Historical Performance Practice

Historical performance practice is the craft of making old music sound as its first audiences might have heard it—or, more cautiously, of making decisions about tempo, tuning, ornamentation, instrumentation, and style that are grounded in evidence about how the music was originally played and sung.

11 frameworks, from 1890 to today · Music · Arts & Architecture

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Historical performance practice is the craft of making old music sound as its first audiences might have heard it—or, more cautiously, of making decisions about tempo, tuning, ornamentation, instrumentation, and style that are grounded in evidence about how the music was originally played and sung1. It is sometimes called "historically informed performance" (HIP), and its practitioners range from scholars who edit treatises to cellists who restring their instruments with gut1. What is at stake is not merely fidelity to a vanished past but the character of the music itself: a Bach cantata performed with modern instruments and equal temperament sounds different in almost every dimension from one performed with period instruments and the tuning systems of Bach's time. The field's history is a long argument about how much of that difference can be recovered, and whether recovery is even the right goal.

Antiquarian Roots and the First Revivals

Interest in older music and its original manner of performance is as old as the music itself. In the late eighteenth century, English antiquarians such as Charles Burney and John Hawkins wrote histories that quoted early treatises, and the Handel Commemoration of 1784—though it used enormous forces—showed a new appetite for reviving a composer's music. The nineteenth century brought the first serious attempts to perform Renaissance and Baroque music with something like its original forces. In Germany, the Berlin Sing-Akademie under Carl Friedrich Zelter performed Bach's motets and Passions from the 1810s onward, and Felix Mendelssohn's 1829 revival of the St Matthew Passion in Berlin was a landmark: it reintroduced a work that had been largely forgotten, though Mendelssohn cut and rescored it for a nineteenth-century orchestra. In France, Alexandre Choron and later the Schola Cantorum (founded 1894) promoted the study and performance of plainchant and Renaissance polyphony. These efforts were scholarly in spirit but not yet systematic about instruments, tuning, or technique.

The Period-Instrument Revival

The decisive turn came in the early twentieth century, when a few musicians began to build and play instruments that had fallen out of use. The most influential figure was Arnold Dolmetsch, a French-born instrument maker and performer who settled in England. From the 1890s he built harpsichords, clavichords, lutes, and recorders based on historical models, and he performed seventeenth- and eighteenth-century music on them. His family's workshops and festivals at Haslemere became a seedbed for the revival. In the 1920s and 1930s, Wanda Landowska made the harpsichord a concert instrument again, though her instrument was a heavy, steel-framed modern adaptation rather than a copy of an eighteenth-century model—a reminder that "period" instruments were themselves being reinvented. The Dutch recorder player and conductor Frans Brüggen, the cellist Nikolaus Harnoncourt, and the violinist Gustav Leonhardt (who was also a harpsichordist) led the postwar generation that insisted on playing on instruments built to historical specifications, with gut strings, lighter bows, and no modern metal fittings.

Treatise-Based Performance Doctrine

The revival's intellectual backbone was the study of historical treatises—the instruction books that musicians wrote for their contemporaries1. These range from Michael Praetorius's Syntagma musicum (1614–20), which describes instruments and their tunings, to Johann Joachim Quantz's Versuch einer Anweisung die Flöte traversiere zu spielen (1752), a comprehensive guide to flute playing and eighteenth-century style, and Leopold Mozart's Versuch einer gründlichen Violinschule (1756). From such sources performers derived rules for ornamentation (trills, appoggiaturas, cadenzas), articulation, bowing, and tempo. The doctrine was not a single code but a body of competing advice: French and Italian traditions differed sharply on ornamentation, and later writers often contradicted earlier ones. The scholar-performers who mined these texts—among them Thurston Dart in Britain and later the American scholar-performer Robert Donington, whose The Interpretation of Early Music (1963) became a standard handbook—treated the treatises as the closest thing to a user's manual for the music.

Tuning and Temperament Reconstruction

A parallel strand concerned pitch itself1. Before the nineteenth century, tuning systems were not standardized: meantone temperaments, in which most fifths are slightly narrowed and the major third is pure, were common in the Renaissance and Baroque, and different regions used different pitch standards. The reconstruction of these systems required both historical research and practical experiment. The scholar and instrument maker John Murray Barbour's Tuning and Temperament: A Historical Survey (1951) mapped the history of tuning theory, and performers such as the harpsichordist and organist Gustav Leonhardt and later the scholar Ross Duffin argued for performing Renaissance and Baroque music in meantone or other historical temperaments rather than equal temperament. The practical effect is audible: in meantone, chords in remote keys sound distinctly sour, which changes how a piece in a given key feels and which keys composers chose.

The Early-Music Movement and the Authenticity Debate

By the 1970s, the period-instrument revival had become a broad movement, often called the early-music movement. Ensembles such as Harnoncourt's Concentus Musicus Wien, Leonhardt's Leonhardt-Consort, Christopher Hogwood's Academy of Ancient Music (founded 1973), and later John Eliot Gardiner's English Baroque Soloists and Ton Koopman's Amsterdam Baroque Orchestra recorded the Baroque and Classical repertory on period instruments at a scale that reached general audiences. The movement's claim was that period instruments and historical techniques revealed the music's true character. This claim provoked a sustained critique1. In 1980 the conductor and scholar Richard Taruskin published a series of essays arguing that the "authenticity" claimed by the movement was illusory: modern period performances were themselves products of the twentieth century, shaped by modern taste for clean textures and fast tempos, and the appeal to the composer's intentions was philosophically incoherent. The debate—often called the authenticity debate—forced performers to be more modest about their claims and more explicit about the choices they made. The term "historically informed performance" gradually replaced "authentic performance" as the preferred label1.

Body and Technique Reconstruction

A further development concerned the body itself. Historical instruments demand different physical techniques: a Baroque violin is held differently and bowed with a lighter, curved bow; a natural trumpet has no valves; a harpsichord's touch is entirely different from a piano's. Scholars and performers reconstructed these techniques from treatises, iconography, and surviving instruments. The result was a rethinking of what "technique" means: a modern violinist's vibrato, for instance, is largely a nineteenth- and twentieth-century development, and period performers learned to play with less or none. This strand overlapped with the study of rhetoric: eighteenth-century writers described music as a language of affects, with figures and gestures analogous to oratory, and performers reconstructed the expressive vocabulary—the Affektenlehre—that shaped how a phrase was shaped and ornamented.

Improvisation and Rhetoric Studies

Closely related was the recovery of improvisation2. Much Baroque and Classical music assumed that performers would ornament, embellish, and sometimes improvise cadenzas. The scholar-performer and musicologist Robert Levin, among others, demonstrated how eighteenth-century cadenzas and ornaments could be reconstructed from treatise rules and stylistic analogy, and performers began to reintroduce improvised ornamentation into concert life. The study of musical rhetoric—how a phrase is shaped like a sentence, how a dissonance is a kind of exclamation—gave performers a vocabulary for expressive decisions that had been lost when the music became a fixed text.

Modern-Instrument Historically Informed Performance

Not all HIP is played on period instruments. From the 1980s onward, a growing number of orchestras and chamber groups performing on modern instruments adopted historical principles: gut-like string sound, period bowing styles, historical tuning where feasible, and attention to treatise-based phrasing. The conductor Roger Norrington and others argued that the insights of the period movement could be applied to modern orchestras, and many conservatories now teach "historically informed" performance on modern instruments as a matter of course. This strand blurred the line between the period-instrument movement and mainstream classical performance.

Global and Non-Canonical Performance Practice

The field's early focus was overwhelmingly on the European Baroque and Classical repertory, but its methods have been extended. Scholars and performers have applied historical-performance questions to medieval and Renaissance music, to nineteenth-century music (where the evidence is richer but the assumptions about "period" style more contested), and to non-Western traditions. The study of historical performance in traditions outside the European canon—for example, the reconstruction of older Japanese gagaku or Indian court music—has raised questions about whether "historical performance" is a European idea or a general human practice. Within the European tradition, the field has also begun to address music by women composers and by composers outside the standard canon, asking what historical performance means for repertories that were never centrally performed.

Recording-Evidence Performance Research

The twentieth century added a new kind of evidence: recordings. Early recordings from the first decades of the century preserve performance styles—portamento, rubato, tempo flexibility—that differ markedly from modern norms, and scholars such as Robert Philip (in Early Recordings and Musical Style, 1992) used them to reconstruct nineteenth- and early twentieth-century performance practice. This "recording-evidence" approach has become central to the study of Romantic and early-modern performance, and it has complicated the field's assumptions: recordings show that historical performance was itself varied and changing, not a single lost style.

The Field Today

Contemporary historical performance practice is less a movement with a single creed than a set of methods. Performers routinely consult treatises, iconography, surviving instruments, and recordings; scholars edit and translate sources and debate what they can and cannot tell us1. The authenticity debate has settled into a working consensus: historical evidence informs choices, but no performance is a transparent window onto the past1. Open questions remain—how far historical tuning and temperament should be applied to modern-instrument performance, how to handle repertories with sparse evidence, and whether the field's methods can be responsibly extended beyond the European canon. The argument that began with Dolmetsch's harpsichords and Taruskin's essays continues, but it now takes place in the rehearsal room as much as in the journal.

References

  1. Historically informed performance (introduction, Interpreting musical notation, Tuning and pitch, Layout), Wikipedia
  2. Baroque music, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Historical Performance Practice

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1890-Present

    Period-Instrument Revival

    Should old music be played on old instruments?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1900-Present

    Treatise-Based Performance Doctrine

    What did historical instruction books say about playing?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1950-Present

    Tuning and Temperament Reconstruction

    How were instruments tuned before equal temperament?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1960-Present

    Body and Technique Reconstruction

    How did players physically hold and bow old instruments?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1960-Present

    Rhetoric and Affektenlehre Studies

    How did music express emotions in the eighteenth century?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1970-Present

    Early music revival

    Why did old music return to concert life?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1970-Present

    Improvisation and Ornamentation Recovery

    How did performers improvise and ornament in the past?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1980-Present

    Authenticity Debate

    Can a performance ever be truly authentic?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1980-Present

    Modern-Instrument Historically Informed Performance

    Can modern orchestras play in a historically informed way?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1990-Present

    Global and Non-Canonical Performance Practice

    Does historical performance apply outside the European canon?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1990-Present

    Recording-Evidence Performance Research

    What can old recordings tell us about performance style?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Period-Instrument RevivalTreatise-Based Performance DoctrineTuning and Temperament ReconstructionBody and Technique ReconstructionRhetoric and Affektenlehre StudiesEarly music revivalImprovisation and Ornamentation Recov…Authenticity DebateModern-Instrument Historically Inform…Global and Non-Canonical Performance …Recording-Evidence Performance Resear…

Beyond the field

Where Historical Performance Practice's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 33 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Historical Performance Practice is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 11 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Historical Performance Practice

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Music

See where Historical Performance Practice sits on the Map of Human Knowledge