History Of Emotions

The history of emotions is the study of how people in the past felt, expressed, named, and judged feelings—and how those feelings changed over time.

9 frameworks, from 1929 to today · Cultural History · History

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

The history of emotions is the study of how people in the past felt, expressed, named, and judged feelings—and how those feelings changed over time1. Its wager is that emotions are not fixed biological constants that history merely clothes in different costumes1. Love, anger, grief, fear, shame, and joy have been experienced and displayed differently in different societies, and the vocabulary available to a person shapes what they can feel and how they can show it. This matters because emotions are where private experience meets public order: they bind families, fuel revolts, seal oaths, and police behaviour. To study them historically is to ask what a society thought a person should feel, what it feared in feeling, and how ordinary people actually navigated those expectations.

From the History of Mentalities to the History of Sensibilities

The subfield grew out of the French history of mentalities (histoire des mentalités), the Annales-school project of reconstructing the collective mental equipment of past societies—the unspoken assumptions, habits of thought, and emotional reflexes that people took for granted. Where political history counted decisions, the history of mentalities asked what a medieval peasant or an eighteenth-century burgher simply assumed about the world. Its practitioners worked from wills, sermons, court records, and literature, reading them for what they revealed about shared outlooks rather than individual opinions.

Emotions entered this project gradually. Early Annales historians such as Lucien Febvre wrote in the 1940s about sensibility and the "mental tools" available to people in a given era, arguing that even the capacity for certain feelings depended on the conceptual equipment a culture provided. The most influential single work in this vein was Philippe Ariès's L'Enfant et la vie familiale sous l'Ancien Régime (1960), which traced changing attitudes toward childhood and death, and his later studies of mourning and the "history of death." Ariès's methods were impressionistic and his chronology contested, but he established that intimate emotional life had a history worth writing.

By the 1970s and 1980s, historians of the body and the senses—working alongside the history of mentalities—were showing that even physical experience is mediated by culture. Studies of gesture, posture, table manners (building on Norbert Elias's The Civilizing Process, published in German in 1939 and translated into English in 1978–82), and the senses argued that how people held themselves, ate, and perceived the world changed across centuries. This work gave the history of emotions a material and bodily dimension: feelings are felt in bodies, and bodies are trained by societies.

Emotionology and the Codification of Feeling

A decisive turn came in the 1980s with the concept of emotionology, introduced by Peter N. Stearns and Carol Z. Stearns. Emotionology names the standards a society holds about which emotions are appropriate, how intensely they should be felt, and how they should be expressed—the official or semi-official emotional rulebook, as distinct from what people actually felt2. The Stearnses used the term to study changing American advice literature, etiquette books, and child-rearing manuals, tracing, for example, a long decline in the acceptability of anger in middle-class American life from the nineteenth century onward, and a corresponding rise in the value placed on emotional control.

The concept was powerful because it separated prescription from experience: one could study what a society said about feeling without claiming direct access to inner states. It also made emotions legible in ordinary sources—magazines, manuals, sermons—that historians had previously mined for other purposes. Critics later objected that emotionology could flatten the gap between what was preached and what was lived, and that the Stearnses' focus on American middle-class norms was narrower than the term implied. But the concept gave the field a workable object of study and a method.

Emotional Communities and Emotional Regimes

The next major reframing came from Barbara H. Rosenwein, whose work on early medieval Europe led her to propose emotional communities: groups—families, monasteries, courts, congregations—that share systems of feeling, valuing some emotions and suppressing others, and that define what counts as appropriate expression. Rosenwein's point was that societies are not emotionally uniform; they contain multiple overlapping communities with different emotional styles, and individuals move among them. Her study of early medieval Francia showed, for instance, that monastic communities cultivated distinct emotional norms from those of warrior aristocracies, and that these norms can be recovered from texts such as letters, chronicles, and saints' lives.

Working in a related direction, William M. Reddy proposed the concept of the emotional regime: the set of normative emotions and official rituals of expression that a political order requires or fosters, together with the emotives—first-person emotional statements such as "I am angry" or "I love you"—through which people navigate and sometimes resist that regime. Reddy's key claim, developed in The Navigation of Feeling (2001), was that emotives are not mere descriptions of inner states but acts that can change those states: saying "I am calm" in a tense moment may actually calm you, or may fail to, and the gap between claim and feeling is where emotional life becomes historically visible13. He used this framework to explain the emotional culture of late eighteenth-century France and the transition from a courtly regime of emotional control to a more expressive, sentimental one.

These two concepts—emotional communities and emotional regimes—became the field's most widely used tools. They allowed historians to study emotions as social and political phenomena without reducing them to either biology or discourse, and they made it possible to compare emotional worlds across periods and places.

The Linguistic and Practice Turns

Running through all of this was a methodological debate about language. The linguistic turn in cultural history—the argument, associated with figures such as Hayden White and Dominick LaCapra, that historical sources are themselves shaped by rhetorical conventions and that historians cannot simply read through them to reality—pushed historians of emotion to ask how far the vocabulary of feeling in a given period actually corresponded to felt experience. If a medieval text speaks of acedia (a kind of spiritual sluggishness or despair), does that mean people felt something we would call depression, or something categorically different? Historians split between those who treated emotional vocabulary as constitutive—you can only feel what your language lets you feel—and those who insisted on a core of bodily experience that language merely labels.

A related development was the turn toward practice and everyday life, influenced by German Alltagsgeschichte (the history of everyday life) and by anthropological work on ritual and performance. Historians began to study emotions not only as ideas or norms but as things people did: weeping in public, swearing oaths, exchanging gifts, staging quarrels, mourning in prescribed ways. This approach treated emotional performances as social actions with consequences, and it drew attention to the gap between prescribed and actual behaviour—the space where people improvised, resisted, or failed to feel what they were supposed to.

Global and Comparative Perspectives

For most of its history the field was heavily European and North American in its sources and assumptions. From the 2000s onward, historians pushed toward a global and comparative history of emotions, asking whether the concepts developed for Latin Christendom—emotional communities, regimes, emotives—travel to other societies, and what happens when they do not. Work on Chinese, Japanese, Indian, Islamic, and African emotional traditions showed both the reach and the limits of the European vocabulary. Comparative studies of grief, honor, shame, and anger across societies raised the question of whether there are universal emotions at all, or whether the very category of "emotion" is a modern Western invention—a point pressed by historians who note that the word "emotion" in its current sense is relatively recent in European languages, and that earlier vocabularies of feeling (passions, affections, sentiments, humors) organized experience differently.

This global turn also brought the field into conversation with anthropology and with the history of colonialism, where emotional norms were part of what was imposed, negotiated, and resisted. Studies of missionary attempts to reform indigenous emotional life, of colonial courts' handling of honor and shame, and of the emotional dimensions of slavery and its aftermath extended the field's reach and complicated its categories.

The Field Today

Contemporary history of emotions is plural in method and increasingly global in scope. Its practitioners work from letters, diaries, court records, sermons, literature, images, and material objects; they combine close reading with attention to ritual, body, and practice; and they draw on psychology and anthropology while remaining wary of presentism—the temptation to project modern emotional categories onto the past. The core concepts—emotional communities, emotional regimes, emotives, emotionology—remain in active use, often revised and combined1. The open questions are substantial: how far emotional experience is shaped by language, whether comparison across cultures is possible without imposing Western categories, how to write the history of feelings that left no written trace, and how the history of emotions relates to the history of the body, the senses, and material life. The field's enduring contribution is to have shown that feeling is not outside history but one of its central substances.

References

  1. History of emotions (introduction, Scope, William Reddy: emotives and emotional regimes, Methodology, Approaches to the History of Emotions), Wikipedia
  2. Peter Stearns (Emotionology), Wikipedia
  3. William Reddy, Wikipedia

The frameworks of History Of Emotions

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1929-1985

    History of mentalities

    What unspoken assumptions shaped past societies' outlooks?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1941-1990

    History of sensibilities

    How have shared ways of feeling changed over time?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1980-Present

    History of everyday life and practice

    How did ordinary people live and act day to day?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1980-Present
  5. 1985-Present

    Emotionology

    What emotional standards did societies prescribe?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1990-Present

    History of the Body and the Senses

    How is bodily and sensory experience shaped by culture?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1998-Present

    Emotional communities

    Which groups share systems of feeling?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 2000-Present
  9. 2001-Present

    Emotion regime

    How do political orders require and foster emotions?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

History of mentalitiesHistory of sensibilitiesHistory of everyday life and practiceLinguistic turn in the history of emo…EmotionologyHistory of the Body and the SensesEmotional communitiesGlobal and comparative history of emo…Emotion regime

Beyond the field

Where History Of Emotions's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 47 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

History Of Emotions is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 9 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on History Of Emotions

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Cultural History

See where History Of Emotions sits on the Map of Human Knowledge