African Indigenous Religions
10 frameworks, from 1849 to today · Indigenous Religions · Religions
- Supreme Being Debate 1849-1980
- Evolutionary and Comparative Religion 1871-1930
- Ethnographic Functionalism 1920-1975
- African Philosophical Theology 1945-Present
- Feminist and Gender Analysis 1975-Present
- African diaspora religions 1980-Present
- Invented tradition 1983-Present
- Collaborative and Repatriation Research 1990-Present
- Critical Study of Religion 1990-Present
- Sacred Landscapes 1990-Present
Overview
African indigenous religions are the living traditions of the peoples of the continent and its diaspora who relate to a world saturated with powers, persons, and presences beyond the human: a high god or creator in many traditions, but also ancestors, territorial spirits, orisa and vodun, divinities of water, iron, thunder, and smallpox, and the forces that inhabit trees, rivers, hills, and crossroads. The traditions are not a single religion1. Yoruba orisa cults, Akan abosom and the Asante royal ancestral stools, Dogon masked societies, Nuer and Dinka conceptions of a distant creator, Igbo alusi, Kongo nkisi, and Zulu amadlozi ancestor veneration differ as much as they resemble one another. What they share is less a doctrine than a history: a history of living practice, of slave-trade and colonial disruption, of missionization, of scholarly misdescription, and of contemporary revival, diaspora, and repatriation.
The stakes are unusually high because for more than a century outsiders defined these traditions as "primitive," "fetish," or "animism," and because many of their custodians were killed, converted, or scattered. The history of the subfield is therefore double: the history of the traditions themselves, and the history of how they have been studied, contested, and reclaimed. This article follows both, because in this field the two cannot be separated.
Early Encounters and the Evolutionary Frame
European contact with West African and Central African religious life began with Portuguese and later Dutch, French, and British traders and missionaries from the fifteenth century onward. Their accounts were shaped by a stark contrast: they saw no temples, no written scriptures, no professional priesthood in the Christian sense, and concluded that Africans had no religion at all, or only "fetishism" and "idolatry." The word fetish, from the Portuguese feitiço (charm, sorcery), entered European languages through these encounters and became a catch-all for African ritual objects.
In the nineteenth century this observation was systematized by the evolutionary and comparative religion frame2. Scholars such as Edward Burnett Tylor, in Primitive Culture (1871), and James Frazer, in The Golden Bough (first edition 1890), placed African traditions at the bottom of a universal ladder from "animism" (Tylor's term for the belief that spirits inhabit natural things) through polytheism to monotheism. The frame was comparative and hierarchical: African materials were raw data for a theory of religious evolution, not traditions worth studying in their own right. Its lasting damage was the assumption that African religion was a survival of an earlier stage of human thought.
The Supreme Being Debate and the Missionary Turn
A counter-current emerged from missionaries themselves. In 1849 the German missionary J. C. L. Gollmer, working among the Yoruba, and later others, reported that Africans did believe in a high god: the Yoruba Olodumare, the Akan Nyame, the Igbo Chukwu. The missionary-scholar Edwin W. Smith, in the early twentieth century, and later the Ghanaian priest and scholar J. B. Danquah, in The Akan Doctrine of God (1944), argued that African traditions were essentially monotheistic, with lesser divinities as intermediaries. This became the supreme being debate: was the high god the real object of African worship, or a distant, otiose figure, with the real religious action among the orisa and ancestors1?
The debate mattered because it was a fight over dignity. If Africans were monotheists, they were not "primitive." But the argument also distorted the evidence, flattening rich polytheistic systems into a Christian-shaped monotheism. The most influential intervention came from the Kenyan Anglican theologian John Mbiti, whose African Religions and Philosophy (1969) presented a pan-African account of a single high god, ancestors, and a cyclical sense of time. Mbiti's synthesis was enormously influential and is still taught, but later scholars criticized it for generalizing across a continent and for reading African traditions through Christian categories.
Ethnographic Functionalism and the Study of Living Practice
The decisive methodological shift came with ethnographic functionalism. Bronisław Malinowski's functionalism, developed in the Trobriand Islands and generalized in the 1920s and 1930s, held that every custom serves a social need. Applied to Africa, it encouraged long-term fieldwork and the study of religion as it was actually practiced. E. E. Evans-Pritchard's Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (1937) and his Nuer Religion (1956) are the landmarks: the Azande study showed that witchcraft beliefs formed a coherent system of explanation, not a failure of reason, and the Nuer study took seriously the Nuer concept of kwoth (spirit) on its own terms. Meyer Fortes and S. F. Nadel, and later Victor Turner in The Forest of Symbols (1967) and The Drums of Affliction (1968), analyzed ritual, symbolism, and the social work of ancestor veneration among the Ndembu.
Functionalism's contribution was to make African religion an object of serious empirical study. Its limitation was that it explained religion by its social function and often ignored what practitioners said about the divine. It also tended to treat the traditions as static and bounded, as if the colonial present had not already transformed them.
African Philosophical Theology and the Search for Indigenous Thought
From the 1950s a generation of African scholars, many of them Christian theologians, set out to show that African traditions contained systematic thought. Placide Tempels, a Belgian Franciscan working in the Congo, published La philosophie bantoue in 1945, arguing that Bantu-speaking peoples shared a philosophy of "vital force." The book was controversial, but it opened the question of an African philosophy. The Yoruba scholar J. O. Sodipo and the philosopher Barry Hallen, in Knowledge, Belief and Witchcraft (1986), later showed through fieldwork that Yoruba divination and ordinary reasoning had their own epistemology.
The most ambitious synthesis was the Ghanaian philosopher Kwame Gyekye's An Essay on African Philosophical Thought (1987), which argued for a communalist conception of personhood and a theistic metaphysics grounded in Akan thought. This body of work, often called African philosophical theology, insisted that African traditions were rational, coherent, and worth philosophical attention. Its risk was over-systematization: turning oral, localized, and contested traditions into a single "African philosophy."
The Invention of Tradition Critique
The 1980s brought a sharp challenge. The historians Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger, in The Invention of Tradition (1983), argued that many supposedly ancient customs were recent creations3. Applied to Africa, the critique showed that colonial administrators and missionaries had codified fluid practices into fixed "tribal" religions, and that some "traditional" institutions were colonial products. The critique was liberating because it denied that African religion was a frozen survival. It was also dangerous, because it could be turned against African claims to authenticity. The best work, such as the historian Paul Landau's The Realm of the Word (1995) on Christianity among the Tswana, showed that African religious life was neither pure survival nor colonial invention but a continuous, creative negotiation.
Feminist and Gender Analysis
From the 1970s and 1980s, feminist scholars and African women researchers asked where women were in the study of African religion. The Nigerian scholar and novelist Buchi Emecheta's fiction, and later the work of scholars such as the Ghanaian theologian Mercy Amba Oduyoye, founder of the Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians in 1989, brought gender into the center. Oduyoye's Hearing and Knowing (1986) and the Circle's collective volumes argued that African women's religious experience, including their roles in spirit possession, healing, and cult leadership, had been ignored by male scholars and male-dominated traditions alike.
The analysis also revealed that many African traditions were not simply patriarchal: women's cults, such as the Yoruba possession cults of the orisa, and the powerful position of queen mothers among the Akan, gave women religious authority that colonial and missionary Christianity often eroded. The field's question shifted from "what do Africans believe?" to "whose knowledge counts, and who is allowed to speak?"
Critical Study of Religion and the Question of Category
The late twentieth century saw sustained critique of the category "religion" itself. The scholar of religion Talal Asad, in Genealogies of Religion (1993), argued that "religion" as a universal, separable domain was a product of Christian and Enlightenment history, and that imposing it on other traditions distorted them. Applied to Africa, this critique questioned whether "African indigenous religions" was a coherent object at all. The Nigerian scholar Jacob Olupona, in City of 1200 Deities (2011) and other works, responded by studying Yoruba religion as a living, urban, transnational tradition rather than a relic. The critical study of religion also pushed scholars to examine their own categories: "belief," "ritual," "myth," and "sacred" were all shown to carry Christian baggage.
Diaspora, Transnational Orisa Revival, and Sacred Landscapes
The most visible transformation of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries has been the diaspora and transnational orisa revival. Enslaved Africans carried Yoruba, Kongo, and Dahomean traditions to the Americas, where they became Candomblé in Brazil, Santería or Regla de Ocha in Cuba, and Vodou in Haiti4567. In the twentieth century these traditions traveled back: Cuban and Brazilian initiates established houses in the United States and Europe, and Nigerian and Beninese priests traveled to the Americas. The scholar of religion Karen McCarthy Brown's Mama Lola (1991), an ethnography of a Haitian Vodou priestess in Brooklyn, showed how diaspora religion was remade in new landscapes.
The revival also reconnected diaspora practitioners to African sacred landscapes. The Yoruba city of Ile-Ife, the Osun-Osogbo sacred grove (inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage list in 2005), and the forests and rivers of orisa devotion became sites of pilgrimage and heritage. The concept of sacred landscape, developed in cultural geography and religious studies, helped scholars and practitioners describe how land, water, and built shrines form a single religious environment.
Collaborative Research, Repatriation, and Restitution
The most recent turn is methodological and political. Community-based collaborative research, in which scholars work with and under the direction of tradition custodians, has challenged the extractive model of fieldwork8. The scholar of religion and Ifa priest Wande Abimbola, and the Ifa divination scholar and babalawo (diviner) practitioners who collaborated with him, exemplified this shift in Yoruba studies. Repatriation and restitution have become central: sacred objects taken during colonial military campaigns, such as the Benin Bronzes looted in 1897, are the subject of ongoing claims, and the return of human remains and ritual objects is reshaping museum practice and the study of African religion itself.
The Present
Today the field is plural. Ethnographic and historical study of living traditions continues, now often in collaboration with practitioners. The critical study of religion supplies the field's methodological caution about its own categories. The supreme being debate has not been resolved so much as reframed: scholars now ask how particular traditions conceive of divinity in their own terms rather than whether they are "really" monotheistic. African philosophical theology and feminist analysis have made African thought and women's authority central rather than marginal. Diaspora and transnational studies have made clear that African indigenous religions are not confined to Africa and are not static. Repatriation and collaborative research have made the politics of knowledge part of the subject. The open questions are the old ones in new form: who has the authority to describe these traditions, what counts as evidence, and how the living communities who practice them will shape the scholarship of the next generation.
References
- African traditional religions (introduction, Practices and rituals, Divination, Basics), Wikipedia
- Anthropology of religion (History), Wikipedia
- Invented tradition (introduction, Background), Wikipedia
- Orisha, Wikipedia
- Candomblé, Wikipedia
- Haitian Vodou, Wikipedia
- Santería, Wikipedia
- Community-based participatory research, Wikipedia
The frameworks of African Indigenous Religions
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1849-1980
- 1871-1930
Evolutionary and Comparative Religion
How do religions evolve from primitive to civilized?
- 1920-1975
- 1945-Present
African Philosophical Theology
Is there a systematic African philosophy?
- 1975-Present
- 1980-Present
African diaspora religions
How did African religions shape the diaspora?
- 1983-Present
- 1990-Present
Collaborative and Repatriation Research
Who owns and controls research on African religions?
- 1990-Present
- 1990-Present
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
African Philosophical Theology grew out of Supreme Being Debate
African philosophical theology grew out of the supreme being debate's concern to demonstrate the rationality and dignity of African religious thought. Mbiti's synthesis and Gyekye's philosophical work extended the argument that African traditions contained systematic thought about God and personhood.
Carried by John Mbiti; Kwame Gyekye.
Ethnographic Functionalism reacted against Evolutionary and Comparative Religion
Ethnographic functionalism rejected the evolutionary and comparative approach's speculative history and armchair theorizing. Evans-Pritchard's fieldwork-based studies treated African religious beliefs as coherent systems to be understood in their own terms, not as survivals of an earlier stage.
Carried by E. E. Evans-Pritchard; Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (1937).
Invented tradition reacted against Evolutionary and Comparative Religion
The invention of tradition critique attacked the evolutionary assumption that African customs were survivals of ancient stages. Hobsbawm and Ranger argued that many supposedly ancient traditions were recent inventions, challenging the evolutionary frame's historical depth.
Carried by Eric Hobsbawm; Terence Ranger; The Invention of Tradition (1983).
Critical Study of Religion reacted against Evolutionary and Comparative Religion
The critical study of religion attacked the category 'religion' as a product of Christian and Enlightenment history, which had been universalized by the evolutionary and comparative frame. Talal Asad's genealogy showed how the comparative approach had imposed a particular Protestant model on other traditions.
Carried by Talal Asad; Genealogies of Religion (1993).
Invented tradition reacted against Ethnographic Functionalism
The invention of tradition critique rejected functionalism's tendency to treat African societies as static and bounded. It showed that colonial administrators and missionaries had codified fluid practices into fixed tribal religions, undermining the functionalist image of timeless custom.
Carried by Eric Hobsbawm; Terence Ranger.
Feminist and Gender Analysis reacted against African Philosophical Theology
Feminist and gender analysis critiqued African philosophical theology for its male-centered focus and its neglect of women's religious experience. Oduyoye and the Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians argued that the earlier scholarship had ignored women's roles and perspectives.
Carried by Mercy Amba Oduyoye; Hearing and Knowing (1986).
African Philosophical Theology influenced by Ethnographic Functionalism
Ethnographic functionalism's emphasis on fieldwork and indigenous concepts influenced African philosophical theology's method. Hallen and Sodipo's epistemological study of Yoruba divination drew on the detailed ethnographic attention to local thought that functionalism had established.
Carried by Barry Hallen; J. O. Sodipo.
Collaborative and Repatriation Research influenced by Ethnographic Functionalism
Collaborative and repatriation research built on ethnographic functionalism's emphasis on long-term fieldwork, but redirected it toward collaboration with descendant communities and the return of research materials. The method shifted from extraction to partnership.
Collaborative and Repatriation Research influenced by Feminist and Gender Analysis
Feminist and gender analysis's question 'whose knowledge counts?' influenced collaborative and repatriation research's attention to power and voice in research relationships. Both movements sought to include previously marginalized perspectives.
Critical Study of Religion influenced by Invented tradition
The invention of tradition critique influenced the critical study of religion's genealogical method by showing how categories and traditions are historically constructed. Both approaches share a suspicion of essentialized and timeless notions.
Carried by Talal Asad.
Beyond the field
Where African Indigenous Religions's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 39 links.
Evolutionary and Comparative Religion provoked Cultural relativist ethnography in Indigenous Religions Of The Americas
Boas and his students defined cultural relativist ethnography against the evolutionary and comparative religion of Tylor and Frazer, rejecting its stage scheme and its use of scattered customs as evidence. The particularist programme was framed as a direct attack on that comparative evolutionism.
Carried by Franz Boas.
Evolutionary and Comparative Religion influenced Salvage ethnography and evolutionary comparative religion in Indigenous Religions Of The Americas
The evolutionary and comparative study of religion, exemplified by Tylor and later Frazer, provided the theoretical scheme that salvage ethnographers applied to Native American materials. Their collections were meant to supply the comparative evidence for a universal developmental sequence of religious forms.
Carried by Edward Burnett Tylor; James George Frazer.
African Philosophical Theology influenced by Ethnophilosophy in African Philosophy
Ethnophilosophy, above all Tempels's Bantu Philosophy and its successors, supplied the collective world-view method and the notion of African communal thought that African philosophical theology took up and criticised. Placide Tempels's work of 1945 was the direct stimulus.
Carried by Placide Tempels; Bantu Philosophy (1945).
African diaspora religions influenced by Diaspora and Retention Studies in African Mythologies
Diaspora and retention studies, especially Melville Herskovits's acculturation work, supplied the retention-versus-creolisation debate on which the study of African diaspora religions was built. The later field reworked Herskovits's framework.
Carried by Melville J. Herskovits.
Critical Study of Religion influenced by Feminist and postcolonial critique in Anthropology Of Religion
Feminist and postcolonial critique in the anthropology of religion, especially critiques of ethnographic authority and of the colonial framing of belief, supplied the analytical tools that the critical study of religion took up in the 1990s.
Critical Study of Religion reacted against Comparative religion in Religious Pluralism
The critical study of religion arose largely as a rejection of comparative religion's decontextualised comparison of traditions, arguing that its categories were colonial products rather than neutral analytical tools.
Supreme Being Debate influenced by Deism in Philosophy Of Theism
The Supreme Being debate among missionaries and Africanists took up Deist and natural-theological arguments about a rational creator knowable by reason apart from revelation. Deist notions of a universal supreme being shaped how nineteenth-century observers framed African high gods.
Evolutionary and Comparative Religion influenced by Comparative Mythology and Diffusionism in African Mythologies
Comparative mythology and diffusionism supplied the comparative method and the solar and nature-myth interpretations that evolutionary writers on religion drew on. Max Müller's comparative philology and myth theory fed directly into Tylor's and Frazer's comparative projects.
Carried by Friedrich Max Müller.
Evolutionary and Comparative Religion influenced Primitive Medicine and Comparative Evolutionism in Medical Anthropology
Comparative religion's evolutionary treatment of ritual and belief, including healing rites, was the direct model for the comparative study of primitive medicine. The same scholars and the same staged scheme carried over.
Carried by James George Frazer; William Robertson Smith.
Ethnographic Functionalism influenced Participant Observation in Anthropology
Malinowski's functionalist ethnography of the Trobriands established the model of long-term residence and participation that became participant observation. The functionalist fieldwork programme supplied the method's canonical form.
Carried by Bronisław Malinowski; Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922).
Ethnographic Functionalism influenced Ethnophilosophy in African Philosophy
Ethnographic functionalism, especially the British structural-functionalist study of African societies, provided the anthropological model of collective thought that ethnophilosophy's critics and practitioners both worked with.
Carried by E. E. Evans-Pritchard.
African Philosophical Theology influenced Liberationist and Contextual Practical Theology in Practical Theology
African philosophical theology's articulation of inculturation and African identity shaped contextual practical theology's method of reading the gospel through local culture.

African Indigenous Religions is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 10 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on African Indigenous ReligionsRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- African Philosophy 9 links
- Indigenous Religions Of The Americas 6 links
- African Mythologies 5 links
- Indigenous Religions 4 links
- Anthropology Of Religion 2 links
- Aboriginal Australian Religions 2 links
- Anthropology 1 link
- Medical Anthropology 1 link
- Archaeological Theory 1 link
- Historical Archaeology 1 link
- Public Archaeology 1 link
- Practical Theology 1 link
More in Indigenous Religions
- Aboriginal Australian Religions
- African Diaspora Religions
- Indigenous Religions
- Indigenous Religions Of Asia
- Indigenous Religions Of The Americas
- Oceanic Indigenous Religions
See where African Indigenous Religions sits on the Map of Human Knowledge