- Atlas
- Humanities
- Masculinity Studies
Masculinity Studies
Masculinity studies is the interdisciplinary study of men and manhood as gendered, historically variable, and socially produced—not as the unmarked human default.
16 frameworks, from 1930 to today · Gender & Sexuality Studies · Humanities
- Sex-Role Theory 1930-1980
- Sex-Role Strain 1975-1995
- Black Masculinity Studies 1980-Present
- Profeminist Men's Studies 1980-Present
- Social Constructionism 1980-Present
- Postcolonial and Transnational Masculinity Studies 1983-Present
- Hegemonic Masculinity 1985-Present
- Performativity and Doing Gender 1987-Present
- Men's health 1990-Present
- Mythopoetic Men's Movement 1990-2000
- Affect and Embodiment Studies 1995-Present
- Trans and Queer Masculinity Studies 1995-Present
- Intersectional Masculinity Studies 2000-Present
- Precarious Manhood Theory 2005-Present
- Digital Masculinity Studies 2010-Present
- Hybrid Masculinity 2010-Present
Overview
Masculinity studies is the interdisciplinary study of men and manhood as gendered, historically variable, and socially produced—not as the unmarked human default. Its practitioners ask how particular societies decide what a man is, which men get to count as real men, what those definitions cost the people who fail them, and how masculinities are bound up with power, race, class, sexuality, and empire. The field matters because the arrangements it studies are not private: they shape war, work, fatherhood, health, violence, and the distribution of authority. Its history is a sequence of arguments about where manhood comes from—biology, social roles, discourse, performance, or the body—and about whose manhood gets studied.
From Sex Roles to the Social Construction of Manhood
The intellectual groundwork lay in mid-twentieth-century sex-role theory, which held that societies assign men and women complementary "sex roles" and that boys learn masculinity through socialization and identification with fathers. Talcott Parsons's mid-century sociology treated the male instrumental role and the female expressive role as functional for the family. By the 1970s, feminist critics and the first "men's liberation" writers turned this framework against itself: if roles are learned, they can be questioned1. Joseph Pleck's The Myth of Masculinity (1981) attacked what he called the "male sex role identity" paradigm—the assumption that healthy manhood depends on a boy's successful identification with a male model—and argued instead that masculinity is a set of socially imposed expectations that strain the men who must meet them. This "sex-role strain" idea reframed masculinity as a problem for men, not a fixed nature.
The decisive move came from social constructionism and gender history. In the 1980s and 1990s historians showed that manhood has a history: ideals of the self-made man, the martial citizen, the breadwinner, and the "new man" succeeded one another as economies, wars, and family forms changed. The Australian sociologist R. W. Connell's Gender and Power (1987) and Masculinities (1995) supplied the field's central concept, hegemonic masculinity: the culturally dominant form of manhood that legitimates men's authority over women and over subordinate men, while most men live it only approximately. Connell's example was the strong, competitive, emotionally restrained breadwinner, sustained less by force than by cultural consent. The concept's power was that it explained hierarchy among men—not all men benefit equally—and it remains the field's most widely used and most debated term.
Profeminist Men's Studies and Its Rivals
By the 1980s a profeminist men's studies had taken shape, largely in the United States, Britain, and Australia, committed to studying men critically and in alliance with feminism rather than as a defensive "men's rights" project. Michael Kimmel's Manhood in America (1996) traced the recurring American anxiety of masculine "self-making," and his later work on "aggrieved entitlement" described the resentment of men who feel promised a status they no longer securely hold. Harry Brod and others argued that men, too, are gendered beings whose lives are distorted by patriarchy.
A rival current, the mythopoetic men's movement, flourished in the early 1990s around the poet Robert Bly's Iron John (1990). Drawing on Jungian psychology and fairy tale, it held that modern men had lost contact with a deep, initiatory masculinity and sought to recover it through retreats and mentorship by older men. Academic masculinity studies largely rejected its essentialism—its assumption of a timeless male core—but the movement's popularity marked how widely the "crisis of masculinity" had spread beyond the university.
Race, Empire, and the Plural Masculinities
A sustained critique from Black and postcolonial scholars reshaped the field. Black masculinity studies, developed from the 1980s onward by writers such as Robert Staples and later Michael Awkward and bell hooks, showed that the hegemonic ideal was implicitly white and that Black men had been figured in dominant culture as hypersexual, criminal, or absent—stereotypes with concrete consequences for policing, employment, and family policy. The field's attention to "cool pose" and to the pressures of proving manhood under racism made clear that masculinity is always racialized.
Postcolonial and transnational work extended the point globally. Ashis Nandy's The Intimate Enemy (1983) analyzed how colonialism worked through gender, producing the "hyper-masculine" colonizer and the "effeminate" colonized, and how anticolonial nationalism often answered by reasserting a purified manhood. Connell's later collaborative work with James Messerschmidt and others on "transnational business masculinity" and on masculinities "on the world stage" argued that global capitalism exports a managerial, mobile masculinity while local gender orders adapt or resist it. The concept of hybrid masculinity—developed by Tristan Bridges and C. J. Pascoe in the 2010s—described how men selectively adopt elements of feminist or gay style (the "sensitive" or "metrosexual" man) while leaving gender inequality intact, a strategy of borrowing without redistribution.
Discourse, Performativity, and the Body
The 1990s brought a linguistic and poststructuralist turn. Following Michel Foucault's account of sexuality as produced through discourse, and Judith Butler's Gender Trouble (1990), which argued that gender is performative—constituted through repeated stylized acts rather than expressing an inner essence—scholars analyzed how masculinities are made in talk, media, and institutional routine. The sociolinguist Michael Kimmel's and others' work on "doing gender" (from Candace West and Don Zimmerman's 1987 article) treated manhood as an accomplishment continually performed and policed. This approach made visible the fragility of masculinity: if it must be constantly demonstrated, it can always fail.
That fragility became a theory in its own right. Precarious manhood theory, advanced by Joseph Vandello and Jennifer Bosson in the 2000s, drew on psychological experiments showing that manhood, unlike womanhood, is treated as a status that must be earned and can be lost—men who fail at a task are more likely to be seen as less manly, and men respond to threats with aggression or risk-taking. Alongside this, affect and embodiment studies attended to what masculinity feels like and does to bodies: the discipline of the gym, the stoicism that blocks help-seeking, the shame and rage that accompany perceived humiliation. These strands fed directly into men's health research, which documented that men die earlier and use health services less, and debated whether the cause is biology, risk-taking, or the masculine norms that discourage vulnerability23.
Intersectionality, Trans, and Digital Turns
From the 2000s, intersectional masculinity studies insisted that manhood is always co-constituted with race, class, sexuality, disability, and nation—following Kimberlé Crenshaw's intersectionality framework—so that there is no generic "masculinity" but a field of positioned masculinities. Trans and queer masculinity studies complicated the equation of masculinity with maleness: trans men, butch women, and gender-nonconforming people all inhabit and remake masculine styles, showing that masculinity can be detached from male bodies and that the field's categories were never as stable as assumed. Queer theory's critique of the closet and of normative gender sharpened attention to gay masculinities and to the policing of effeminacy among men.
Most recently, digital masculinity studies has examined how online platforms produce and circulate masculinities—from "manosphere" forums and pickup-artist communities to the influencer economies of fitness and self-improvement, and the algorithmic amplification of grievance. These spaces have become primary sites where hegemonic and hybrid masculinities are negotiated, and where the field's older questions about proof, performance, and precarity reappear in new media.
The Field Today
Contemporary masculinity studies works across sociology, history, psychology, media studies, and public health, with hegemonic masculinity, intersectionality, and performativity as its most-used tools and precarious manhood and hybrid masculinity as active research programs. Its open questions are substantial: how to study masculinities beyond the Anglophone North without re-exporting a Western template; whether "hegemonic masculinity" has become too elastic to test; how to connect cultural analysis to measurable outcomes in health and violence prevention; and how trans and queer perspectives will continue to unsettle the field's founding distinction between men and masculinity.
References
- Men's liberation movement (History), Wikipedia
- Men's studies (Health), Wikipedia
- Men's health, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Masculinity Studies
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1930-1980
- 1975-1995
- 1980-Present
Black Masculinity Studies
How is manhood shaped by racism and racial stereotypes?
- 1980-Present
Profeminist Men's Studies
How can men study manhood critically alongside feminism?
- 1983-Present
Postcolonial and Transnational Masculinity Studies
How did empire and global capitalism shape masculinities?
- 1985-Present
Hegemonic Masculinity
Which form of manhood dominates and how does it hold power?
- 1987-Present
Performativity and Doing Gender
How is gender accomplished through repeated acts?
- 1990-Present
- 1990-2000
Mythopoetic Men's Movement
How can men recover a deep, initiatory masculinity?
- 1995-Present
Affect and Embodiment Studies
What does masculinity feel like and do to bodies?
- 1995-Present
Trans and Queer Masculinity Studies
Can masculinity exist apart from male bodies?
- 2000-Present
Intersectional Masculinity Studies
How do race, class and sexuality shape manhood together?
- 2005-Present
- 2010-Present
Digital Masculinity Studies
How do online platforms produce and spread masculinities?
- 2010-Present
Hybrid Masculinity
Why do men borrow feminist style without changing inequality?
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Sex-Role Strain reacted against Sex-Role Theory
Joseph Pleck's The Myth of Masculinity (1981) attacked the male sex-role identity paradigm of sex-role theory, arguing that masculinity is not an internalized role but a set of imposed expectations that strain men. Sex-role strain thus defined itself against sex-role theory's core assumption.
Carried by Joseph Pleck; The Myth of Masculinity (1981).
Social Constructionism replaced Sex-Role Theory
Social constructionism replaced sex-role theory's socialization model with the claim that manhood is historically and discursively produced. Gender historians and sociologists in the 1980s treated sex roles as a limiting case of socially constructed gender.
Carried by R. W. Connell; Gender and Power (1987).
Hegemonic Masculinity grew out of Social Constructionism
Hegemonic masculinity was built directly on social constructionist premises: Connell argued that masculinities are produced in gender relations and institutional power rather than given by biology or fixed roles. The concept generalized constructionism into a theory of dominant and subordinate masculinities.
Carried by R. W. Connell; Gender and Power (1987); Masculinities (1995).
Performativity and Doing Gender influenced by Social Constructionism
Butlers performativity extended the social constructionist and Foucauldian claim that gender is produced through discourse and repeated acts rather than expressing an inner essence. West and Zimmermans doing gender supplied the interactional method for treating manhood as an ongoing accomplishment.
Carried by Judith Butler; Gender Trouble (1990); Candace West.
Profeminist Men's Studies grew out of Sex-Role Theory
Profeminist men's studies grew out of the men's liberation current that had turned sex-role theory against itself, taking the idea that learned roles can be questioned and directing it to a critical, feminist-aligned study of men.
Carried by Joseph Pleck; Michael Kimmel.
Intersectional Masculinity Studies grew out of Black Masculinity Studies
Intersectional masculinity studies generalized the Black masculinity studies insight that the hegemonic ideal is implicitly white and that manhood is always racialized, extending the analysis to class, sexuality, disability and nation following Crenshaws framework.
Carried by bell hooks.
Mythopoetic Men's Movement rival of Profeminist Men's Studies
The mythopoetic men's movement and profeminist men's studies competed in the early 1990s over the meaning of the crisis of masculinity, the one seeking a timeless initiatory male core and the other studying men critically in alliance with feminism.
Carried by Robert Bly; Iron John (1990); Michael Kimmel.
Intersectional Masculinity Studies influenced by Postcolonial and Transnational Masculinity Studies
Postcolonial and transnational work established that masculinities are co-constituted with empire, nation and global capitalism, a premise intersectional masculinity studies took up and combined with race, class and sexuality analysis.
Carried by Ashis Nandy; R. W. Connell.
Intersectional Masculinity Studies influenced by Hegemonic Masculinity
Intersectional masculinity studies took hegemonic masculinitys account of hierarchy among men and pressed it to specify how race, class and other axes position men differently, arguing that no generic masculinity exists.
Carried by R. W. Connell.
Digital Masculinity Studies influenced by Hegemonic Masculinity
Digital masculinity studies took hegemonic masculinitys questions about proof, performance and hierarchy among men and applied them to online manosphere forums and influencer economies, where dominant and hybrid masculinities are negotiated.
Hybrid Masculinity grew out of Hegemonic Masculinity
Hybrid masculinity was developed by Bridges and Pascoe as a refinement of hegemonic masculinity, describing how men selectively borrow feminist or gay style while leaving gender inequality intact. It extends the hegemonic framework to strategies of borrowing without redistribution.
Carried by Tristan Bridges; C. J. Pascoe.
Trans and Queer Masculinity Studies influenced by Performativity and Doing Gender
Trans and queer masculinity studies drew on performativity to argue that masculinity can be detached from male bodies, since trans men, butch women and gender-nonconforming people inhabit and remake masculine styles through repeated acts.
Carried by Judith Butler.
Precarious Manhood Theory influenced by Performativity and Doing Gender
Precarious manhood theory took from performativity and doing gender the idea that manhood must be continually demonstrated and can always fail, and turned that fragility into a testable psychological claim about earning and losing manhood.
Carried by Joseph Vandello; Jennifer Bosson.
Beyond the field
Where Masculinity Studies's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 71 links.
Sex-Role Strain grew out of Gender role in Gender And Sexuality
Sex-role strain theory grew directly out of the mid-century gender-role literature, taking the idea of socially prescribed male and female roles and asking what happens when individuals cannot meet them. It refined role theory into an account of psychological conflict and its consequences.
Profeminist Men's Studies grew out of Feminist Theory in Gender & Sexuality Studies
Profeminist men's studies grew directly out of second-wave feminist theory, adopting its analysis of patriarchy and male power and turning it on men themselves. Men's studies defined its project as extending feminist critique to the study of masculinity.
Social Constructionism grew out of Social constructionism in Sociology
The sociology of social constructionism, above all Berger and Luckmann's account of the social construction of reality, is the direct source of the constructionist framework applied to masculinity. Masculinity scholars took its claim that categories are produced through social interaction and applied it to gender.
Carried by Peter L. Berger; Thomas Luckmann; The Social Construction of Reality (1966).
Postcolonial and Transnational Masculinity Studies grew out of Postcolonial and subaltern studies in Cultural Studies
Postcolonial and subaltern studies supplied the core analytical apparatus of postcolonial masculinity studies, including the critique of colonial representations and the recovery of subaltern agency. Scholars applied its concepts of colonial discourse and hybridity to the study of masculinities.
Carried by Edward Said; Orientalism (1978); Homi K. Bhabha.
Hegemonic Masculinity influenced Men's studies in Gender & Sexuality Studies
The concept of hegemonic masculinity, formulated by Connell and colleagues, became the central analytic tool of men's studies, organising its account of how particular masculinities are culturally exalted over others.
Carried by Raewyn Connell.
Hegemonic Masculinity influenced by Feminist Theory in Gender & Sexuality Studies
R. W. Connell built the concept of hegemonic masculinity on feminist analyses of patriarchy, especially the sex/gender system and critiques of male dominance, developing it in Gender and Power (1987). The idea was offered as a feminist-informed account of how men's power is reproduced.
Carried by Raewyn Connell; Gender and Power (1987).
Performativity and Doing Gender influenced Geographies of Masculinities in Feminist Geography
Butler's performativity and doing-gender framework supplied geographies of masculinities with the idea that gender is enacted rather than fixed.
Carried by Judith Butler.
Trans and Queer Masculinity Studies influenced by Transgender Studies in Sexuality Studies
Transgender studies, built on works such as Sandy Stone's The Empire Strikes Back (1987) and later transgender history and theory, supplied the foundational critique of the sex/gender binary that trans and queer masculinity studies adopted. The later field grew out of transgender studies' accounts of gender crossing and self-definition.
Carried by Sandy Stone; The Empire Strikes Back (1987).
Trans and Queer Masculinity Studies influenced by Queer Theory in Gender And Sexuality
Queer theory, especially Butler's performativity and the critique of stable identity categories, provided the conceptual tools for analysing queer and trans masculinities. Trans and queer masculinity studies took its anti-identitarian and performative account of gender.
Carried by Judith Butler.
Sex-Role Theory provoked Sex/Gender Distinction in Gender & Sexuality Studies
The sex/gender distinction was formulated partly in response to sex-role theory, separating the cultural script of the role from the biological category it was thought to attach to.
Sex-Role Theory led to Sex/Gender System Theory in Gender & Sexuality Studies
Sex/gender system theory grew out of and reworked sex-role theory, replacing the notion of learned roles with a structural account of the sex/gender system.
Sex-Role Theory influenced Men's studies in Gender & Sexuality Studies
Sex-role theory's vocabulary of learned masculine roles was inherited by men's studies, which then criticised and moved beyond the role framework toward relational conceptions of masculinity.

Masculinity Studies is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 16 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Masculinity StudiesRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Gender & Sexuality Studies 31 links
- Gender History 10 links
- Feminist Geography 4 links
- Sexuality Studies 2 links
- Trans Studies 2 links
- Public Health 2 links
- Gender And Sexuality 2 links
- Sociology 2 links
- Anthropology 1 link
- Cultural Anthropology 1 link
- Kinship And Relatedness 1 link
- Performance Studies 1 link
More in Gender & Sexuality Studies
See where Masculinity Studies sits on the Map of Human Knowledge