- Atlas
- Philosophy
- Philosophy Of Music
Philosophy Of Music
Philosophy of music asks what music is, what it means, and why it moves us.
19 frameworks, from 500 BCE to today · Aesthetics · Philosophy
- Confucian Ritual Music Theory 500 BCE-1900
- Mimetic Theory of Music 400 BCE-1600
- Doctrine of the Affections 1600-1750
- Expression Theory of Music 1750-1850
- Absolute music 1790-1900
- Arousal Theory of Musical Expression 1850-1980
- Formalism 1854-Present
- Critical Theory of Music 1930-Present
- Resemblance Theory of Musical Expression 1940-Present
- Historical Ontology of the Musical Work 1950-Present
- Musical Universalism 1950-Present
- Expectation Theory 1956-Present
- Analytic Musical Ontology 1960-Present
- Cognitivist Theory of Musical Expression 1970-Present
- Cultural Constructivism 1970-Present
- Psychology of music 1970-Present
- Universalism versus Cultural Constructivism 1980-Present
- Global and Decolonial Philosophy of Music 1990-Present
- Simulation and Contagion Theory 1990-Present
Overview
Philosophy of music asks what music is, what it means, and why it moves us1. It is not music theory (how music is built) or music history (what happened when), though it borrows from both2. Its questions are philosophical: Is a piece of music a thing, a performance, or a pattern of sound? Does music express emotions, or merely arouse them in listeners? Can instrumental music mean anything without words, and if so, what? Are musical responses universal or learned? These questions matter because music is among the most pervasive and emotionally powerful human practices, yet its power is strangely resistant to explanation. The history of the field is a sequence of attempts to say what that power consists in.
Ancient Foundations: Imitation and Cosmic Order
The earliest systematic philosophy of music in the West came from Plato and Aristotle, who treated music as a form of mimesis—imitation. For Plato, music imitated the harmonies of the cosmos and could shape the character of the soul; certain modes were to be banned from the ideal city because they fostered disorder. Aristotle, in the Politics, was more empirical: music imitates states of character and emotion, and its ethical effects depend on how it is used. This mimetic theory of music—the idea that music is meaningful because it imitates something—dominated ancient and medieval thought. In China, Confucian thought developed a parallel but distinct tradition: ritual music (yue) was understood as a means of harmonizing society and cultivating virtue, while Daoist writers questioned whether the finest music could be heard at all. These traditions were not in dialogue, but both treated music as ethically and cosmologically significant rather than as mere entertainment.
The Rise of Expression: From Affections to Romantic Metaphysics
During the Baroque period, European theorists developed the doctrine of the affections, holding that music could represent specific emotional states through conventional figures and rhythms. This was still broadly mimetic: music copied the motions of the passions3. The decisive break came in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, when composers and critics began to treat instrumental music—music without words, program, or function—as the highest form of the art. The Romantic metaphysics of instrumental music, articulated by writers such as E. T. A. Hoffmann and later Arthur Schopenhauer, held that absolute music revealed the inner nature of reality itself, bypassing concepts entirely. Schopenhauer argued that music expressed the Will—the blind striving underlying all existence—more directly than any other art4. This was a radical claim: music did not imitate emotion; it gave voice to something deeper than emotion.
The expression theory of music grew from this soil. Its central claim is that music expresses emotions—that a passage can be sad or joyful in something like the way a person's bearing can be. But what does "expresses" mean here? One answer, the arousal theory, held that music expresses an emotion by arousing it in the listener5. If a piece makes you feel sad, it is sad. This view, associated with writers such as Edmund Gurney in the nineteenth century, faced an obvious objection: we can recognize that a piece is sad without feeling sad, and we can feel sad without the music being sad. A rival account, the expression theory proper, held that music expresses emotion by resembling its outward symptoms—its gestures, its tempo, its dynamics. This resemblance theory, developed in the twentieth century by Susanne Langer and others, treated music as a symbol of emotional life rather than a cause of it.
Formalism and the Autonomy of Music
Against all expression theories, musical formalism insisted that music's value lies in its form—its patterns of melody, harmony, rhythm, and structure—not in any emotional content6. The most influential statement came from Eduard Hanslick, whose On the Musically Beautiful (1854) argued that music is a "tonally moving form" and that the emotions it supposedly expresses are merely the effect of formal relations. Hanslick's target was the Romantic view that music revealed metaphysical depths; his alternative was austere. Formalism was later refined by analytic philosophers, most notably in the twentieth century, who distinguished the formal properties of a work from its expressive ones and asked whether the latter could be reduced to the former. The debate between formalism and expressionism remains one of the field's central axes.
Analytic Philosophy and the Ontology of the Work
In the twentieth century, philosophy of music became increasingly analytic, asking precise questions about the nature of musical works. The historical ontology of the musical work is the study of how the concept of a "work" emerged and changed. In the Western classical tradition, the idea that a piece of music is a stable, repeatable entity—something that can be performed many times yet remain the same work—is relatively recent, crystallizing around the late eighteenth century with the rise of the public concert and the cult of the composer. Before that, music was often conceived as a practice or an occasion rather than a fixed object. This historical shift matters because it shapes what we mean when we ask whether a performance is "faithful" to a work.
Musical ontology asks what kind of thing a musical work is1. Is it a physical object (a score, a sound event)? A mental object (an idea in the composer's mind)? A type of which performances are tokens? The most influential answer, developed by analytic philosophers such as Jerrold Levinson and Peter Kivy, treats a work as a type—an abstract structure or a pattern of sounds—that is instantiated in performances. But this raises problems: which properties of a performance count as part of the work, and which are merely interpretive additions? The debate continues, with some philosophers arguing that works are essentially historical entities, defined by the conventions and intentions of their time.
Cognitivism and the Cognitive Turn
A major development in the late twentieth century was the rise of cognitivist theories of musical expression. Where arousal theories located emotion in the listener's response and expression theories in the music's resemblance to emotional behavior, cognitivism held that music expresses emotion by presenting it in a way that can be cognized—recognized and understood—without necessarily being felt. The cognitivist theory of musical expression, associated with philosophers such as Peter Kivy and Stephen Davies, argues that music can be sad in the way a face can be sad: it has the appearance of emotion, and we recognize that appearance. This view preserves the intuition that music is meaningful while avoiding the problems of both arousal and simple resemblance theories.
A related development was expectation theory, which holds that musical meaning arises from the way music fulfills, delays, or frustrates our expectations1. Developed in the late twentieth century by Leonard Meyer and later refined by David Huron, this approach treats music as a system of probabilities: a cadence feels conclusive because it resolves tensions set up earlier; a modulation surprises because it violates learned patterns. Expectation theory connects philosophy of music to empirical psychology and has become one of the most productive frameworks for explaining how music generates emotional response.
Empirical Aesthetics and Music Cognition
The late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries saw a growing alliance between philosophy of music and the empirical sciences7. Music cognition and empirical aesthetics study how listeners perceive, remember, and respond to music, using experiments to test philosophical claims. Does music arouse emotion, and if so, how? Do listeners across cultures share basic responses to consonance and dissonance, or are these learned? The simulation and contagion theory of musical expression—the idea that listeners internally simulate the emotional gestures they hear, or "catch" emotions from music as they might from a crowd—draws on findings from neuroscience and psychology. These empirical approaches have not settled the philosophical questions, but they have made them more precise.
Universalism, Constructivism, and the Global Turn
A persistent question is whether musical meaning is universal or culturally constructed. Universalism holds that certain musical features—such as the association of major keys with happiness or the emotional power of rhythm—are grounded in human biology or cognition. Cultural constructivism holds that musical meaning is entirely a product of cultural convention, so that what sounds joyful in one tradition may sound mournful in another. The debate is not new, but it has been transformed by the global and decolonial philosophy of music, which challenges the Eurocentrism of the field. Scholars have pointed out that the Western classical tradition's assumptions about works, composers, and listeners are not universal; they are historically specific. This has led to a broader comparative aesthetics, asking how different traditions—Indian raga, Javanese gamelan, West African drumming—conceive of musical meaning and value. The field is now more plural than at any point in its history.
Critical Theory and the Present
Critical theory of music, associated with the Frankfurt School and later with feminist and postcolonial critics, asks how music relates to power. Theodor Adorno's writings on music argued that musical form encodes social relations: the tensions and resolutions of tonal music mirror the tensions and resolutions of bourgeois society. Later critical theorists have examined how music shapes and is shaped by gender, race, and class. This approach has broadened the field's scope, bringing it into conversation with cultural studies and political philosophy.
Today, philosophy of music is a plural field. Analytic philosophers continue to debate ontology, expression, and meaning with precision. Empirically minded philosophers work alongside psychologists and neuroscientists. Critical and decolonial scholars insist that the field's traditional questions were shaped by a particular tradition and that other traditions ask different questions. The open questions remain: What is the relationship between musical structure and emotional response? Can music mean anything without words? And whose music, and whose listening, should philosophy of music take as its starting point?
References
- Philosophy of music (introduction, Meaning and purpose), Wikipedia
- Music theory, Wikipedia
- Doctrine of the affections (History and definition), Wikipedia
- Arthur Schopenhauer's aesthetics, Wikipedia
- Musical expression, Wikipedia
- Aesthetics of music, Wikipedia
- Music and emotion, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Philosophy Of Music
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 500 BCE-1900
Confucian Ritual Music Theory
How does ritual music cultivate virtue and harmonize society?
- 400 BCE-1600
Mimetic Theory of Music
What does music imitate, and how does it shape character?
- 1600-1750
Doctrine of the Affections
How can music represent specific emotional states?
- 1750-1850
Expression Theory of Music
How does music express the composer's inner feeling?
- 1790-1900
- 1850-1980
Arousal Theory of Musical Expression
Does music express emotion by arousing it in listeners?
- 1854-Present
- 1930-Present
Critical Theory of Music
How does music reflect and critique social power?
- 1940-Present
Resemblance Theory of Musical Expression
Does music resemble the gestures of emotional life?
- 1950-Present
Historical Ontology of the Musical Work
When and how did the musical work become a stable object?
- 1950-Present
- 1956-Present
Expectation Theory
How do fulfilled and frustrated expectations generate musical meaning?
- 1960-Present
- 1970-Present
Cognitivist Theory of Musical Expression
Can music present emotion to be recognized without being felt?
- 1970-Present
Cultural Constructivism
Is musical meaning entirely a product of cultural convention?
- 1970-Present
Psychology of music
How do listeners perceive, remember, and respond to music?
- 1980-Present
Universalism versus Cultural Constructivism
Is musical meaning universal or culturally constructed?
- 1990-Present
Global and Decolonial Philosophy of Music
Whose music and whose philosophy count as universal?
- 1990-Present
Simulation and Contagion Theory
Do listeners internally simulate the emotions they hear?
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Absolute music grew out of Expression Theory of Music
The Romantic metaphysics of instrumental music, articulated by Hoffmann and Schopenhauer, elevated wordless music as the art that reveals the inner nature of reality, giving absolute music its philosophical charter.
Carried by E. T. A. Hoffmann; Arthur Schopenhauer.
Formalism reacted against Absolute music
Hanslick's On the Musically Beautiful attacked the Romantic claim that music reveals metaphysical depths, arguing that its content is nothing but tonally moving form.
Carried by Eduard Hanslick; On the Musically Beautiful (1854).
Cognitivist Theory of Musical Expression grew out of Resemblance Theory of Musical Expression
Cognitivism refined the resemblance account by holding that music presents the appearance of emotion to be recognized, as a face is sad, without requiring the listener to feel it.
Carried by Peter Kivy; Stephen Davies.
Doctrine of the Affections grew out of Mimetic Theory of Music
Baroque theorists kept the mimetic premise that music imitates the motions of the passions but systematized it into a catalogue of conventional figures and rhythms tied to specific affections.
Carried by Athanasius Kircher; Musurgia Universalis (1650).
Expression Theory of Music reacted against Doctrine of the Affections
Romantic writers rejected the doctrine's conventional code of affections and recast instrumental music as expressing inward feeling rather than copying outward passion.
Carried by E. T. A. Hoffmann.
Arousal Theory of Musical Expression grew out of Expression Theory of Music
The arousal theory grew out of the expression theory's question of what 'expresses' means, answering that music expresses an emotion by arousing it in the listener.
Carried by Edmund Gurney.
Resemblance Theory of Musical Expression reacted against Arousal Theory of Musical Expression
Resemblance theorists rejected the arousal account because we can recognize a piece as sad without feeling sad, and instead treated music as a symbol resembling the gestures of emotional life.
Carried by Susanne Langer.
Cognitivist Theory of Musical Expression reacted against Arousal Theory of Musical Expression
Cognitivist theorists defined themselves against arousal theories, arguing that musical expressiveness is a perceived property of the music rather than a caused feeling in the listener.
Carried by Peter Kivy.
Analytic Musical Ontology influenced by Historical Ontology of the Musical Work
The historical study of how the concept of a musical work emerged fed into analytic ontology's debate over whether works are abstract types or historically defined entities.
Carried by Jerrold Levinson.
Global and Decolonial Philosophy of Music influenced by Universalism versus Cultural Constructivism
The universalism-versus-constructivism debate was taken up by global and decolonial philosophers, who used the constructivist side to challenge the Eurocentrism of the field.
Beyond the field
Where Philosophy Of Music's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 101 links.
Confucian Ritual Music Theory influenced Shi'er lü in Chinese Music
Confucian ritual music theory supplied the pitch-pipe cosmology and the moral-cosmological justification for the twelve-lü system; the Lüshi chunqiu and later Confucian writings tied the standard pitches to seasons and governance, which is the framework the shi'er lü encodes.
Carried by Lüshi chunqiu.
Mimetic Theory of Music grew out of Pythagorean-Platonic Ethos Theory in Music Aesthetics
The mimetic theory of music is the generalisation of Pythagorean-Platonic ethos theory: music imitates states of soul and thereby affects character. Later writers extended the imitation claim from ethos to the representation of passions and natural sounds.
Carried by Plato; Aristotle.
Doctrine of the Affections revived by Rhetoric and Affektenlehre Studies in Historical Performance Practice
The philosophical treatment of the doctrine of the affections was taken up again by later scholars who used its categories to interpret Baroque expression. The revival of Affektenlehre studies rests on this earlier body of theory.
Expression Theory of Music reacted against Doctrine of the Affections in Music Aesthetics
Expression theory arose in the late eighteenth century in opposition to the doctrine of the affections: instead of music exciting conventionalised passions, it was held to express the composer's or performer's feeling. Writers of the Sturm und Drang and early Romantic generation defined themselves against the Affektenlehre.
Carried by Johann Georg Sulzer; Johann Gottfried Herder.
Expression Theory of Music led to Expression Theory in Music Aesthetics
The expression theory of music, developed from the mid-eighteenth century, is the direct ancestor of the general expression theory; the later doctrine generalised music's expressive model to art at large.
Absolute music influenced Formalism in Music Aesthetics
The idea of absolute music, especially as formulated by Hanslick in Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (1854), supplied the core claim that music's content is purely musical form.
Carried by Eduard Hanslick; Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (1854).
Arousal Theory of Musical Expression grew out of Expression Theory in Music Aesthetics
The arousal theory is a branch of the broader expression theory of music, narrowing the question of expression to the listener's emotional response. It developed from nineteenth-century expression aesthetics by asking how music arouses feeling.
Formalism reacted against Expression Theory in Music Aesthetics
Hanslick's musical formalism defined itself against the expression theory of music, rejecting the claim that music's task is to arouse or depict emotions and insisting instead on the autonomy of musical form.
Carried by Eduard Hanslick; Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (1854).
Formalism grew out of Absolute music in Music Aesthetics
The idea of absolute music, developed in early nineteenth-century German aesthetics around E. T. A. Hoffmann and the symphony, was taken up and given its classic philosophical defence by Hanslick's formalism, which made absolute instrumental music the paradigm of musical value.
Carried by E. T. A. Hoffmann; Eduard Hanslick.
Critical Theory of Music grew out of Critical Theory in Continental Philosophy
The critical theory of music is a branch of Frankfurt critical theory, applying its critique of instrumental reason and the culture industry to musical production and reception, above all in Adorno's writings.
Carried by Theodor W. Adorno.
Critical Theory of Music grew out of Frankfurt School critical theory in Literary Theory
The critical theory of music grew directly out of Frankfurt School critical theory, whose members, especially Adorno, extended its social and ideological critique to music.
Carried by Theodor W. Adorno; Max Horkheimer.
Analytic Musical Ontology grew out of Analytic Aesthetics in Philosophy Of Art
Analytic musical ontology grew out of analytic aesthetics as that field turned to music: Goodman's Languages of Art (1968) and the Danto/Dickie debates set the terms, and philosophers of music applied them to works and performances.
Carried by Nelson Goodman; Languages of Art (1968).

Philosophy Of Music is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 19 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Philosophy Of MusicRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Music Aesthetics 35 links
- Music Cognition 21 links
- Sound Studies 6 links
- Philosophy Of Art 6 links
- Chinese Music 5 links
- Philosophy Of Emotion 5 links
- Western Classical Music 4 links
- Aesthetics 4 links
- African Music 2 links
- Ethnomusicology 2 links
- Opera 2 links
- African Philosophy 2 links
More in Aesthetics
- Aesthetic Experience
- Aesthetics
- Environmental Aesthetics
- Everyday Aesthetics
- Philosophy Of Art
- Philosophy Of Literature
See where Philosophy Of Music sits on the Map of Human Knowledge