Mercantilism And Physiocracy

Before economics had a name, two rival bodies of thought tried to answer the same question: where does a nation's wealth come from, and how should a state go about increasing it?

6 frameworks, from 1500 to today · History Of Economic Thought · Economics

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Before economics had a name, two rival bodies of thought tried to answer the same question: where does a nation's wealth come from, and how should a state go about increasing it? The mercantilists, writing from roughly the sixteenth through the eighteenth centuries, answered that wealth meant treasure—gold and silver—and that the state should manage trade to accumulate it. The physiocrats, a small and tightly organized French school of the mid-eighteenth century, answered that wealth came from the land and that only agriculture produced a genuine surplus. Together these two traditions mark the moment when economic argument became a systematic subject: the mercantilists supplied the first working framework of state economic policy, and the physiocrats supplied the first self-consciously scientific model of an economy as a whole. Adam Smith learned from both and defined his own system against them, which is why they remain the starting point of any history of economic thought.

Bullionism: Treasure as the Measure of Wealth

The earliest stratum of mercantilist thinking is usually called bullionism, from bullion, meaning precious metal in bars or coin12. Its core claim was simple: a country's wealth consists in its stock of gold and silver, so policy should aim to keep that stock inside the country12. The practical expression was the fear of bullion draining abroad. In England, a royal commission under Thomas Mun's father, John Hales, produced the 1581 tract A Compendious or Briefe Examination of Certayne Ordinary Complaints, which worried that English money was being carried off by foreign traders and that the realm was importing too much. The remedy proposed was to restrict exports of coin and to require foreign merchants to spend their proceeds on English goods.

Bullionism's weakness was that it confused the stock of money with the flow of wealth. A country that hoards coin but cannot produce or trade will simply find its money bid away by those who can. The most famous early statement of the alternative is Thomas Mun's England's Treasure by Forraign Trade, written in the 1620s and published posthumously in 1664. Mun, a director of the East India Company, argued that England should not worry that the East India trade exported silver, because the goods it brought back were resold at a profit, so the net effect was to bring in more treasure than went out. The unit of account shifted from the single transaction to the whole national balance—the seed of the balance-of-trade idea.

Balance-of-Trade Mercantilism

The mature mercantilist position, which dominated European policy from the late sixteenth to the late eighteenth century, held that a nation should export more than it imports so that the difference is settled in precious metal. This is the balance-of-trade doctrine, and it is the heart of what historians call mercantilism. The reasoning was not merely about money: a favorable balance was thought to support employment, shipping, and military capacity, because exports kept domestic producers busy and a merchant marine could be converted to a navy.

The doctrine was elaborated by writers across Europe. In England, Charles Davenant and Josiah Child wrote on trade and the balance of payments; in France, the droit administratif of the state was built around it. The instrument was the tariff, the navigation act, and the monopoly charter. England's Navigation Acts, beginning in 1651, required that trade with English colonies be carried in English ships—a direct application of the idea that trade should serve national power13. The doctrine's internal difficulty was that one country's favorable balance is another's unfavorable one, so a world of mercantilist states was a world of conflict over a fixed pool of treasure1. That zero-sum premise is what the physiocrats and Smith attacked1.

Colbertism: The French State as Economic Manager

The most thoroughgoing practical application of mercantilist ideas was French, under Jean-Baptiste Colbert, controller-general of finances to Louis XIV from 1665 until his death in 1683. Colbertism is the name given to his program: build up French manufactures, especially luxury goods, so that France could export finished products and import raw materials; protect domestic industry with tariffs; charter trading companies; and develop the navy and colonies. Colbert founded the Manufacture des Gobelins and other royal workshops, subsidized lace and glassmaking, and used the Conseil de Commerce to coordinate policy. His aim was national self-sufficiency and a favorable balance, and his instruments were inspection, subsidy, and monopoly.

Colbertism shows both the ambition and the limits of mercantilist policy. It created industries and a fiscal apparatus, but it also produced a thicket of regulations that raised costs and provoked resistance; the French textile inspectors who measured cloth by the thread became a byword for bureaucratic interference. Colbert's system was the target of the physiocrats' most pointed criticism, because it favored urban manufactures over agriculture and treated the countryside as a source of revenue rather than of wealth.

Cameralism: The German Science of Administration

In the German-speaking lands, mercantilist ideas took a distinct form called cameralism, from the Kammer, the prince's treasury chamber. Cameralism was less a theory of trade than a science of state administration: how to manage the prince's domains, taxes, mines, forests, and manufactures so as to increase revenue and population. Its leading teachers held chairs at universities—Johann Heinrich Gottlob von Justi, who wrote widely on police, finance, and manufactures in the mid-eighteenth century, and Joseph von Sonnenfels in Vienna. Cameralist instruction was practical and encyclopedic, covering accounting, mining, agriculture, and what we would now call public administration.

Cameralism matters in the history of economics because it made economic knowledge a university subject and tied it to the training of officials. Its emphasis on population and on the productive use of land also prepared the ground for physiocratic ideas in German lands, where they were received with interest. But cameralism never developed a theory of the economy as a self-regulating system; it remained a handbook for the prince's servants.

Colonial and Imperial Mercantilism

Mercantilism's most consequential expression was imperial. The doctrine that colonies exist for the benefit of the mother country—supplying raw materials and buying finished goods—was written into the charters and navigation laws of the English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese empires. The English system after 1651 required colonial trade to pass through English ports and English ships; the Spanish flota system funneled American silver to Seville; the French exclusif reserved colonial trade to French merchants. The colonies were to run a favorable balance with the mother country, which meant an unfavorable one for themselves.

This system generated both revenue and resentment. The American colonies' resistance to the Navigation Acts and to the Stamp Act of 1765 was in part a revolt against mercantilist regulation, and Adam Smith's argument in The Wealth of Nations (1776) that colonies were a drain rather than a benefit was aimed directly at it. The imperial framework also produced the first sustained critiques of mercantilism from within the empire, as colonial writers pointed out that the balance-of-trade logic counted the colony's loss as the mother country's gain.

Physiocracy: The First Scientific Model of the Economy

Physiocracy—literally "rule of nature"—was a French school founded by François Quesnay, physician to Louis XV, and elaborated by a small circle including Victor Riqueti, marquis de Mirabeau, and Pierre Samuel du Pont de Nemours. Its central claim was that only agriculture produces a net product (in French, produit net): a surplus of output over the costs of production45. Manufacture and trade, on this view, merely transform or move wealth; they add no surplus45. Hence the physiocrats' policy program: tax the land, free the grain trade, and let nature's productivity do the work.

The school's masterwork is Quesnay's Tableau économique (1758), a diagram of the annual flow of wealth among three classes—the productive class (farmers), the proprietary class (landowners), and the sterile class (artisans and merchants). The Tableau is the first attempt to represent the economy as a circular flow, with the surplus passing from agriculture to landlords as rent and then back through spending. It is a genuine model, and it made physiocracy the first school of economics with a doctrine, a journal (Les Éphémérides du citoyen), and a policy platform.

The physiocrats' influence was out of proportion to their numbers. They coined the term laissez-faire—"let do," meaning let things take their course—and argued for free trade in grain against the Colbertist regulation of the food supply. Their claim that land is the sole source of surplus was wrong in the long run, but their insistence that the economy has an internal structure that can be analyzed as a whole was a permanent contribution. Smith met Quesnay and the physiocrats in Paris in 1765–66 and acknowledged the Tableau as an important attempt, even while rejecting the claim that agriculture alone is productive.

The Critique and the Transition to Classical Economics

The mercantilist and physiocratic systems were both displaced by the classical political economy of Adam Smith, but in different ways1. Smith's Wealth of Nations attacked mercantilism as a confusion of money with wealth and as a set of policies that served merchants and manufacturers at the expense of consumers. His argument that the division of labor and the extent of the market, not the balance of trade, determine a nation's wealth was a direct rebuttal of the balance-of-trade doctrine. Against the physiocrats, Smith accepted the idea of a surplus and the circular flow but denied that only agriculture is productive; he treated manufacturing as productive too, which opened the way for the classical growth model.

The mercantilist label itself is partly a later construction1. Smith used the term "mercantile system" to describe the policy regime he opposed, and nineteenth-century historians generalized it into a period1. Modern scholarship has qualified the picture: mercantilist writers were not uniformly bullionist, and some, like Mun, already reasoned in terms of the national balance1. The physiocrats, by contrast, were a self-conscious school with a founder and a doctrine, and their influence on the classical tradition—through the idea of the surplus, the circular flow, and laissez-faire—is direct14.

The Present: Living Legacies and Open Questions

Today the history of mercantilism and physiocracy is studied less as a museum of errors than as the origin of questions that remain live. The mercantilist concern with the balance of payments and with state management of trade reappears in debates over industrial policy, export-led growth, and strategic trade theory; the physiocratic idea of a surplus and of the economy as a circular flow is a remote ancestor of input-output analysis and of growth theory. The scholarly questions still open are about classification and context: how unified mercantilism really was, how much of it was theory versus administrative practice, and how the physiocrats' model should be read—as a technical diagram, a political program, or both. What is not in doubt is that these two traditions, one sprawling and practical, the other small and doctrinal, between them turned economic argument into a subject with schools, models, and policy consequences.

References

  1. Mercantilism (History, Policies, Theory, United Kingdom, Decline, Origins), Wikipedia
  2. Bullionism, Wikipedia
  3. Navigation Acts, Wikipedia
  4. Physiocracy, Wikipedia
  5. Tableau économique, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Mercantilism And Physiocracy

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1500-1650

    Bullionism

    How can a nation keep its gold and silver at home?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1580-1776

    Balance-of-Trade Mercantilism

    Should a nation export more than it imports?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1651-1776

    Colonial and Imperial Mercantilism

    Should colonies exist to serve the mother country?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1665-1750

    Colbertism

    How can the state build national industry and trade?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1700-1800

    Cameralism

    How should a prince manage his domains for revenue?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1756-1780

    Physiocracy

    Where does a nation's surplus actually come from?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

BullionismBalance-of-Trade MercantilismColonial and Imperial MercantilismColbertismCameralismPhysiocracy

Beyond the field

Where Mercantilism And Physiocracy's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 38 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Mercantilism And Physiocracy is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 6 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Mercantilism And Physiocracy

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in History Of Economic Thought

See where Mercantilism And Physiocracy sits on the Map of Human Knowledge