 15 links
- Wargames 6 links
- History Of Board Games 3 links
- Educational Technology 2 links
- Public Policy 2 links
- Turn Based Strategy 2 links
- Health Communication 1 link
- Education 1 link
- Esports Performance 1 link
- Applied Mathematics 1 link
- Modern Board Games 1 link
More in Game Studies & Design
See where Serious Games And Gamification sits on the Map of Human Knowledge