Philosophy Of Art

Philosophy of art is the branch of philosophy that asks what art is, what makes something a work of art, what it means, and why it matters.

16 frameworks, from 380 BCE to today · Aesthetics · Philosophy

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Philosophy of art is the branch of philosophy that asks what art is, what makes something a work of art, what it means, and why it matters1. Aesthetics, the wider discipline that contains it, is named from the Greek aisthēsis, perception or sensation: it concerns sensory experience and the judgments we make about beauty, the sublime, and art1. The philosophy of art differs from art history or criticism in that it pursues general questions—about the nature of art, the logic of taste, the meaning of works, and their place in human life—rather than the interpretation of particular works. Its history is a long argument about whether such general questions can be answered at all, and about what changes when art does.

Imitation and the Classical Inheritance

The oldest systematic account of art in the Western tradition is Plato's, and it is hostile. In the Republic he treats painting and poetry as mimesis—imitation—at two removes from truth: the craftsman imitates the Form of a bed, the painter imitates the craftsman's bed. Because art feeds the lower part of the soul and can corrupt judgment, Plato banishes much poetry from his ideal city. Aristotle answered him in the Poetics (fourth century BCE, surviving only in part). For Aristotle, imitation is natural to humans and a source of pleasure and learning; tragedy works by mimesis of action, and its power comes from plot structure—reversal and recognition—that produces catharsis, a purging or clarification of pity and fear. Later classical and medieval thought folded art into craft and rhetoric: the liberal arts included grammar and music but not painting or sculpture, and beauty was treated as a metaphysical property—proportion, harmony, radiance—rather than a matter of taste.

Taste and the Birth of Aesthetics as a Discipline

The eighteenth century changed the question. As art production shifted from guild and court to a market of connoisseurs and public exhibitions (the Paris Salon opened in 1737, and its juried shows became a forum for critical debate), attention moved from what makes a thing beautiful to what happens in the mind of the person who judges it. In 1750 Alexander Baumgarten published the first volume of his Aesthetica, naming a new science of sensory cognition—knowledge that comes through the senses—and treating the arts as its proper domain. David Hume's essay "Of the Standard of Taste" (1757) asked how judgments that seem merely personal can nevertheless be argued and corrected; his answer invoked the verdict of the "true judges," those with delicacy of perception, practice, and freedom from prejudice.

Immanuel Kant gave the debate its most durable form in the Critique of Judgment (1790). A judgment of taste, he argued, is subjective—grounded in the feeling of pleasure—yet claims universal agreement; it is disinterested, attending to the form of the object rather than its existence or use. The pleasure comes from a "free play" of imagination and understanding, a harmony of our cognitive faculties1. Kant called this the first part of the critique, the analytic of the beautiful; the second part, the critique of the sublime, described the overwhelming magnitude or power of nature as a negative pleasure that reveals our supersensible vocation. His account of artistic genius distinguished fine art, which cannot have rules and yet sets them through exemplars, from craft. Kant's fusion of subjective feeling with a claim to universality set the terms for nearly every subsequent discussion of aesthetic judgment.

Idealism and Art as the Highest Expression of Spirit

German idealists turned aesthetics into metaphysics. In Friedrich Schelling's System of Transcendental Idealism (1800), art is the supreme organon of philosophy: the unconscious productivity of nature and the conscious activity of mind meet in the work of art, which philosophy can only reconstruct after the fact. G. W. F. Hegel's lectures on aesthetics (delivered in Berlin in the 1820s, published posthumously) told a different history: art is one of the forms in which Spirit—Geist—comes to know itself, alongside religion and philosophy. Hegel arranged art in three historical stages. Symbolic art, exemplified by ancient Egyptian architecture, reaches for a meaning it cannot embody. Classical art, above all Greek sculpture, achieves a perfect equilibrium of sensuous form and spiritual content—the human body as the dwelling of free self-consciousness. Romantic art, in painting, music, and poetry from the Christian era onward, transcends sensuousness and turns inward; art in this stage reveals its own limits, and Spirit passes to philosophy. Hegel's claim that art, for us, is "a thing of the past" in this specific sense—its highest vocation fulfilled by philosophy—became a provocation that much later aesthetics, from Heidegger to Arthur Danto, answered. The idealist tradition also gave us the concept of the aesthetic as a distinctive mode of experience: Schelling, Hegel, and their successors developed its philosophical vocabulary even when they disagreed about art's status.

Formalism: Art as Significant Form

The turn of the twentieth century produced the sharpest break with mimetic and expressive accounts. Formalism holds that what makes something art and what matters in it are its formal properties—lines, colors, masses, tones—arranged so as to produce an aesthetic experience. Its philosophical statement came from Clive Bell's Art (1914), which named the property "significant form," and from Roger Fry's Vision and Design (1920); both were art critics associated with the Bloomsbury group. The influential art historian Heinrich Wölfflin had offered a contrasting formalism, analyzing styles through categories of visual organization (linear versus painterly, closed versus open form) in Principles of Art History (1915). Formalist criticism became the dominant method in the English-speaking world, especially for modern art: it treated subject matter as irrelevant to aesthetic value and could champion post-impressionist painting, which seemed to have abandoned representation.

The philosophical strengthening came from Monroe Beardsley, who with W. K. Wimsatt published "The Intentional Fallacy" (1946). The essay argued that the meaning and value of a work are to be found in the work itself, not in the author's private intentions; to judge a poem by what its author meant is a confusion. This was the analytic core of anti-intentionalism, and Beardsley's later Aesthetics: Problems in the Philosophy of Criticism (1958) worked it into a general theory—the work as an object for aesthetic perception, intention as irrelevant to its interpretation.

The Institutional and Historical Turns: What Counts as Art

Formalism presupposed that works could be recognized by their formal properties, and that taste or perception would then do the rest. But twentieth-century avant-garde practice—Duchamp's readymades, above all Fountain (1917), an inverted urinal submitted to an exhibition; then Pop art and conceptual art—seemed to make formal properties beside the point. In 1964 Arthur Danto published "The Artworld," asking why Brillo Box, a sculpture by Andy Warhol that looked indistinguishable from a supermarket carton, was art while the carton was not2. His answer: an object becomes art when it is situated within a theory, an "artworld" of criticism, interpretation, and art-historical context—a context he later called an "atmosphere of theory." The same year, George Dickie developed the institutional theory of art, which holds that something is a work of art if a person or institution within the artworld confers that status on it—a conferral that need not be based on perceptible properties.

Danto's later work moved toward a historical definition. In The Transfiguration of the Commonplace (1981) and after, he argued that a work of art is about something, and embodies its meaning; art's history is the progressive discovery of what art can be about, so that what is possible for art shifts with history, not with perception. Other philosophers pursued adjacent paths. Jerrold Levinson proposed a historical definition in "Defining Art Historically" (1979): something is art if it is intended to be regarded as earlier art was correctly regarded. Morris Weitz, in "The Role of Theory in Aesthetics" (1956), had already challenged the very attempt: art, he argued, is an "open concept" whose conditions change as artists invent; we should stop asking for a definition and instead describe how the concept is used. Anti-essentialism of this kind later reappeared in pragmatic and institutional terms.

Expressing Feeling: Expression Theory

A rival tradition focused on the inner life. Expression theory holds that art is the expression of emotion—the work manifests what the artist feels, or, more subtly, what the work itself expresses1. Leo Tolstoy's What Is Art1? (1897) defined art as the transmission of feeling from artist to audience, and judged art good by the sincerity and moral quality of the feeling transmitted (a doctrine that led him to reject much of his own earlier work). The British aesthetician R. G. Collingwood, in The Principles of Art (1938), argued that art proper is the expression of emotion in the artist's own mind, clarified through the making of the work, and distinguished this from craft and amusement. This tradition provoked one of the central debates of twentieth-century aesthetics: whether emotional qualities can belong to works of art themselves, or only to their creators and audiences. The long-running controversy over musical expression, and later cognitivist theories, grew from this question.

Phenomenology and Hermeneutics: Art as Encounter and Interpretation

Continental philosophy took up art under a different description. Edmund Husserl's phenomenology, a disciplined description of the structures of experience, was extended to art by Roman Ingarden, whose The Literary Work of Art (1931, Polish; German translation 1931–32) analyzed the work as an "intentional object" whose "places of indeterminacy" are filled in by the reader—an early treatment of interpretation as the reader's activity. Martin Heidegger's essay "The Origin of the Work of Art" (delivered 1935–36, published 1950) argued that the work opens a "world" and sets forth a "striving" between world and earth; Van Gogh's painting of peasant shoes figures in it as an example of how a work lets truth happen. Hans-Georg Gadamer's Truth and Method (1960) made aesthetics part of hermeneutics: understanding the work is a dialogue with tradition in which the interpreter's horizon meets the work's, fusing them; the notion of a "classical" work is the ongoing authority of a text that continues to speak. These thinkers gave aesthetics its vocabulary of world, horizon, dialogue, and the interpretive encounter.

Critical Theory: Art and Society

A parallel Continental strand asked what art does within society. Walter Benjamin's essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" (1935) argued that technical reproduction—photography, film—erodes the "aura" of the unique, tradition-bound work, which is also its authoritarian authority, and that this shift has political consequences. Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno's Dialectic of Enlightenment (1947) attacked the "culture industry," which turns art into a commodity addressed to the masses. Adorno's Aesthetic Theory (published posthumously in 1970) argued that art is autonomous—its own distinctive mode of rationality—and yet shot through with society; the tensions within the work register social antagonism. Though their evaluations differed, both" target="_blank">both strands made art a site of ideology and critique.

Analytic Aesthetics Comes of Age

In 1951 two articles reshaped the English-speaking field. William Elton published "Aesthetics and Language," and the following decade saw a sustained attack on what was called "aesthetic theory." The criticisms—that different arts have different standards, that aesthetic experience may be a vacuous notion, that the field's central questions rest on conceptual confusions—matured into a positive program. Frank Sibley's "Aesthetic Concepts" (1959) distinguished aesthetic properties, such as being delicate or graceful, from nonaesthetic ones, and argued that aesthetic judgment is not guaranteed by any rule—taste cannot be replaced by principles. From the 1970s analytic aesthetics expanded into a dense field: ontology of art, which asks what kind of entity a work is—is a symphony identical with its score, its performances, or a type instantiated by them, as Richard Wollheim's and Jerrold Levinson's analyses argued?—and the nature of fiction, with Kendall Walton's Mimesis as Make-Believe (1990) explaining our imaginative engagement with fictions in terms of games of pretense.

Widening the Field: Environment, Everyday Life, Gender, Race

From the 1960s a series of claims pushed aesthetics beyond the gallery. Environmental aesthetics grew from Ronald Hepburn's essay "Contemporary Aesthetics and the Neglect of Natural Beauty" (1966), which argued that beauty in nature deserves the same scrutiny as art, and Allen Carlson's work articulating models of appropriate aesthetic appreciation of environments—including his" target="_blank">his knowledge-based, natural-scientific model. The field developed theories of the picturesque, the sublime, and, more recently, everyday aesthetics: Yuriko Saito's Everyday Aesthetics (2007) argues that the look and feel of kitchens, clothes, and streets are fully aesthetic matters, continuous with art but wider in scope, and that attention to them has ethical consequences.

Feminist aesthetics, emerging from the women's movement of the late 1960s and 1970s, challenged the field's givens: the exclusion of women artists from canons, the gendered coding of the gaze, and the masculine assumptions of the "disinterested" spectator. Linda Nochlin's essay "Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?" (1971) was formative for art history and its aesthetic consequences; later philosophers took up the body, subjectivity, and the gendered construction of taste and genius. Postcolonial aesthetics, developing later and partly out of that current, examined how aesthetic concepts—the beautiful, the primitive, the universal—were shaped by colonial relations between European centers and the rest of the world, and pressed the field to expand its canon beyond the European tradition.

The Present: System, Science, and Repair

Today the philosophy of art is plural. Analytic aesthetics remains dominant in the English-speaking world, having moved from grand definitional theories to piecemeal work: the ontology of the various arts, aesthetic properties and evaluation, fiction, depiction, and the relation of aesthetic to ethical value. The institutional and historical theories of art have been refined into accounts that make art's status depend on context, intention, and art-historical position; no single definition commands consensus. Experimental aesthetics, which measures aesthetic responses in laboratories, has expanded in the twenty-first century into neuroaesthetics and empirical studies of beauty, preference, and aesthetic emotions. Continental aesthetics persists in hermeneutic and critical modes, often engaged with contemporary art, ecology, and politics. Meanwhile environmental and everyday aesthetics, feminist and postcolonial critique, and work on the aesthetic dimension of non-Western traditions continue to widen the field beyond the fine arts and beyond Europe. The open question—whether art is one thing or many, whether aesthetic judgment has grounds, and how far the aesthetic reaches into ordinary life—is the same question the field has been arguing about since Plato.

References

  1. Aesthetics (introduction, Definition, Modern and contemporary, Definitions, Representation and expression), Wikipedia
  2. Theory of art (Institutional), Wikipedia

The frameworks of Philosophy Of Art

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 380 BCE-1750

    Mimesis and Classical Poetics

    What makes a poem or painting an imitation?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1750-Present

    Aesthetics of Taste and Judgment

    How can judgments of beauty be argued about?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1800-1900
  4. 1870-Present

    Experimental aesthetics

    What measurable laws govern aesthetic preference?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1897-1970

    Expression Theory

    Is art the communication of feeling?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1914-1970

    Formalism

    What makes a work art and gives it value?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1931-Present

    Phenomenology and Hermeneutics of Art

    How does art disclose truth through experience?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1935-Present
  9. 1946-Present

    Intentionalism and Anti-Intentionalism

    Does the artist's intention determine a work's meaning?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1951-Present

    Analytic Aesthetics

    What do our concepts of art and beauty mean?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1956-Present
  12. 1964-Present
  13. 1966-Present

    Environmental and Everyday Aesthetics

    Can nature and daily life be aesthetically appreciated?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  14. 1968-Present

    Ontology of Art

    What kind of thing is a work of art?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  15. 1971-Present

    Feminist and Postcolonial Aesthetics

    Whose art and whose taste count as universal?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  16. 1979-Present

    Historical Definition of Art

    Does art's history determine what art is?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Mimesis and Classical PoeticsAesthetics of Taste and JudgmentGerman Idealism and Metaphysics of ArtExperimental aestheticsExpression TheoryFormalismPhenomenology and Hermeneutics of ArtCritical Theory and Aesthetics of Soc…Intentionalism and Anti-IntentionalismAnalytic AestheticsAnti-Essentialism and Open ConceptsInstitutional and Historical Definiti…Environmental and Everyday AestheticsOntology of ArtFeminist and Postcolonial AestheticsHistorical Definition of Art

Beyond the field

Where Philosophy Of Art's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 116 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Philosophy Of Art is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 16 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Philosophy Of Art

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Aesthetics

See where Philosophy Of Art sits on the Map of Human Knowledge