Scholarly Communication

Scholarly communication is the system by which researchers create, certify, disseminate, and preserve knowledge.

9 frameworks, from 1665 to today · Information Science · Social Sciences

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Scholarly communication is the system by which researchers create, certify, disseminate, and preserve knowledge1. It includes the journal article and the peer review that vets it, the preprint server, the citation index, the conference talk, the data repository, and the metrics that governments and universities use to judge a scholar's worth. What is at stake is not just convenience. The machinery of scholarly communication decides what counts as a fact, who gets credit for discovering it, who can read it, and which questions get funded. When that machinery changes, so does the shape of knowledge itself.

Learned Societies and the Birth of the Journal

For most of the history of scholarship, communication was epistolary. Natural philosophers wrote letters to one another, and the letters circulated among a small republic of letters2. The problem was scale and credit: a letter reached only its recipients, and priority disputes were common because there was no public record of who had found what first.

The learned journal solved both problems. The Royal Society's Philosophical Transactions, begun in 1665 under the editorship of Henry Oldenburg, and the Journal des sçavans, founded in Paris the same year, established the pattern: a periodic publication that registered a claim publicly and dated it. The journal made knowledge citable. It also created an editorial function—someone decided what was worth printing—though formal peer review as we know it did not yet exist3. The model spread through the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries as disciplinary societies founded their own journals, each tied to a community of specialists.

The Documentation Movement and the Problem of Too Much to Read

By the late nineteenth century, the volume of scientific publication had outrun any individual's ability to read it. The response was the documentation movement: a project to organize and index the scientific literature itself. Paul Otlet and Henri La Fontaine, working in Brussels, founded the International Institute of Bibliography in 1895 and set out to build a universal bibliography and a classification scheme (the Universal Decimal Classification) that could organize all recorded knowledge45. Their work was ambitious and never completed, but it established the idea that the literature was an object of management in its own right.

In the early twentieth century the movement took institutional form. Specialized abstracting and indexing services—Chemical Abstracts from 1907, Biological Abstracts from 1926—condensed the literature so that a researcher could survey a field without reading every paper. S. R. Ranganathan's Colon Classification (1933) and his five laws of library science gave the organizing impulse a theoretical vocabulary. The documentation movement's lasting contribution was the recognition that scholarly communication needed infrastructure: indexes, abstracts, and classification systems standing between the reader and the mass of text.

Peer Review Becomes the Gatekeeper

Peer review in its modern form is a twentieth-century development36. Journals had long relied on editors and trusted referees, but the systematic practice of sending manuscripts to anonymous expert reviewers took shape in the mid-twentieth century, particularly in the sciences6. The Journal of the American Medical Association formalized external review in the 1940s; many other journals followed over the next decades. The rationale was quality control: an editor alone could not judge every specialty, and referees could catch errors, demand revisions, and filter out weak work.

The system's authority grew alongside the growth of science after the Second World War7. Peer review became the mechanism that certified a claim as publishable, and publication in a reviewed journal became the currency of academic careers. Its weaknesses were known early—slowness, conservatism, the difficulty of finding willing reviewers, and the vulnerability of anonymity to abuse—but it became so central that alternatives were rarely considered. The gatekeeping function and the credit function fused: a reviewed paper was both a validated finding and a line on a curriculum vitae.

Citation Indexing and the Quantitative Turn

In the 1950s Eugene Garfield, trained in chemistry and interested in how scientific information was used, proposed that citations themselves could serve as an indexing system. If paper A cites paper B, then B is relevant to A's topic, and a researcher starting from A can move backward through the literature. Garfield founded the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI) and launched the Science Citation Index in 19638. It indexed the references in a defined set of journals, making it possible to trace who had cited whom9.

The citation index was built for retrieval, but it made something else possible: counting. If citations could be counted, they could be used to rank journals, papers, and authors. Garfield's journal impact factor, introduced in the early 1960s, divided a journal's citations by its recent article count to produce a single number. Bibliometrics—the quantitative study of publications and citations—grew into a research field of its own, with laws and regularities such as Lotka's law of author productivity and Bradford's law of scattering. The tools were descriptive at first, but they were quickly adopted for evaluation.

The Serials Crisis and the Open Access Revolt

The postwar expansion of science produced an expansion of journals, and commercial publishers came to dominate the market. By the 1970s and 1980s, library subscription prices were rising far faster than inflation, and the "serials crisis" forced libraries to cancel subscriptions. The paradox was sharp: the research was funded publicly, written by academics, and reviewed by academics for free, yet the resulting journals were sold back to universities at prices that strained their budgets.

The response was open access. The Budapest Open Access Initiative of 2002 articulated the principle: research literature should be freely available online, with authors retaining the right to distribute it. Two routes emerged. The "gold" route publishes articles in open-access journals, often charging authors an article processing charge13. The "green" route deposits a version of the article in an institutional or disciplinary repository1011. The Public Library of Science (PLOS), founded in 2000 and launching its first journal in 2003, became the most visible gold-route publisher. The Directory of Open Access Journals, begun in 2003, catalogued the growing number of such titles. Open access shifted the question from who could afford to read to who could afford to publish, and the debate over that shift continues.

Preprints Return

The preprint—a manuscript circulated before formal review—is older than the journal, but it returned to prominence in the late twentieth century as a way to accelerate communication. The physics community built arXiv in 1991, initially at Los Alamos and later at Cornell, and it became the central distribution channel for physics and mathematics. The life sciences followed much later: bioRxiv launched in 2013, and medRxiv in 2019. The COVID-19 pandemic made preprints a mass phenomenon, with thousands of unreviewed papers circulating and shaping policy before any journal had vetted them. Preprint culture reopens the old question of certification: if a paper is public before review, what does review add, and what does the public do with findings that have not yet been checked?

Altmetrics and the Evaluation Problem

Citation counts measure influence slowly and unevenly. A paper may be read, discussed, and used without being cited for years, and citation practices vary by field. In the late 2000s, researchers including Jason Priem proposed altmetrics: indicators drawn from the web—downloads, social media mentions, bookmarking, news coverage—that might capture attention and engagement earlier and more broadly than citations. Altmetric.com and Plum Analytics built commercial services around the idea1213. The promise was a richer picture of impact; the problem was that attention is not the same as quality, and a paper can be widely shared for being wrong.

The evaluation problem grew more urgent as governments and universities adopted quantitative indicators for hiring, promotion, and funding. The San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA), published in 2012, called for abandoning the journal impact factor as a proxy for the quality of individual articles. The Leiden Manifesto of 2015 set out ten principles for responsible metrics, insisting that quantitative evaluation support rather than replace expert judgment. The movement for responsible metrics is now a recognized strand of scholarly communication, arguing that measurement shapes behavior and that badly designed measures distort research.

Open Science and the Sharing of Data

The most recent turn extends openness from articles to the whole research process. Open science encompasses open data, open code, open methods, and open peer review. The FAIR principles—findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable—published in 2016, gave data sharing a common vocabulary14. Funders began to mandate data management plans, and repositories such as Dryad, Figshare, and Zenodo made datasets citable objects in their own right. The argument is that data underlying a finding should be available for verification and reuse, and that the public investment in research should yield public goods.

Data sharing raises its own problems: privacy, the cost of curation, the difficulty of making data intelligible without its context, and the reluctance of researchers to release material that might be mined by competitors. The infrastructure of open science—persistent identifiers such as ORCID for authors and DOIs for datasets, metadata standards, and repository certification—is still being built.

The Present Landscape

Scholarly communication today is a field of competing infrastructures and unresolved tensions. Peer review persists as the central certification mechanism, but it is strained by volume, slow, and increasingly supplemented by post-publication review and preprint commenting. Open access has moved from margin to mainstream, with major funders requiring it, yet the economics of publishing remain contested. Bibliometrics and altmetrics are embedded in evaluation systems, and the responsible-metrics movement pushes back against their misuse. Open science has extended the sharing norm to data and code, while the tools for making that sharing useful are still maturing15.

The questions that remain open are the ones the history has produced: how to certify knowledge quickly without sacrificing rigor, how to pay for publishing without excluding authors or readers, how to measure worth without distorting it, and how to keep the record of research complete and usable as it grows beyond any individual's capacity to read. Each generation of infrastructure has answered one version of these questions and created the next.

References

  1. Scholarly communication (introduction, Scholarly communication and academic reward and reputation), Wikipedia
  2. Academic journal (History), Wikipedia
  3. Academic publishing (History, introduction), Wikipedia
  4. Information science (European documentation), Wikipedia
  5. Paul Otlet, Wikipedia
  6. Scholarly peer review (History), Wikipedia
  7. Bibliometrics, Wikipedia
  8. Citation index (introduction, History), Wikipedia
  9. Web of Science (History), Wikipedia
  10. Open-access repository, Wikipedia
  11. Self-archiving, Wikipedia
  12. Altmetric, Wikipedia
  13. Plum Analytics, Wikipedia
  14. FAIR data, Wikipedia
  15. Open science, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Scholarly Communication

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1665-Present
  2. 1895-1970
  3. 1940-Present
  4. 1955-Present
  5. 1991-Present
  6. 2002-Present
  7. 2008-Present
  8. 2012-Present
  9. 2016-Present

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Academic journalDocumentation scienceScholarly peer reviewBibliometricsPreprintOpen AccessAltmetricsResponsible MetricsOpen Science

Beyond the field

Where Scholarly Communication's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 19 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Scholarly Communication is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 9 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Scholarly Communication

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Information Science

See where Scholarly Communication sits on the Map of Human Knowledge