Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication

Clinical communication and shared decision making concern the part of medical care that happens in conversation: how a clinician and a patient exchange information, build a relationship, and arrive at a decision about what to do.

11 frameworks, from 1900 to today · Clinical Medicine · Medicine & Health

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Clinical communication and shared decision making concern the part of medical care that happens in conversation: how a clinician and a patient exchange information, build a relationship, and arrive at a decision about what to do. For most of medicine's history this was treated as a matter of good manners or native talent rather than a subject with methods of its own. The transformation of the past seventy years is the story of that conversation becoming a discipline—with models, measurement tools, training methods, and evidence. What is at stake is not politeness but outcomes: whether patients understand their options, whether they take part in decisions that affect them, whether they adhere to treatment, and whether they are harmed by care.

The Paternalistic Baseline

For much of the twentieth century the dominant model of the clinical encounter was paternalistic: the physician, holding specialized knowledge, decided what was best and the patient complied. This was not merely custom but was codified in ethics. The Hippocratic tradition's injunction to do good and avoid harm was read as licensing the physician to act on the patient's behalf, and the principle of primum non nocere—first, do no harm—was often invoked to justify withholding distressing information. In many countries it was routine practice not to tell patients they had cancer, on the grounds that disclosure would harm them. The physician's duty of beneficence was understood to include deciding how much the patient should know.

The countercurrent was informed consent. Its legal foundations were laid in the mid-twentieth century, most famously in the Nuremberg Code (1947), which arose from the trials of Nazi doctors and required voluntary consent to research, and later in the American doctrine of informed consent developed through malpractice cases in the 1950s and 1960s. The key shift was from "consent" as mere permission to "informed" consent as disclosure of risks, benefits, and alternatives. By the 1970s, courts in the United States had begun to articulate a "patient-centered" standard—asking what a reasonable patient would want to know, rather than what a reasonable physician would disclose. Informed consent established a legal and ethical floor: patients had a right to information and to refuse. It did not yet say that patients should share in the decision.

The Biopsychosocial Model and Patient-Centred Medicine

A parallel shift came from clinical theory. In 1977 George Engel, a psychiatrist at the University of Rochester, published the biopsychosocial model, arguing that the dominant biomedical model—which explained disease in biological terms alone—was insufficient. Illness, he argued, is shaped by psychological and social factors as well as biological ones, and the clinical method must therefore take the patient's experience, circumstances, and meaning into account1. The model gave a theoretical rationale for attending to the person, not just the disease.

This fed into patient-centred medicine, a term that gained currency in the 1970s and 1980s, particularly through the work of Ian McWhinney and colleagues in family medicine in Canada and the United Kingdom. Patient-centred care meant exploring the patient's agenda—their concerns, expectations, and feelings—alongside the clinician's biomedical agenda, and finding common ground. The patient's experience of illness became a clinical object in its own right, not a distraction from the disease.

Evidence-Based Medicine and the Problem of Preference

The next turning point came from a different direction. Evidence-based medicine (EBM), articulated in the early 1990s by Gordon Guyatt and colleagues at McMaster University, insisted that clinical decisions be grounded in the best available research evidence, critically appraised, rather than in tradition or authority2. EBM's founding statement, published in JAMA in 1992, defined it as combining the best research evidence with clinical expertise and patient values. That last phrase—patient values—was easy to state and hard to operationalize. EBM gave clinicians tools to estimate what could work (systematic reviews, randomized trials, numbers needed to treat), but it sharpened a question: once the evidence is in, whose values determine whether a treatment is worth it? A patient who values avoiding a stroke may accept the bleeding risk of anticoagulation that another patient would refuse. The evidence cannot answer that; the patient must.

This gap—between evidence and preference—is where shared decision making took shape. The term was formalized in the late 1990s, notably in a 1997 paper by Cathy Charles, Amiram Gafni, and Tim Whelan in Social Science & Medicine, which described shared decision making as a model in which both physician and patient contribute information and both participate in the decision. It was distinguished from paternalism (physician decides) and from consumerism (patient decides alone). The model's claim was that the best decisions are those in which the clinician brings evidence and expertise and the patient brings values and preferences, and the two are integrated.

Decision Aids and the Tools of Participation

If patients were to share decisions, they needed to understand their options. This produced decision aids: structured tools—booklets, videos, web programs—that present the options, the evidence about outcomes, and the trade-offs in plain language. Early decision aids appeared in the 1980s, and by the 1990s they were being evaluated in randomized trials. The Cochrane review of decision aids, first published in the late 1990s and updated repeatedly, found that they improve patients' knowledge and accuracy of risk perception and reduce decisional conflict, though their effect on the actual choice is variable. A later innovation, the option grid, developed by Glyn Elwyn and colleagues in the 2010s, presented options and their attributes in a simple table to support conversation in the consultation itself.

Decision aids made concrete what shared decision making required: not just goodwill but information formatted for comprehension, including absolute risks and natural frequencies rather than relative risks alone.

The Consultation as a Skill: Training and Frameworks

Alongside the decision-making literature, a separate strand treated communication itself as a teachable clinical skill. From the 1970s onward, medical educators began to argue that interviewing and communication could be taught and assessed rather than left to aptitude. Communication skills training spread through medical curricula, using role-play, simulated patients, and video review with feedback. The evidence base grew: reviews in the 1990s and 2000s showed that training changed clinicians' behavior and improved patient satisfaction, though effects on hard clinical outcomes were harder to demonstrate.

The most influential framework was the Calgary–Cambridge guide, developed by Suzanne Kurtz and Jonathan Silverman and published in the 1990s. It broke the consultation into phases—initiating the session, gathering information, building the relationship, explanation and planning, closing the session—and specified the skills within each. Its contribution was to make the consultation visible and teachable, integrating communication skills with the clinical tasks of history-taking and planning.

A related development was the SPIKES protocol, published by Walter Baile and colleagues in 2000 for breaking bad news3. SPIKES—Setting up the interview, assessing the patient's Perception, obtaining an Invitation, giving Knowledge, addressing Emotions, and Strategy and Summary—gave clinicians a stepwise method for a conversation that had previously been left to intuition3. It exemplifies the broader move: difficult conversations were decomposed into learnable steps.

Measuring the Conversation

A field that claims to improve communication must measure it. Consultation coding systems—beginning with instruments like the Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS), developed by Debra Roter in the late 1970s—categorized utterances in recorded consultations, allowing researchers to count and compare communication behaviors. Later tools specifically measured shared decision making: the OPTION scale, developed by Elwyn and colleagues in the early 2000s, rated the extent to which clinicians involved patients in decisions, and the Observer OPTION and other instruments followed. Measurement made the field empirical: it could show that shared decision making was often espoused but rarely practiced, and that training and tools changed scores. It also exposed the gap between what clinicians say they do and what recordings show.

The Present

Today shared decision making is embedded in policy—endorsed by bodies such as the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and written into guidelines and health-system programs in several countries—and decision aids are widely available, though their routine use remains uneven. Communication skills training is standard in medical education, and frameworks like Calgary–Cambridge and SPIKES are taught internationally. The field's open questions are practical and empirical: how to make shared decision making routine in time-pressed consultations, how to reach patients with limited health literacy, how to measure quality of decision support rather than just its presence, and whether the approach improves outcomes equitably across populations. The conversation that was once invisible is now a subject with methods, measures, and a history of its own.

References

  1. Biopsychosocial model (History), Wikipedia
  2. Evidence-based medicine (Background, history, and definition), Wikipedia
  3. SPIKES, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1900-1975

    Medical paternalism

    Who should decide what treatment a patient receives?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1975-Present

    Communications training

    Can clinicians be taught to communicate better?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1975-Present

    Patient-centred medicine

    How should care be organized around the patient's experience?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1977-Present

    Biopsychosocial model

    What factors beyond biology shape illness?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1977-Present

    Consultation coding and measurement systems

    How can we measure what happens in a consultation?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1985-Present

    Decision aids

    How can patients understand their treatment options?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1992-Present

    Evidence-based medicine

    What should clinical decisions be based on?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1996-Present

    Calgary–Cambridge model

    What are the phases and skills of a medical consultation?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1997-Present

    Shared decision-making in medicine

    How should clinician and patient decide together?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 2000-Present

    SPIKES

    How should a clinician deliver bad news?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Medical paternalismInformed consentCommunications trainingPatient-centred medicineBiopsychosocial modelConsultation coding and measurement s…Decision aidsEvidence-based medicineCalgary–Cambridge modelShared decision-making in medicineSPIKES

Beyond the field

Where Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 37 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 11 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Clinical Medicine

See where Shared Decision Making And Clinical Communication sits on the Map of Human Knowledge