Empirical Law And Economics

Law and economics began as a deductive enterprise.

5 frameworks, from 1960 to today · Law And Economics · Law

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Law and economics began as a deductive enterprise. Its practitioners took a legal rule, assumed that people respond to incentives, and reasoned from there to a prediction: raise the expected penalty for a crime and crime should fall; make a promise legally enforceable and parties should rely on it more. The reasoning was elegant, but for decades it rested on very little evidence about what actually happened when rules changed. Empirical law and economics is the branch that set out to supply that evidence—to measure the effects of legal rules rather than infer them from theory. What is at stake is whether the field's central claims are true. A theory of deterrence that has never been tested is a hypothesis, not a finding, and a legal policy built on it may fail or backfire.

The deductive foundations and the first data

The modern field's founding texts were almost entirely theoretical. Gary Becker's 1968 paper "Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach" modeled criminals as rational calculators weighing expected punishment against expected gain, and it launched deterrence research as a formal enterprise. Around the same time, Ronald Coase's "The Problem of Social Cost" (1960) and Guido Calabresi's The Costs of Accidents (1970) framed tort and property rules as instruments for minimizing social costs. Richard Posner's Economic Analysis of Law (1973) then applied price theory across the whole legal map. This deductive law and economics was powerful because it generated sharp, testable predictions—but its authors mostly did not test them.

Some early work did reach for data. Isaac Ehrlich's 1975 study of capital punishment and murder rates, published in the American Economic Review, claimed that each execution deterred several murders; it was cited in a Supreme Court opinion and then fiercely attacked by other economists for its statistical assumptions. The episode taught the field a lasting lesson: empirical claims about law carry enormous policy weight, so the methods behind them matter as much as the conclusions.

Deterrence research becomes an empirical program

Deterrence research was the first area to move from deduction to measurement. The core problem was that crime and punishment are jointly determined: places that punish more may have more crime precisely because they have more crime. Early cross-sectional studies could not separate the effect of punishment from the effect of crime on punishment.

The turning point was the use of natural experiments—situations where a legal change happens for reasons unrelated to the outcome being studied, so it mimics a controlled trial1. A landmark case was the 1970s–80s research on drunk-driving laws. Studies of Scandinavian-style laws that automatically revoked licenses found sharp declines in fatal crashes, and later work on U.S. laws raised the legal drinking age and imposed administrative license suspension reached similar conclusions. The economist Steven Levitt's 1990s work on prison capacity used litigation-driven court orders that forced some states to release prisoners, finding that prison population growth reduced crime. The broader lesson, consolidated in surveys by Levitt and others, was that the certainty of punishment tends to deter more reliably than its severity—a finding that reversed or refined several deductive predictions.

Empirical legal studies as a movement

By the 1990s a wider community had formed around the idea that legal scholarship should be evidence-based. The John M. Olin Foundation funded law-and-economics programs at several law schools, and a generation of legally trained scholars learned econometrics. In 2004 the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies was founded, and the Conference on Empirical Legal Studies began meeting annually in 2006. Empirical legal studies (ELS) is broader than law and economics: it studies courts, judges, juries, lawyers, and litigation as well as the effects of rules, often with little economic theory attached. Its rise changed legal academia's norms—empirical papers became common in top law reviews, and law schools hired scholars with statistics training.

The credibility revolution

The most consequential methodological shift came from economics and is usually called the credibility revolution: the insistence that causal claims rest on research designs whose assumptions are transparent and plausible, rather than on regression controls chosen after the fact. The idea crystallized in the 1990s and 2000s around instrumental variables, difference-in-differences, regression discontinuity, and randomized controlled trials. The 2015 re-analysis of minimum-wage studies by David Card and Alan Krueger (originally published in 1994) is a canonical example of the design-driven approach: comparing adjacent counties across a state border after one state raised its minimum wage.

Law and economics absorbed this shift quickly. A well-known illustration is the study of "judge effects": because cases are assigned to judges essentially at random, differences in outcomes across judges can be used to estimate the causal effect of, say, being detained pretrial or being sentenced to prison. Work by economists including Jeffrey Kling and others in the 2000s used random assignment of cases to judges to measure the effect of incarceration on subsequent employment and recidivism. The design solved a problem the deductive literature could not: it isolated the effect of the legal intervention from the characteristics of the people subject to it.

Evidence-based policy analysis

The credibility revolution fed directly into evidence-based policy analysis—the practice of evaluating legal and regulatory interventions with the same rigor as clinical trials, and of using systematic reviews and cost-benefit analysis to guide decisions. In the United States, the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has required cost-benefit analysis of major regulations since the Reagan era, and the 1990s "welfare reform" evaluations and later randomized trials in criminal justice and education supplied the evidence base. The approach spread internationally through bodies such as the U.K.'s Behavioural Insights Team (founded 2010) and the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab, which ran randomized evaluations of legal and institutional interventions in developing countries. The field's ambition—that legal rules be judged by measured consequences—became institutional practice.

Where the field stands

Today empirical law and economics is a mature, methodologically plural enterprise. Randomized and quasi-experimental designs dominate causal work; administrative data from courts, police, and agencies has made large-scale study routine; and machine learning is increasingly used to predict case outcomes and detect discrimination. The field's central questions remain open: how to generalize from one jurisdiction's natural experiment to another, how to measure deterrence when punishment is endogenous, and how to weigh efficiency findings against distributional and rights-based concerns that empirical methods cannot settle. The deductive tradition has not disappeared—it now supplies the hypotheses that the empirical program tests.

References

  1. Natural experiment, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Empirical Law And Economics

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1960-Present

    Deductive Law and Economics

    What outcomes do legal rules produce by shaping incentives?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1975-Present

    Empirical Deterrence Research

    Does more certain or severe punishment reduce crime?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1981-Present

    Evidence-based policy

    Which legal interventions actually work when tested?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1994-Present

    Credibility Revolution

    When can a legal effect be called causal?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Deductive Law and EconomicsEmpirical Deterrence ResearchEvidence-based policyCredibility RevolutionEmpirical Legal Studies

Beyond the field

Where Empirical Law And Economics's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 14 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Empirical Law And Economics is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 5 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Empirical Law And Economics

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Law And Economics

See where Empirical Law And Economics sits on the Map of Human Knowledge