Archival Science

Archival science is the study of how records are kept, and why.

14 frameworks, from 1681 to today · Information Science · Social Sciences

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Archival science is the study of how records are kept, and why12. Its practitioners decide what counts as a record worth preserving, how to arrange and describe it so that it can be found and trusted, and how to keep it authentic and usable across centuries1. The stakes are unusually high for a technical field: archives are where societies store the evidence of what they did—property, rights, crimes, promises, identities—and the choices archivists make about what to keep and how to describe it determine what future generations can know and prove. The history of archival science is therefore a history of changing answers to two questions: what should be kept, and who has the authority to decide.

Clay, Papyrus, and the First Record Keepers

Record keeping is as old as writing. The clay tablets of Mesopotamia, from roughly the fourth millennium BCE, are largely administrative: receipts, inventories, rations, contracts. They were stored in groups, often by transaction or household, and the earliest archival practice was simply the physical arrangement of these groups in rooms and on shelves. Egyptian papyrus archives, Greek city archives, and Roman tabularia continued the pattern: records were kept because they had ongoing legal or administrative force, and they were organized by the office that created them.

The word "archive" itself comes from the Greek arkheion, the building where magistrates kept official documents. What mattered was custody—secure, authoritative storage—and the records' value lay in their capacity to be produced as evidence. This custodial, evidence-centred conception would dominate for two millennia.

Diplomatics: The Science of Authenticating Documents

The first genuine archival theory emerged in the seventeenth century, not from archivists but from scholars of law and history who needed to tell genuine medieval charters from forgeries. Diplomatics is the critical study of the form, structure, and transmission of documents to establish their authenticity and origin3. Its founding work is Jean Mabillon's De re diplomatica (1681), which set out rules for judging charters by their internal features—the formulas of address, dating clauses, signatures, seals, and handwriting—rather than by their content alone.

Diplomatics gave archivists a vocabulary that persists: the distinction between the document (the physical carrier), the act (the legal transaction it records), and the record (the enduring evidence of that act). It taught that a document's trustworthiness depends on understanding the process that produced it3. For the next two centuries, diplomatics remained the closest thing to a scientific method in archives, though it was applied mainly to medieval documents and mainly by historians.

The French Revolution and the Principle of Provenance

The decisive turning point came from administration, not scholarship. Before the French Revolution, archives were largely the private instruments of rulers, churches, and families, arranged by whatever scheme suited their keepers—often by subject or chronology. The Revolution nationalized these holdings and created a public archival system, and in 1841 the French archivist Natalis de Wailly issued a circular establishing the principle of respect des fonds: records originating from one body should be kept together as a unit and not intermingled with records from other bodies.

The problem this solved was practical. When masses of records from many institutions were consolidated, subject-based rearrangement destroyed the context that gave each document its meaning. Respect des fonds preserved the organic connection between records and the office that created them. The related principle of provenance holds that records should be maintained according to their origin, and the "principle of original order" holds that the creator's own arrangement should be preserved where possible1. Together these became the foundation of modern archival arrangement—the idea that an archive is not a collection assembled by a collector but an organic body of records reflecting the activities that produced it.

The Dutch Manual and the Custodial Consensus

In 1898 three Dutch archivists—Samuel Muller, Johan Feith, and Robert Fruin—published the Handleiding voor het ordenen en beschrijven van archieven (Manual for the Arrangement and Description of Archives), usually called the Dutch Manual1. It codified the principles of provenance and original order into a hundred rules and became the first internationally influential archival textbook. Its outlook was thoroughly custodial: the archivist's job was to receive records, preserve their order, and describe them, not to judge their value or interpret them.

This custodial impartiality—the belief that the archivist should be a neutral keeper rather than an active shaper of the record—was articulated most influentially by the British archivist Hilary Jenkinson. His A Manual of Archive Administration (1922) argued that archives grow naturally out of administrative business, that their value depends on their being kept intact and unbroken in custody, and that the archivist's duty is preservation and description rather than selection. Jenkinson's custodial theory held that the records creator, not the archivist, should decide what is destroyed, and that the archivist who selects compromises the impartiality of the whole. This view was coherent for a national archive receiving relatively settled departmental records, and it dominated British and much Commonwealth practice for decades.

Schellenberg and the Turn to Appraisal

The custodial consensus could not survive the explosion of twentieth-century bureaucracy. Governments and institutions produced records in volumes no archive could hold, and someone had to decide what to destroy. In the United States, the National Archives, established in 1934, confronted this directly, and the archivist Theodore Schellenberg supplied the theory4.

Schellenberg's Modern Archives: Principles and Techniques (1956) distinguished primary value—the value of records to the creating office for administrative, legal, and fiscal purposes—from secondary value, their value to later researchers, divided into evidential value (evidence of the creator's organization and functions) and informational value (information about people, places, and events). This value-based appraisal gave archivists a reasoned basis for selection and made appraisal a central professional function rather than a compromise of neutrality. Schellenberg's framework was widely adopted, especially in North America, and it reframed the archivist as an active participant in shaping the historical record.

The Records Life Cycle and the Records Continuum

Schellenberg's work was embedded in a broader model: the records life cycle, which describes records as passing through stages—creation, active use, semi-active storage, and final disposition as either destruction or permanent archival preservation. The life cycle model, developed in the mid-twentieth century and closely associated with records management as a profession, made the archive the end point of a linear process and separated records managers from archivists.

Australia produced the most significant challenge to this linear model. The records continuum framework, developed from the 1980s onward by Australian archivists including Frank Upward, reconceived records as existing simultaneously in multiple dimensions—as evidence of an act, as part of a business process, as part of organizational memory, and as part of societal memory—rather than moving through sequential stages. In the continuum view, recordkeeping and archiving are one integrated process, and appraisal, description, and preservation are ongoing activities rather than terminal ones. The continuum model proved especially suited to digital records, where the "life cycle" distinction between current and archival phases blurs.

Macro-Appraisal and Documentation Strategy

The problem of volume and selection generated further approaches. In Canada, Terry Cook developed macro-appraisal from the late 1980s, arguing that archivists should appraise the functions and activities of records creators—the "macro" level of how institutions work and interact with citizens—rather than evaluating individual records series one by one. Macro-appraisal shifted attention from the record to the society and institution that produced it, and it explicitly acknowledged that appraisal is an act of interpretation, not neutral measurement.

A related response was the documentation strategy, advanced by Helen Samuels in the 1980s and developed by others. Rather than appraising the records of a single institution in isolation, a documentation strategy asks how the documentary record of an entire subject area or region—say, a scientific discipline or a community—can be built cooperatively among many institutions and creators. It treats the archival record as a distributed resource to be planned rather than an accumulation to be received.

Community and Participatory Archives

From the late twentieth century, a different critique emerged: that the archival record, shaped by states and institutions, systematically underrepresents marginalized groups, and that the authority to define and describe records should be shared with the communities they concern. Community archives are collections created and controlled by the communities themselves—ethnic, Indigenous, LGBTQ+, labour, and local groups—often outside formal institutional archives, asserting ownership of their own memory.

Participatory archives extend this into institutional practice: models in which community members contribute to description, selection, and interpretation, and in which the archivist's monopoly on authority is deliberately loosened. These approaches draw on and connect to broader movements for Indigenous data sovereignty and reparative description, and they represent the most substantial challenge to the custodial tradition's assumption that the archivist speaks for the record rather than with the community.

Digital Preservation

The arrival of digital records transformed every prior assumption. Digital material is fragile in a new way: files depend on software and hardware that become obsolete, storage media degrade, and the "original order" of a database or email system is not a physical arrangement at all. Digital preservation is the set of practices for keeping digital material authentic and usable over time—through migration (converting files to current formats), emulation (recreating the original technical environment), fixity checking (verifying that files have not changed), and metadata that documents provenance and technical context.

The OAIS reference model (Open Archival Information System), developed from the late 1990s and standardized as ISO 14721, provided a common conceptual framework for digital repositories, defining the functions and information packages involved in long-term preservation. Digital preservation forced archival science to engage seriously with information technology and with the question of what "authenticity" means when a record can be copied perfectly and altered invisibly.

The Present: Plural Authority and Persistent Questions

Archival science today holds several approaches in tension rather than resolving them. Provenance and original order remain foundational for arrangement, but their application to digital and distributed records is actively debated. Appraisal is universally acknowledged as interpretive, and macro-appraisal, documentation strategy, and value-based methods coexist, often combined. The records continuum informs digital recordkeeping in Australia and beyond, while the life cycle model still structures many records management programs. Community and participatory approaches have moved from the margins toward the centre of professional discourse, reshaping description standards and acquisition practices.

The open questions are substantial. How should archives document the digital present, when records are created in platforms no institution controls? Whose authority should govern description when communities contest institutional labels? Can authenticity be maintained across repeated migration, and what evidence must accompany a digital record to make it trustworthy? And how should the profession reckon with the fact that its custodial ideal of impartiality was always partly a fiction—that selection and description have always shaped what the archive contains? These questions descend directly from the field's history: from diplomatics' concern with authenticity, from the Revolution's concern with context, from Schellenberg's concern with selection, and from the community critique's concern with power.

References

  1. Archival science (introduction, Provenance in archival science, The principle of provenance, Emergence of provenance), Wikipedia
  2. Archive, Wikipedia
  3. Diplomatics, Wikipedia
  4. Archival research (History of archives organizations), Wikipedia

The frameworks of Archival Science

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1681-Present

    Diplomatics

    How can a document's authenticity be established?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1841-Present

    Respect des fonds

    How should records from different creators be kept apart?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1922-1970

    Custodial impartiality

    Should archivists remain neutral keepers?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1922-1970

    Custodial theory

    What is the archivist's proper duty?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1950-Present

    Records life cycle

    What stages do records pass through?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1956-Present
  7. 1970-Present

    Community archives

    Who should control a community's records?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1985-Present

    Documentation strategy

    How can a whole subject be documented cooperatively?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1985-Present

    Records continuum model

    Are recordkeeping and archiving one process?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1988-Present

    Macro-appraisal

    Should appraisal judge functions rather than records?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1990-Present

    Archival Diplomatics

    How do we trust digital records?

    About Archival Diplomatics
    How can archivists know whether a digital record is what it claims to be? In the 1990s, as government and corporate records migrated to electronic systems, traditional methods for verifying authenticity—relying on physical custody, handwriting, and seals—became obsolete. Archival Diplomatics emerged to answer this question by adapting the centuries-old discipline of diplomatics to the modern archival context. Unlike its medieval predecessor, which studied the formal characteristics of charters and deeds to detect forgeries, Archival Diplomatics provides a systematic framework for analyzing the form, context, and provenance of any record—paper or electronic—to assess its trustworthiness. It stands apart from neighboring frameworks like Macroappraisal or the Records Continuum by focusing not on selection or lifecycle, but on the intrinsic qualities that make a record reliable and authentic.
    At the heart of Archival Diplomatics is the concept of diplomatic analysis, a method for dissecting a record's components to understand how it was created, maintained, and transmitted. The curriculum begins with documentary form, the essential structure that identifies a document as a specific type (e.g., a contract, a letter, a database export). From there, students learn to identify three interconnected layers: structural elements (physical and intellectual parts like signatures, dates, subject lines), contextual elements (the juridical-administrative environment, the creator, and the purpose), and content elements (the text or data itself). A key insight is the archival bond—the organic relationship that ties a record to others produced in the same activity; this bond is what distinguishes a record from mere information. Next come the three qualities that diplomatic analysis evaluates: reliability (the record's authority as a trustworthy statement of facts), authenticity (the record's identity and integrity over time), and trustworthiness (the overall confidence that a record is what it purports to be, given its form and history). These qualities are built through three phases of the record's life: creation, maintenance, and preservation. The modern challenge appears in electronic records, where form and context are unstable, and recordkeeping metadata becomes essential for documenting provenance and integrity. Finally, diplomatic criticism applies these concepts to a concrete corpus, enabling the archivist to evaluate and defend the trustworthiness of a body of records.
    Archival Diplomatics traces its roots to classical diplomatics, which originated in the 17th century with Jean Mabillon's De Re Diplomatica and was later refined by medievalists. However, its formal application to modern records began in the 1990s, led by Luciana Duranti at the University of British Columbia. Building on the foundational principle of provenance and reacting against the custodial passivity of Jenkinsonian theory, Duranti argued that archivists needed a rigorous, content-based method to verify authenticity—especially as electronic records made physical custody irrelevant. Her seminal 1995 report "The Reliability and Authenticity of Electronic Records" and her 1996 article "Diplomatics: A New Method for the Study of Records" (published in Archivaria and The American Archivist) crystallized the framework. Heather MacNeil extended the work in her 2000 book Trusting Records: Legal, Historical, and Diplomatic Perspectives, connecting diplomatic analysis to legal evidence and historical method. The framework coexisted with the rise of Macroappraisal and the Records Continuum Model, offering a complementary rather than competing perspective: where appraisal focused on what to keep, and the continuum on the record's multiple contexts, diplomatics provided the tools to keep it trustworthy. Today, Archival Diplomatics underpins digital preservation standards (such as the Open Archival Information System model) and metadata schemas (like the Recordkeeping Metadata Standard). It has transformed archival science by equipping practitioners with a precise vocabulary and analytical procedure for the one thing that has always mattered: the record's ability to stand as evidence.
    The 15 concepts its tower teaches
    • Archival Bond
    • Authenticity
    • Content Elements of Records
    • Contextual Elements of Records
    • Creation Phase
    • Diplomatic Analysis
    • Diplomatic Criticism
    • Documentary Form
    • Electronic Records
    • Maintenance Phase
    • Preservation Phase
    • Recordkeeping Metadata
    • Reliability
    • Structural Elements of Records
    • Trustworthiness

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  12. 1990-Present

    Digital preservation

    How can digital records be kept usable over time?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  13. 1997-Present

    OAIS reference model

    What functions must a digital archive perform?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  14. 2000-Present

    Participatory archives

    Should communities help shape their own archives?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

DiplomaticsRespect des fondsCustodial impartialityCustodial theoryRecords life cycleValue-based appraisalCommunity archivesDocumentation strategyRecords continuum modelMacro-appraisalArchival DiplomaticsDigital preservationOAIS reference modelParticipatory archives

Beyond the field

Where Archival Science's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 55 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Archival Science is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 14 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Archival Science

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Information Science

See where Archival Science sits on the Map of Human Knowledge