- Atlas
- Philosophy
- Philosophy Of Emotion
Philosophy Of Emotion
Emotions are everywhere in human life and strangely hard to pin down.
17 frameworks, from 500 BCE to today · Philosophy Of Mind · Philosophy
- Non-Western Contemplative Traditions 500 BCE-Present
- Confucian and Daoist relational accounts 400 BCE-Present
- Aristotelian affection theory 350 BCE-Present
- Buddhist Abhidharma psychology 300 BCE-Present
- Stoic passions 300 BCE-Present
- Scholastic passions theory 1250-1600
- Passions of the Soul 1649-1750
- Humean motivational primacy 1739-Present
- Evolutionary expression theory 1872-Present
- Feeling Theories 1884-Present
- James–Lange theory 1884-Present
- Appraisal theory 1960-Present
- Cognitivist theories 1963-Present
- Perceptual theory 1987-Present
- Enactive and embodied approaches 1990-Present
- Theory of constructed emotion 1990-Present
- Embodied appraisal theory 2004-Present
Overview
Emotions are everywhere in human life and strangely hard to pin down. Fear seems to be about something—a snake, a diagnosis—yet it also floods the body with a racing heart and a cold stomach. Anger can be a judgment that one has been wronged, and also a heat that rises before any judgment is formed. The philosophy of emotion asks what an emotion is: whether it belongs to the body or the mind, whether it is a feeling, a thought, a perception, an action-tendency, or some construction out of several of these; whether emotions are the same across cultures or shaped by them; and whether they can be rational or are simply forces that reason must manage. These questions matter because almost every other part of philosophy—ethics, action theory, philosophy of mind, aesthetics—leans on some picture of what emotions are and what they do.
Ancient Foundations: Emotion as Judgment and as Force
The Western tradition begins with a split that has never quite closed. Plato, in the Republic and Phaedrus, pictured the soul as a charioteer (reason) driving two horses, one spirited and one appetitive. Emotion, on this picture, is a non-rational part of the soul that can be trained but not argued with directly. Aristotle gave a more integrated account. In the Rhetoric he analyzed the emotions as states that involve belief: anger, he said, is a desire for revenge accompanied by a belief that one has been slighted. In the Nicomachean Ethics he treated emotions as capacities to feel things in the right way, at the right time, toward the right objects—so that virtue lies in feeling well, not in feeling nothing1. This is the root of what later readers call Aristotelian affection theory: emotions are not blind impulses but are bound up with how we take the world to be.
The Stoics pushed the cognitive side much further. For them, an emotion (a pathos) just is a judgment—typically a false judgment about what is good or bad and within our control1. Grief, on this view, involves the judgment that something genuinely valuable has been lost; fear involves the judgment that a future evil is impending. Because emotions are judgments, the Stoics held they could in principle be corrected by reason, and the sage would be free of them. This is the root of Stoic cognitivism: the claim that emotion is, or essentially involves, evaluative belief. It set the terms for nearly two thousand years of debate.
Medieval and Early Modern Transformations
Thomas Aquinas absorbed Aristotle into Christian theology and produced a systematic account of the passions (the medieval term for emotions, especially those involving bodily change). For Aquinas, passions belong to the sensory appetite—they are movements of the sensitive soul toward or away from perceived goods and evils—and they are distinct from the intellectual operations of will and reason, though they can be guided by them. Love, desire, pleasure, hate, aversion, and pain are the basic passions, and the "irascible" passions such as hope and anger arise when obstacles appear. Aquinas's scheme was taught in universities for centuries and remains a reference point for anyone asking how emotion relates to virtue.
René Descartes broke with the scholastic framework. In The Passions of the Soul (1649) he treated the passions as perceptions caused by the "animal spirits"—fine material particles flowing through the nerves—and located them in the pineal gland, where soul and body interact. There were six primitive passions (wonder, love, hatred, desire, joy, sadness), and all others were compounds. What matters philosophically is that Descartes made emotion a psychophysical phenomenon: a state of the soul caused by the body, felt as a distinctive quality, and yet capable of being shaped by thought. This is the root of Cartesian passions theory, and it set up the modern problem of how a feeling can also be a cognition.
David Hume took a different route. In the Treatise of Human Nature (1739–40) he argued that reason alone cannot move us to act: "reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions." Beliefs about matters of fact can inform our desires, but only a passion—a feeling of pleasure or pain, desire or aversion—can supply a motive. This is Humean motivational primacy: emotion, not reason, is the source of action. Hume's account also made emotion a species of feeling, distinguished by the ideas that accompany it, and it made sympathy—the communication of feeling from one person to another—central to morality.
The Nineteenth Century: Feeling, Expression, and the Body
The nineteenth century turned toward the physiology of emotion. Charles Darwin's The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872) argued that emotional expressions are vestiges of once-useful actions, shared with other animals and continuous across species. This naturalized emotion and opened the way for evolutionary and comparative study.
Then came the most famous intervention in the field's history. In the 1880s, William James (and independently the Danish physician Carl Lange) proposed that the bodily changes come first and the feeling follows: we do not tremble because we are afraid, we are afraid because we tremble1. James's Principles of Psychology (1890) made emotion a feeling of bodily changes—a perception of the visceral and motor state. This is the classic feeling theory, and it had the virtue of explaining why emotions feel the way they do while locating them squarely in the body. It also provoked a long counter-tradition: Walter Cannon argued in the 1920s that the viscera are too slow and too undifferentiated to distinguish emotions, and that the brain must be doing more of the work.
The Cognitive Revolution and Its Critics
The mid-twentieth century brought behaviorism, which for a time made emotion a taboo topic—an inner state not amenable to scientific study. The cognitive revolution of the 1950s and 1960s reopened the question. In philosophy, the decisive move was to treat emotions as intentional states: states that are about something and that involve appraisal or evaluation. Anthony Kenny's Action, Emotion and Will (1963) argued that emotions are not mere feelings but are structured by their objects—fear is fear of something, and that "of" is essential. Robert Solomon and, later, Martha Nussbaum developed cognitivist theories in which emotions are judgments or evaluative appraisals. Nussbaum's Upheavals of Thought (2001) argued that emotions are forms of evaluative thought, often about what matters to one's flourishing, and that they can be assessed for rationality.
Cognitivism had an obvious problem: emotions often seem to outrun our judgments. You can know a spider is harmless and still feel terror. The perceptual theory of emotion, developed by Ronald de Sousa and others from the 1980s onward, answered this by modeling emotions on perception rather than belief. On this view, an emotion is a way of seeing a situation as salient—as dangerous, as an insult, as a loss—and like perception it can be recalcitrant to belief. De Sousa's The Rationality of Emotion (1987) argued that emotions are the mind's way of framing what matters, and that they have a kind of rationality even when they conflict with judgment.
A parallel development came from psychology. Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer's experiments in the early 1960s suggested that physiological arousal plus a cognitive label produces an emotion, and appraisal theorists such as Magda Arnold and Richard Lazarus built detailed accounts of how we evaluate situations as relevant to our goals. In philosophy, embodied appraisal theory—associated especially with Jesse Prinz—combined the Jamesian insight that emotions are bodily feelings with the cognitivist insight that they represent evaluative content: a bodily feeling can represent danger because it was reliably caused by danger in the past.
Construction, Embodiment, and the Present Landscape
The late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries saw a challenge to the assumption that emotions are natural kinds with fixed essences. Psychological constructionism, most prominently associated with Lisa Feldman Barrett, argues that emotions are not discrete entities triggered by specific mechanisms but are constructed in the moment from more basic ingredients—interoceptive sensations, conceptual knowledge, and cultural categories12. On Barrett's theory of constructed emotion, the brain predicts and categorizes bodily states, and what we call "anger" or "fear" is a culturally shaped category imposed on that flux. This view has been controversial but has forced the field to take seriously the variability of emotion across cultures and the role of language and learning.
Enactive and embodied approaches push further in the same direction. Drawing on phenomenology (Merleau-Ponty, Husserl) and on enactivism in cognitive science, these approaches treat emotions not as inner states but as ways the whole organism engages with its situation—patterns of action readiness, bodily orientation, and affective attunement. On this view, to be angry is not to have a certain feeling plus a certain belief but to be poised to act in a certain way toward a certain object, with the body already involved. This connects the philosophy of emotion to the philosophy of action and to embodied cognition more broadly.
Meanwhile, the field has become global in scope. Non-Western contemplative traditions have entered the conversation not as curiosities but as sophisticated analyses of emotion. Buddhist Abhidharma psychology, for instance, catalogs mental factors in fine detail and treats certain emotions—such as compassion—as cultivable and cognitively structured; the practice of mindfulness involves observing affective states as they arise, which has fed directly into contemporary debates about whether emotions are constructed or discovered. Confucian and Daoist traditions offer accounts of emotion as relational and as harmonized with a larger order, challenging the individualistic assumptions of much Western theorizing. Comparative work now asks whether "emotion" is even a single cross-cultural category.
Today the field is plural. Cognitivist and perceptual theories remain central, but they are increasingly supplemented by constructionist, embodied, and enactive accounts, and by empirical work from psychology and neuroscience. The old questions persist—is emotion feeling, judgment, perception, or construction?—but they are now asked with more attention to culture, to the body, and to the possibility that the category of "emotion" itself may need to be rethought. What unites the field is the conviction that getting emotion right is essential to understanding mind, action, and value.
References
- Emotion (Pre-modern history, James–Lange theory, Notable theorists, Emergent explanation), Wikipedia
- Theory of constructed emotion, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Philosophy Of Emotion
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 500 BCE-Present
Non-Western Contemplative Traditions
How do contemplative practices transform emotional life?
- 400 BCE-Present
Confucian and Daoist relational accounts
How are emotions shaped by relationships and ritual?
- 350 BCE-Present
Aristotelian affection theory
When is feeling an emotion the right amount?
- 300 BCE-Present
Buddhist Abhidharma psychology
Which mental factors accompany each emotional state?
- 300 BCE-Present
- 1250-1600
Scholastic passions theory
How do bodily passions relate to will and reason?
- 1649-1750
- 1739-Present
- 1872-Present
Evolutionary expression theory
Why do we express emotions with our faces?
- 1884-Present
- 1884-Present
- 1960-Present
- 1963-Present
- 1987-Present
- 1990-Present
Enactive and embodied approaches
How does the lived body shape emotional sense-making?
- 1990-Present
Theory of constructed emotion
Are emotions built from more basic ingredients?
- 2004-Present
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Scholastic passions theory influenced by Aristotelian affection theory
Aquinas absorbed Aristotle's account of the emotions as bound up with belief and with the sensory appetite, recasting it within Christian theology as the doctrine of the passions. The scholastic scheme of concupiscible and irascible passions is a direct development of Aristotelian affection theory.
Carried by Thomas Aquinas; Summa Theologiae.
Passions of the Soul reacted against Scholastic passions theory
Descartes explicitly set aside the scholastic doctrine of the sensitive soul and its passions, replacing it with a mechanistic psychophysics of animal spirits and the pineal gland. The Passions of the Soul defines itself against the Aristotelian-Thomistic framework it was taught.
Carried by René Descartes; The Passions of the Soul (1649).
Embodied appraisal theory revived James–Lange theory
Prinz's embodied appraisal theory deliberately revives the James–Lange thesis that emotions are perceptions of bodily changes, adding that such perceptions can represent evaluative properties. It is a self-conscious return to James against purely cognitivist accounts.
Carried by Jesse Prinz; Gut Reactions (2004).
Perceptual theory grew out of Cognitivist theories
The perceptual theory arose as a response to the cognitivist problem that emotions can outrun and conflict with our judgments. De Sousa modeled emotion on perception rather than belief precisely to explain recalcitrance while keeping evaluative content.
Carried by Ronald de Sousa; The Rationality of Emotion (1987).
Cognitivist theories influenced by Aristotelian affection theory
Cognitivists took from Aristotle the idea that emotions involve beliefs about their objects—anger as desire for revenge accompanied by a belief of slight—and that emotions can be assessed as fitting or unfitting. Nussbaum in particular builds her evaluative-thought account on Aristotelian affection theory.
Carried by Martha Nussbaum; Anthony Kenny.
Scholastic passions theory influenced by Stoic passions
Aquinas took over the Stoic idea that passions involve evaluative judgments about good and evil, while denying the Stoic claim that the sage is free of them. The scholastic passions are movements of the sensory appetite guided by reason, a modified Stoic cognitivism.
Carried by Thomas Aquinas.
Cognitivist theories revived Stoic passions
Cognitivist theories of emotion in the 1960s and after deliberately revived the Stoic thesis that emotions are or involve evaluative judgments. Solomon and Nussbaum explicitly drew on the Stoic identification of passion with judgment about what is good or bad.
Carried by Robert Solomon; Martha Nussbaum.
Humean motivational primacy influenced by Passions of the Soul
Hume inherited from the Cartesian and post-Cartesian tradition the picture of passions as felt perceptions distinct from reason, and built on it the claim that reason alone cannot motivate. His Treatise treats passions as impressions of reflection, a refinement of the Cartesian psychophysics of feeling.
Carried by David Hume; A Treatise of Human Nature (1739).
Appraisal theory reacted against James–Lange theory
Appraisal theorists such as Arnold and Lazarus rejected the Jamesian claim that undifferentiated bodily arousal is sufficient for emotion, arguing that cognitive evaluation of the situation is required. Schachter and Singer's experiments were framed as showing that arousal plus a cognitive label produces emotion, against pure feeling theory.
Carried by Magda Arnold; Richard Lazarus; Stanley Schachter.
Cognitivist theories reacted against James–Lange theory
Kenny's Action, Emotion and Will argued against treating emotions as mere feelings of bodily change, insisting that emotions are intentional states structured by their objects. This cognitivist move defined itself in opposition to the Jamesian feeling tradition.
Carried by Anthony Kenny; Action, Emotion and Will (1963).
Enactive and embodied approaches revived James–Lange theory
Enactive and embodied approaches revive the Jamesian emphasis on the body as constitutive of emotion, drawing also on phenomenology, against cognitivist and appraisal accounts that treat the body as mere output. The felt, lived body returns as the site of emotional sense-making.
Theory of constructed emotion reacted against James–Lange theory
Barrett's theory of constructed emotion rejects the classical view that emotions are discrete natural kinds with dedicated bodily signatures, a view she associates with the Jamesian tradition of basic emotion. Constructionism defines itself against the assumption of fixed emotion essences.
Carried by Lisa Feldman Barrett.
Embodied appraisal theory influenced by Appraisal theory
Prinz's embodied appraisal theory takes the appraisal-theory insight that emotions represent evaluative content relevant to goals and combines it with the Jamesian claim that this content is carried by bodily feelings. The appraisal tradition supplies the representational structure; James supplies the vehicle.
Carried by Jesse Prinz.
Embodied appraisal theory reacted against Cognitivist theories
Prinz's theory is framed against disembodied cognitivism: it accepts that emotions represent evaluations but denies that this requires judgment or thought, locating the representation in bodily feeling instead. It thus defines itself by rejecting the pure cognitivist picture.
Carried by Jesse Prinz.
Feeling Theories influenced by Evolutionary expression theory
Darwin's naturalization of emotional expression as vestigial action helped make emotion a bodily, physiological phenomenon fit for scientific study, a background condition for James's feeling theory. The link is real but indirect: James does not build directly on Darwin's expression theory.
Carried by Charles Darwin; The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872).
Beyond the field
Where Philosophy Of Emotion's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 76 links.
Confucian and Daoist relational accounts grew out of Classical Confucian Ethics in Confucian Ethics
Classical Confucian ethics is the earlier core (Confucius, Mencius, Xunzi) out of which the broader Confucian ethics framework developed.
Carried by Confucius; Mencius; Xunzi.
Buddhist Abhidharma psychology grew out of Buddhist Philosophy in Indian Philosophy
Abhidharma psychology is a systematic branch of early Buddhist philosophy, elaborating its analysis of mind and experience.
Scholastic passions theory grew out of Scholastic Aristotelianism in Medieval Philosophy
Scholastic passions theory is a branch of Scholastic Aristotelianism, applying its hylomorphic psychology to the emotions.
Carried by Thomas Aquinas.
Scholastic passions theory influenced by Scholastic and Islamic faculty psychology in Philosophy Of Mind
Scholastic passions theory took its faculty psychology of appetites and powers from the Islamic and earlier scholastic faculty psychology, above all Avicenna's.
Carried by Avicenna; Thomas Aquinas.
Scholastic passions theory influenced by Platonic and Aristotelian psychology in Philosophy Of Mind
Scholastic passions theory inherits its account of the soul's parts and affections from Platonic and Aristotelian psychology as transmitted through Arabic and Latin commentaries.
Carried by Aristotle; Thomas Aquinas.
Passions of the Soul grew out of Cartesian Mechanism and Dualism in Philosophy Of Perception
The Passions of the Soul applies Cartesian mechanism and dualism to the emotions, explaining them through the motion of animal spirits in the nerves and brain while assigning the feeling itself to the immaterial soul. It is the psychological extension of the mechanical-dualist programme of the Discourse and Meditations.
Carried by René Descartes; Passions of the Soul (1649).
Passions of the Soul grew out of Cartesian substance dualism in Philosophy Of Mind
The Passions of the Soul is a direct outgrowth of Cartesian substance dualism, defining passions as perceptions of the soul occasioned by bodily motions under the mind-body union. The emotion theory is the psychological branch of the dualist metaphysics.
Carried by René Descartes; Passions of the Soul (1649).
Passions of the Soul grew out of Cartesian dualism in Metaphysics
Descartes's account of the passions presupposes his dualism of thinking substance and extended substance, and the Passions of the Soul is the systematic application of that metaphysics to the emotions. The work treats the passions as modes of the mind caused by the body's animal spirits.
Carried by René Descartes; Passions of the Soul (1649).
Passions of the Soul grew out of Cartesian Substance Dualism in Mental Causation And Physicalism
Descartes's Passions of the Soul is built directly on the substance dualism of the Meditations: the passions are defined as perceptions the soul receives through the union with the body, which presupposes the real distinction of mind and body. The treatise works out the interactionist psychology that Cartesian dualism required.
Carried by René Descartes; Passions of the Soul (1649).
Evolutionary expression theory grew out of Darwinian Evolutionary Approach in Animal Behavior
Darwin's evolutionary expression theory is a direct application of his Darwinian approach to animal behaviour, treating emotional expressions as inherited habits and vestiges shaped by natural and sexual selection. The Expression of the Emotions draws on comparative observations of animals and humans within that evolutionary framework.
Carried by Charles Darwin; The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872).
Evolutionary expression theory led to Discrete emotion theory in Psychology Of Emotion
Discrete emotion theory grew directly out of Darwin's evolutionary expression theory: the claim that a small set of basic emotions is evolved and universally expressed is a refinement of Darwin's thesis. Ekman, Izard and Tomkins built on it.
Carried by Charles Darwin; Paul Ekman; Silvan Tomkins.
James–Lange theory provoked Cannon–Bard Theory in Psychology Of Emotion
Cannon and Bard argued against the James–Lange claim that bodily changes precede and constitute emotion, showing that visceral responses are too slow and undifferentiated to generate distinct feelings. Their theory defined itself by rejecting James–Lange and relocating emotion to thalamic and hypothalamic processes.
Carried by Walter B. Cannon; Philip Bard.

Philosophy Of Emotion is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 17 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Philosophy Of EmotionRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Psychology Of Emotion 28 links
- Philosophy Of Music 5 links
- Philosophy Of Mind 5 links
- Philosophy Of Perception 4 links
- Ethics 3 links
- Philosophy Of Consciousness 3 links
- Reasoning Decision Making 2 links
- History Of Emotions 2 links
- Epistemology 2 links
- Moral Psychology 2 links
- Music Aesthetics 1 link
- Neuroeconomics 1 link
More in Philosophy Of Mind
- Mental Causation And Physicalism
- Mental Representation
- Philosophy Of Action
- Philosophy Of Consciousness
- Philosophy Of Mind
- Philosophy Of Perception
- Self Knowledge And Subjectivity
See where Philosophy Of Emotion sits on the Map of Human Knowledge