- Atlas
- Business, Management & Finance
- Human Resources
Human Resources
Human resources is the part of management concerned with the people who work in an organization: how they are hired, paid, trained, organized, disciplined, and let go, and how their interests are balanced against the organization's.
13 frameworks, from 1880 to today · Human Resources · Business, Management & Finance
- Welfare Work 1880-1930
- Scientific Management 1900-1950
- Personnel Administration 1910-1980
- Industrial Relations 1920-1985
- Human relations movement 1930-1960
- Content theory 1943-1980
- Sociotechnical system 1950-1980
- Theory X and Theory Y 1960-1985
- Labour law 1964-Present
- Human resources information systems 1965-Present
- Strategic Human Resource Management 1984-Present
- High-Performance Work Systems 1990-Present
- People Analytics 2005-Present
Overview
Human resources is the part of management concerned with the people who work in an organization: how they are hired, paid, trained, organized, disciplined, and let go, and how their interests are balanced against the organization's12. Its history is a story of widening scope. What began as a clerical function—keeping payroll and personnel records—became, over the twentieth century, a set of competing attempts to answer a harder question: what actually makes people work well, and what do employers owe them12? The answers have ranged from time-and-motion measurement to motivational psychology to the statistical analysis of workforce data, and each answered a problem the previous approach could not.
Welfare Work and the Origins of Personnel Administration
Industrial employment in the nineteenth century created a problem no one had managed before: large concentrations of workers in factories, mines, and mills, far from the small workshops where an owner knew every employee. Absenteeism, turnover, drunkenness, and accidents were handled ad hoc, often by foremen with near-absolute authority over hiring and firing.
The first organized response was welfare work, which emerged in Britain and the United States in the later nineteenth century. Large employers—textile mills, department stores, and especially railway and manufacturing firms—appointed welfare secretaries, often women, to look after workers' housing, canteens, medical care, savings schemes, and recreation. The motives were mixed: genuine paternalism, a wish to reduce turnover, and sometimes a desire to keep unions out. The Quaker confectionery firms Rowntree and Cadbury in Britain are well-documented examples of the paternalist model, providing housing, education, and medical services to their workforces.
Out of welfare work grew personnel administration, the bureaucratic management of employment. Its central tools were the personnel record, the job description, the hiring interview, and the wage scale. The First World War accelerated it: mass mobilization in Britain and the United States created huge demand for labor, and government pressure pushed firms to formalize recruitment and retention. In the United States, the war industries boards and later the growth of civil service examinations spread standardized hiring. By the 1920s, large corporations had personnel departments handling hiring, records, and welfare, and the field had its own professional associations and journals.
Scientific Management and the Measurement of Work
The decisive early-twentieth-century influence on how work was organized came from scientific management, associated above all with Frederick Winslow Taylor3. Taylor, an engineer at the Midvale Steel Company in Philadelphia, published The Principles of Scientific Management in 1911. His claim was that management should determine the "one best way" to do each task by systematic observation rather than rule of thumb4. The famous example is the pig-iron handling experiments at Bethlehem Steel, where Taylor's associates studied how much iron a worker could load per day and designed rest breaks and a task rate to match.
Taylorism introduced time study (measuring how long a task takes) and motion study (analyzing the movements involved), the latter developed further by Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, who filmed workers and classified motions into elemental units they called "therbligs." The practical result was the standardized job, the piece-rate wage, and the separation of planning from execution: engineers designed the work, and workers performed it. Scientific management spread internationally—to France, Germany, and Japan—and shaped factory organization for decades. Its weakness was that it treated the worker as a mechanism whose output could be optimized by measurement, and it largely ignored how workers felt about the work.
The Human Relations School
The problem scientific management could not solve was that measured, rationalized work did not reliably produce satisfied or cooperative workers. The human relations school emerged from the Hawthorne studies at the Western Electric plant near Chicago, conducted from the late 1920s into the 1930s under the direction of Elton Mayo and colleagues including Fritz Roethlisberger and William Dickson. The studies began as an investigation of how lighting affected productivity and found, confusingly, that output rose whether lighting was increased or decreased5. The researchers concluded that the attention itself—being studied, being consulted—changed behavior, and that informal social groups at work set their own output norms.
The "Hawthorne effect," as the attention-driven change came to be called, and the discovery of the informal organization became foundational. Human relations argued that workers are motivated by social needs, recognition, and belonging, not only by pay, and that supervisors should attend to morale and group dynamics1. The school's influence on personnel practice was large: it encouraged employee counseling, communication programs, and supervisory training. Later scholars criticized the studies' methods and the school's tendency to treat conflict as a communication failure rather than a genuine clash of interests, but the shift from the worker-as-machine to the worker-as-social-being was permanent.
Motivation Theory and the Two Faces of Management
The mid-twentieth century produced a wave of need and motivation theories that tried to specify what drives people at work6. Abraham Maslow's hierarchy of needs, published in 1943, proposed that people satisfy physiological, safety, social, esteem, and self-actualization needs in sequence—a scheme later much criticized for weak empirical support but enormously influential in management teaching7. Frederick Herzberg's two-factor theory (1959) distinguished "hygiene" factors—pay, conditions, supervision—which prevent dissatisfaction but do not motivate, from "motivators" such as achievement and responsibility, which do. David McClelland studied the need for achievement, affiliation, and power8. These theories gave managers a vocabulary for job design and recognition, and they fed directly into the redesign of jobs to make them more varied and responsible.
Running alongside them was Douglas McGregor's distinction, in The Human Side of Enterprise (1960), between Theory X—the assumption that workers are lazy and must be coerced—and Theory Y—the assumption that work is natural and people seek responsibility. McGregor argued that management style tends to become a self-fulfilling prophecy: treat people as shirkers and they will behave that way. Theory Y became a slogan for participative management, though it was a set of assumptions rather than a tested method.
Industrial Relations and the Institutional Turn
A parallel tradition treated employment as a relationship between organized interests rather than a problem of individual motivation. Industrial relations developed as a field in the early twentieth century, especially in the United States and Britain, around the study of unions, collective bargaining, and the rules governing work9. Its most influential statement was John Dunlop's Industrial Relations Systems (1958), which modeled industrial relations as a system of three actors—workers and their organizations, management, and government—interacting within an environment of technology, markets, and power to produce a web of rules.
This "pluralist" view held that employers and employees have legitimately different interests and that conflict is normal and should be channeled through bargaining and procedure rather than suppressed. It gave personnel work its industrial-relations specialists, grievance procedures, and negotiation practices. In Britain, the tradition was closely tied to the development of labor law and the shop-steward system; in the United States, the National Labor Relations Act of 1935 and the postwar collective-bargaining era made it central to personnel practice.
Socio-Technical Systems and the Redesign of Work
After the Second World War, a group at the Tavistock Institute in London—notably Eric Trist and Ken Bamforth—studied British coal mining and found that the technology of longwall mining had broken up the small, self-directing work groups miners had traditionally used, with damaging effects on productivity and morale. Their answer, socio-technical systems theory, was that work should be designed by jointly optimizing the social system (groups, roles, communication) and the technical system (machines, processes), rather than fitting people to technology10. The approach inspired the "autonomous work group" experiments in Norway and Sweden and influenced later job-redesign movements such as the quality-of-working-life programs of the 1970s.
Employment Law and Compliance
As employment grew more regulated, a compliance function became central to personnel work. The timeline differs by country, but the pattern is common: factory legislation in the nineteenth century limited hours and regulated child labor; the twentieth century added workers' compensation, minimum wages, and social insurance; and the postwar decades added anti-discrimination law. In the United States, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibited employment discrimination on grounds of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission was created to enforce it11. In Britain, the Race Relations Acts of the 1960s and 1970s and later equality legislation played a similar role. Compliance turned personnel departments into interpreters of statute and case law, and it made documentation—job descriptions, interview records, performance files—a legal necessity as well as an administrative one.
Strategic Human Resource Management
By the 1980s, personnel administration faced a criticism from within management: it was a cost center and a rule-enforcer, disconnected from how the firm competed. Strategic human resource management (SHRM) answered by arguing that people practices should be designed as a coherent system aligned with business strategy. Two positions competed. The "best fit" approach held that HR practices must match the firm's strategy and environment; the "best practices" or high-performance approach held that certain bundles of practices—selective hiring, extensive training, performance-based pay, participation—work well across firms.
The Harvard model, set out by Michael Beer and colleagues in Managing Human Resources (1984), framed HR as shaped by stakeholder interests and producing outcomes for employees, the organization, and society. The AMO framework—a later summary formulation holding that performance depends on employees' Ability, Motivation, and Opportunity to participate—became a common way to describe what HR systems are trying to achieve. The field's central empirical claim, that coherent "bundles" of practices outperform piecemeal ones, remains debated, but the strategic framing permanently changed how HR presents itself.
High-Performance Work Systems
The high-performance work systems literature grew from the same impulse, asking which combinations of practices raise organizational performance. Studies of manufacturing plants in the 1990s, notably by Paul Osterman and by Jeffrey Pfeffer, associated practices such as self-managed teams, problem-solving groups, job rotation, and incentive pay with higher productivity and quality. The research program generated a long argument about causality—do these practices cause performance, or do well-performing firms simply adopt them?—and about whether they benefit workers as well as firms. It remains one of the most-studied questions in the field.
Information Systems and People Analytics
The last major shift is technological. HR information systems began as mainframe payroll and personnel-record systems in the 1960s and 1970s, then moved to client-server HR management systems covering recruitment, benefits, and timekeeping, and then to cloud-based platforms in the 2000s. Each step moved more employment data into queryable form.
People analytics—the use of statistical analysis on workforce data to inform decisions—grew from that base in the 2000s and 2010s. Its landmark demonstration was Google's "Project Oxygen," an internal study that analyzed performance reviews and found that technical skill ranked below coaching, communication, and empathy among the behaviors of effective managers. The field now applies regression, network analysis, and predictive modeling to hiring, attrition, and performance, and it raises the same question that has run through HR's history: whether measurement captures what actually matters about people at work.
The Present
Human resources today is a composite of all these layers. Personnel administration survives as the transactional core—payroll, records, compliance—increasingly automated. Strategic HR and high-performance work systems supply the language in which HR justifies itself to executives. Motivation and job-design theory inform how work is structured. Industrial relations persists wherever unions and collective bargaining remain significant, though its influence has declined in many countries since the 1980s. People analytics is the fastest-growing edge, and it is contested: its advocates argue it replaces intuition with evidence, while critics ask whether the data available measure the things that make work good. The open questions are old ones in new dress—whether HR serves the organization, the employee, or both, and how to know when a practice actually works.
References
- Human resources (Distinction to human resource management, History), Wikipedia
- Human resource management, Wikipedia
- Scientific management, Wikipedia
- Work design (History), Wikipedia
- Hawthorne effect (History), Wikipedia
- Content theory, Wikipedia
- Maslow's hierarchy of needs (introduction, Historical development), Wikipedia
- Need theory, Wikipedia
- Industrial relations (introduction, History), Wikipedia
- Sociotechnical system, Wikipedia
- Equal employment opportunity, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Human Resources
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1880-1930
- 1900-1950
- 1910-1980
Personnel Administration
How should employment records and hiring be administered?
- 1920-1985
Industrial Relations
How should employers and organized workers bargain?
- 1930-1960
- 1943-1980
- 1950-1980
Sociotechnical system
How should social and technical systems be jointly designed?
- 1960-1985
Theory X and Theory Y
What assumptions should managers hold about workers?
- 1964-Present
- 1965-Present
Human resources information systems
How should workforce data be stored and processed?
- 1984-Present
Strategic Human Resource Management
How should people practices serve organizational strategy?
- 1990-Present
High-Performance Work Systems
Which work practices raise firm performance?
- 2005-Present
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Personnel Administration grew out of Welfare Work
Personnel administration grew directly out of welfare work: the welfare secretary's duties over housing, canteens and records were formalized into the personnel department's hiring, job description and wage-scale functions, accelerated by First World War labor mobilization.
Carried by Rowntree; Cadbury.
Human relations movement reacted against Scientific Management
The human relations school defined itself against Taylorism's treatment of the worker as a mechanism, using the Hawthorne studies to show that social attention and informal groups, not measurement alone, drove output.
Carried by Elton Mayo; Fritz Roethlisberger; William Dickson.
High-Performance Work Systems grew out of Strategic Human Resource Management
High-performance work systems refined strategic HRM by specifying bundles of practices—selective hiring, training, participation, performance pay—claimed to raise firm performance, a branch of the strategic HRM research program.
Personnel Administration influenced by Scientific Management
Scientific management's time study, motion study and standardized job description were absorbed into personnel administration as tools for setting wages and defining jobs, giving the personnel function its technical vocabulary.
Carried by Frederick Winslow Taylor; The Principles of Scientific Management (1911).
Sociotechnical system reacted against Scientific Management
Socio-technical systems theory rejected scientific management's fitting of people to technology, arguing from the Tavistock coal-mining studies that social and technical systems must be jointly optimized.
Carried by Eric Trist; Ken Bamforth.
Industrial Relations rival of Personnel Administration
Personnel administration and industrial relations competed over the same employment questions: the former managed individuals through records and welfare, the latter treated employment as bargaining between organized interests, and both claimed the personnel function.
Carried by John Dunlop.
Human resources information systems grew out of Personnel Administration
Human resources information systems automated the personnel record, payroll and wage-scale work that personnel administration had created, turning its paper bureaucracy into computer files.
Strategic Human Resource Management grew out of Personnel Administration
Strategic human resource management grew out of personnel administration by recasting its hiring, records and wage functions as levers aligned with organizational strategy rather than clerical support.
Labour law influenced by Industrial Relations
Industrial relations' study of collective bargaining, grievance procedure and the rules governing work supplied the substance that labor law codified, especially in the United States and Britain.
Carried by John Dunlop; National Labor Relations Act (1935).
Theory X and Theory Y influenced by Human relations movement
McGregor's participative Theory Y carried forward the human relations emphasis on supervision, morale and group dynamics, framing management style as a self-fulfilling prophecy about worker motivation.
Carried by Douglas McGregor.
Theory X and Theory Y influenced by Content theory
McGregor's Theory Y drew on the need theories' premise that people seek responsibility and self-actualization, turning Maslow's hierarchy into a set of managerial assumptions about workers.
Carried by Douglas McGregor; The Human Side of Enterprise (1960).
People Analytics grew out of Human resources information systems
People analytics grew out of HR information systems as the accumulated workforce data began to be analyzed statistically for prediction and decision-making rather than record-keeping.
Sociotechnical system influenced by Human relations movement
The Tavistock group shared human relations' focus on work groups and morale, and its autonomous work group designs extended the informal-group findings into a principle of work redesign.
Carried by Eric Trist.
People Analytics influenced by High-Performance Work Systems
People analytics took up the high-performance work systems question of which practices actually raise performance, answering it with workforce data and statistical measurement rather than practice bundles.
Beyond the field
Where Human Resources's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 95 links.
Scientific Management provoked Theory X and Theory Y in Industrial Organizational Psychology
Theory X was explicitly built as a critique of the scientific-management assumptions about human motivation in the workplace, with Theory Y offered as their replacement.
Carried by Frederick Winslow Taylor; Douglas McGregor.
Personnel Administration led to Human Resource Management in Organizational Communication
Human resource management developed directly out of personnel administration, retaining its selection, training and compensation functions while recasting them in a strategic, developmental frame.
Industrial Relations provoked Radical Critique of Industrial Relations in Employee Relations
The radical critique of industrial relations defined itself against the pluralist and institutionalist industrial relations orthodoxy of Dunlop, Kerr and the Oxford school. Writers such as Braverman and later radical labour-process scholars attacked that tradition's assumption of shared interests and its neglect of class conflict.
Carried by Harry Braverman; Labor and Monopoly Capital (1974).
Human relations movement provoked Radical Critique of Industrial Relations in Employee Relations
Radical industrial relations writers rejected the human relations movement's unitarist premise that satisfied workers and good communication would dissolve conflict. They recast human relations techniques as instruments of managerial control.
Carried by Harry Braverman; Labor and Monopoly Capital (1974).
Sociotechnical system led to Industrial Democracy and Quality of Working Life in Sociotechnical Systems
The industrial democracy and quality-of-working-life programme grew directly out of the Tavistock sociotechnical systems approach to work design.
Carried by Eric Trist; Fred Emery.
Human resources information systems influenced People analytics in Strategic Human Resource Management
People analytics grew directly out of human resources information systems, extending HR data capture into statistical analysis and prediction. HRIS provided the data infrastructure on which people analytics depends.
Strategic Human Resource Management influenced Strategic Human Resource Development in Training And Development
Strategic human resource management supplied strategic HRD with its core premise that people practices must align with business strategy. The HRD variant applied SHRM's fit logic to training and development.
Strategic Human Resource Management led to Best practices approach in Strategic Human Resource Management
The best-practices approach grew out of strategic HRM's debate over whether universal HR bundles or contingency-fit models drive performance. Huselid's 1995 high-performance work practices study and Pfeffer's 1994 competitive-advantage work crystallised the universalist 'best practices' position within that strategic HRM literature.
Carried by Mark Huselid; Jeffrey Pfeffer.
Strategic Human Resource Management grew out of Human Resource Management in Organizational Communication
Strategic HRM grew directly out of human resource management, extending its functional personnel practices by tying them to business strategy; the Harvard and Michigan models of the early 1980s mark the transition.
Carried by Michael Beer; Harvard model (1984).
Strategic Human Resource Management led to High-performance work system in Strategic Human Resource Management
The high-performance work system concept developed within strategic HRM as the specification of which HR practices drive firm performance. Huselid's 1995 study of high-performance work practices operationalised the strategic HRM performance link.
Carried by Mark Huselid.
Strategic Human Resource Management provoked Critical HRM in Strategic Human Resource Management
Critical HRM arose as a critique of strategic HRM's unitarist assumption that HR practices align employee and employer interests. Writers such as Karen Legge attacked the performance-focused strategic HRM literature for ignoring power and conflict.
Carried by Karen Legge.
Strategic Human Resource Management led to HR architecture in Strategic Human Resource Management
HR architecture was developed within strategic HRM by Lepak and Snell to specify how employment modes differ by value and uniqueness of human capital. It refined strategic HRM's fit logic into a differentiated portfolio of employment relationships.
Carried by David Lepak; Scott Snell.

Human Resources is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Human ResourcesRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Strategic Human Resource Management 21 links
- Labor And Employment Law 9 links
- Employee Relations 9 links
- Industrial Organizational Psychology 6 links
- Organizational Communication 5 links
- Talent Strategy 5 links
- Organizational Behavior 5 links
- Organization Theory 3 links
- Compensation And Rewards 2 links
- Performance Management 2 links
- Training And Development 2 links
- Human Factors 2 links
More in Human Resources
- Compensation And Rewards
- Employee Relations
- Performance Management
- Recruitment And Selection
- Strategic Human Resource Management
- Talent Strategy
- Training And Development
- Workplace Health And Safety
See where Human Resources sits on the Map of Human Knowledge