New Religious Movements

New religious movements are groups and spiritual currents that have emerged, or taken recognisable shape, in roughly the last century and a half, often in tension with the surrounding society.

11 frameworks, from 1900 to today · Religious Studies · Religions

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

What the field studies and why it matters

New religious movements are groups and spiritual currents that have emerged, or taken recognisable shape, in roughly the last century and a half, often in tension with the surrounding society. The field that studies them asks how such movements form, recruit, organise, believe, and change; how they relate to states, families, and media; and why some become flashpoints of public fear while others pass unnoticed. The stakes are unusually high. Because these groups are often small, unfamiliar, and controversial, the scholarship has repeatedly been pulled between two temptations: defending them against hostile outsiders, or diagnosing them as pathological. Much of the field's history is the story of building methods that avoid both.

The subject matter itself is older than the discipline. Nineteenth-century America produced a wave of homegrown movements—Mormonism from the 1830s, Seventh-day Adventism from the 1840s, Christian Science from the 1870s, and Pentecostalism from the early 1900s—while spiritualist circles and Theosophy spread across Europe and the Americas. Japan's nineteenth-century New Religions, such as Tenrikyo and Konkokyo, and later Soka Gakkai, arose from different roots. These movements were the raw material; the scholarly field took shape only as researchers found ways to study them without assuming they were either frauds or revelations.

Church, sect, and the first typologies

The earliest systematic tool was the church–sect typology, developed in the sociology of religion around the turn of the twentieth century. Its core idea is that religious bodies can be placed on a continuum according to how far they are accommodated to the surrounding society1. A church is large, established, and at ease with the state and culture; a sect is smaller, stricter, in tension with society, and often recruits from the margins1. Max Weber used the distinction in his sociology of religion, and Ernst Troeltsch developed it in The Social Teaching of the Christian Churches (1912), though both were describing European church history rather than new movements. The typology's virtue was that it made tension with society a measurable dimension rather than a moral judgement. Its limitation was that it was built for a Christendom in which "church" and "sect" were the only options; movements with no churchly parent, or with a universalising mission, did not fit.

Later refinements tried to fix this. The most influential was the threefold scheme of world-rejecting, world-affirming, and world-accommodating movements, associated with Roy Wallis's The Elementary Forms of the New Religious Life (1984). World-rejecting movements demand sharp separation from mainstream society; world-affirming ones embrace it and offer techniques for success within it; world-accommodating ones are inwardly focused and largely indifferent to the wider society. The scheme's advantage is that it describes the movement's stance rather than its size or age, and it travels beyond Christianity. Its weakness is that stance can change over time, and many movements mix all three.

Brainwashing, coercion, and the problem of conversion

From the 1960s the field was overtaken by a public panic2. New movements—the Unification Church, the Children of God, Hare Krishna, Scientology, and others—attracted young converts whose families sometimes could not recognise them. A theory of coercive persuasion, popularly called brainwashing, offered an explanation: converts had been psychologically manipulated, their wills broken by isolation, sleep deprivation, and indoctrination. The idea drew on Cold War accounts of Chinese and Korean prisoner-of-war re-education and was popularised by journalists and by parents' groups. Its appeal was that it explained why apparently rational people joined groups outsiders found bizarre, and it gave families and courts a language for intervention.

The scholarly response was sceptical. Sociologists who did fieldwork among converts, notably in the 1970s and 1980s, found that recruitment was usually gradual, that converts were active interpreters of their own experience, and that many left on their own. The brainwashing model, critics argued, treated converts as passive objects and ignored the social bonds and meanings that made membership attractive. The debate was never fully settled in public opinion, but within religious studies the coercive-persuasion model lost its explanatory standing, and the burden shifted to understanding conversion as a process of socialisation and identity change. The episode taught the field a lasting lesson: theories that pathologise membership tend to be built from outside testimony rather than from the members' own accounts.

Fieldwork and the turn to the members' point of view

The methodological answer to both the brainwashing panic and the older typologies was participant observation3. Researchers began attending meetings, living alongside members, and taking converts' own accounts seriously3. This was not new in anthropology, but applying it to controversial contemporary groups was. The approach treats the movement as a social world with its own logic, and asks how members make sense of their lives34. It produced detailed studies of recruitment, ritual, authority, and everyday life, and it made the field's central methodological virtue the suspension of judgement long enough to understand.

Fieldwork also exposed the field's practical difficulties: access is fragile, members may suspect the researcher, and leaving can be as complicated as entering. The method's strength is that it can show, for example, how a millenarian group's failed prophecy is reinterpreted rather than abandoned—a classic finding in the study of apocalyptic movements5. Its weakness is that close immersion can make criticism difficult, and the field has repeatedly argued about how to balance empathy with analysis.

Millenarianism and the apocalyptic conflict model

A distinct strand of the field studies millenarian movements—groups expecting an imminent, total transformation of the world6. The classic analysis is Leon Festinger, Henry Riecken, and Stanley Schachter's When Prophecy Fails (1956), a study of a small group whose predicted apocalypse did not occur. The book argued that disconfirmation can strengthen commitment when members are socially supported, a finding that shaped later work on cognitive dissonance. Later scholarship complicated the picture: failed prophecy does not always produce intensification, and movements interpret failure in varied ways.

The apocalyptic conflict model grew from cases where millenarian expectation ended in violence, most notoriously the 1978 Jonestown deaths and the 1993 Waco siege. The model holds that conflict between a millenarian group and outside authorities can escalate through mutual misunderstanding and threat, each side reading the other's actions as proof of hostile intent. It treats violence as a relational outcome rather than an inherent property of belief. The model has been influential in policy discussions about how states should handle such groups, and it has been criticised for sometimes shifting blame away from leaders who organised violence.

The critical study of the "cult" label

Running through all of this is a debate about language. "Cult" is not a neutral category; it carries stigma and is used by media, opponents, and former members. From the 1970s onward, scholars argued that the label itself shapes what can be seen, encouraging a focus on deviance and control rather than on belief and practice. The critical study of the label asks who applies it, for what purposes, and with what effects. It has led the field to prefer "new religious movement" as a descriptive term, while acknowledging that the replacement is also a choice2. The debate connects to broader questions in religious studies about how categories carry power, and it has made the field unusually self-conscious about its own vocabulary.

Disaffiliation and exit

If recruitment was the early obsession, leaving became the later one. Disaffiliation and exit studies examine how and why people leave new movements, what happens to them afterwards, and how former members narrate their past. Early work often assumed exit was traumatic and produced by coercion; later research showed a wider range of exits, from gradual drift to sudden rupture, and a range of outcomes, from relief to grief. The field also studies "exit counselling" and the deprogramming movement, treating them as objects of analysis rather than as neutral help27. The central finding is that leaving is a social process, shaped by relationships, family, and the availability of alternatives, not simply a decision of belief.

The state and minority religions

A further strand studies how states regulate minority religions. This includes legal recognition, registration requirements, tax status, anti-cult legislation, and the policing of "sects." France's parliamentary commissions on cults in the 1990s and 2000s, and similar moves elsewhere, became case studies in how states classify and control religious minorities. The field asks whether regulation protects citizens or persecutes minorities, and how the line between the two is drawn. It connects to broader questions in religious studies about secularism, toleration, and the legal construction of religion.

Global and comparative study

The field began as a largely Euro-American enterprise, but it has become increasingly global and comparative2. Scholars now study new religions in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the post-socialist world, and compare movements across traditions. This has challenged the field's inherited categories: the church–sect typology assumed Christian institutions, and the "cult" label assumed Western media frames. Comparative work has shown that new religious movements arise in many settings, from postcolonial states to migrant communities, and that their relationship to modernity is varied. The global turn has also raised questions about translation and about whose categories count.

Digital and diffuse spirituality

The most recent development is the study of digital and diffuse spirituality: practices that are not organised into recognisable movements at all. Online communities, influencer-led spiritualities, "spiritual but not religious" identities, and hybrid practices drawn from many traditions are increasingly common. These are harder to study with the field's classic tools, because there may be no membership, no leadership, and no bounded group. Researchers have turned to digital ethnography and to the study of networks and platforms. The question this raises is whether "new religious movement" remains the right unit of analysis, or whether the field is moving toward studying spirituality as a dispersed cultural phenomenon.

Where the field stands

Today the field combines several approaches: sociological typologies, ethnographic fieldwork, historical study of particular movements, legal and policy analysis, and the critical study of categories. The older debates—brainwashing, the cult label, the church–sect scheme—remain live in public discussion even where scholarship has moved on28. The open questions are substantial: how to study movements that exist mainly online; how to compare across traditions without importing Christian categories; how to balance empathy with critical distance; and how states should treat religious minorities whose beliefs are unfamiliar. The field's history is, in large part, a history of learning to ask those questions carefully.

References

  1. Sociological classifications of religious movements (introduction, Church-sect typology), Wikipedia
  2. New religious movement (History, Definitions and terminology, Joining), Wikipedia
  3. Participant observation (introduction, History and development), Wikipedia
  4. Ethnography, Wikipedia
  5. Doomsday cult, Wikipedia
  6. Millenarianism, Wikipedia
  7. Deprogramming, Wikipedia
  8. Jehovah's Witnesses (History), Wikipedia

The frameworks of New Religious Movements

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1900-1975
  2. 1956-Present
  3. 1960-1990
  4. 1970-Present
  5. 1975-Present
  6. 1978-Present
  7. 1980-Present
  8. 1984-Present
  9. 1990-Present
  10. 1990-Present
  11. 2010-Present
A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

New Religious Movements is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 11 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on New Religious Movements

Related fields

More in Religious Studies

See where New Religious Movements sits on the Map of Human Knowledge