History Of Scientific Practices

The history of scientific practices studies science as something people do: observing, measuring, collecting, drawing, dissecting, mixing, calibrating, recording, teaching, and arguing over results.

12 frameworks, from 1500 to today · History Of Science & Technology · History

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

The history of scientific practices studies science as something people do: observing, measuring, collecting, drawing, dissecting, mixing, calibrating, recording, teaching, and arguing over results. Its subject is not primarily the sequence of theories about nature but the working arrangements that made knowledge possible—the bench, the field notebook, the instrument, the workshop, the expedition, the classroom. What is at stake is a simple but far-reaching claim: that what counts as a scientific fact depends on how it was made, by whom, with what tools, under what conditions, and for whom it was meant to be convincing. A measurement taken with a borrowed instrument, a specimen preserved badly on a long voyage, or a result recorded in a private notebook rather than a printed table are not the same kind of knowledge claim, even if the words describing them are identical.

Erudition, Craft, and the Early Modern Workshop

Before there was a discipline, there were practices to describe. Renaissance humanists recovered and edited ancient technical texts—Pliny, Dioscorides, Vitruvius—and in doing so confronted the gap between what the texts said and what artisans actually did. The sixteenth-century physician and naturalist Conrad Gessner compiled enormous bibliographies of natural knowledge; the anatomist Andreas Vesalius, in De humani corporis fabrica (1543), insisted that dissection and direct observation could correct the ancient authorities, and his woodcuts made the body's structures visible to readers who would never open a corpse. These were not yet histories of practice, but they established that knowing nature required attending to how knowledge was obtained.

The crucial development came with the artisanal and workshop tradition. Historians of this subfield have shown that early modern science drew heavily on the tacit knowledge of miners, metalworkers, apothecaries, instrument makers, and navigators—people who knew how to do things but rarely wrote theory. Georgius Agricola's De re metallica (1556) described mining and metallurgy in detail; the alchemical workshops of the period developed distillation, filtration, and furnace techniques that later chemistry inherited. The point is not that artisans were proto-scientists but that their skills, materials, and standards of workmanship entered the learned world and shaped what counted as a reliable result. A recipe that worked was a kind of evidence.

Experimental Philosophy and the Credible Witness

The seventeenth century turned practice into a public method. The "experimental philosophy" associated with the early Royal Society of London—founded in 1660—made the witnessed experiment a foundation of natural knowledge12. Robert Boyle's air-pump experiments, published in New Experiments Physico-Mechanical (1660), were designed so that gentlemen witnesses could see the results for themselves; the pump's construction, the sealing of the glass, and the presence of observers all mattered to whether the claim was accepted. Boyle's insistence on detailed "matters of fact" and modest reporting was itself a practice: it told readers how to judge a report and whom to trust.

This was inseparable from instrumentation and standardization. The air pump, the barometer, the thermometer, and the telescope were not neutral windows on nature; each had to be built, calibrated, and made comparable across places. The problem of comparing thermometers filled with different liquids, or barometers read at different altitudes, drove the slow creation of shared scales and conventions. The Greenwich observatory, founded in 1675, and the later establishment of the metre and other standards during the French Revolution show the same logic at a larger scale: a measurement is only useful if others can reproduce it.

Collecting, the Field, and the Inscription of Nature

Alongside the laboratory grew field science and collecting. Cabinets of curiosities in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries gathered shells, minerals, and exotica; by the eighteenth century, systematic collectors such as Carl Linnaeus built classifications that depended on careful preservation and description. Voyages of exploration—Captain Cook's in the 1760s and 1770s, the Beagle's in the 1830s—carried naturalists who collected, sketched, and labeled specimens under difficult conditions. Alexander von Humboldt's travels in South America (1799–1804) produced measurements of temperature, altitude, and magnetism that he plotted and compared, turning travel into a quantitative enterprise.

Fieldwork raised a distinctive problem: how to make observations taken far away, often by people with different training, credible back home. The answer lay in inscription and data practices—the conversion of fleeting experience into durable records. Sketches, maps, tables, herbarium sheets, and standardized notebooks allowed a distant observation to travel. The nineteenth-century naturalist's field journal, with its ruled columns and fixed categories, was a technology for making nature comparable. The same logic appears in the great nineteenth-century surveys and observatories, where armies of computers—human calculators—reduced observations to tables.

The Laboratory as a Place of Work

The late nineteenth and twentieth centuries made the laboratory the emblematic site of science, and historians learned to study it as a workplace. The German research laboratory, the industrial laboratory of companies such as Bayer and General Electric, and the university teaching laboratory each organized knowledge differently. Laboratory pedagogy and disciplined technique became central: students were trained through repeated manipulation—titrations, dissections, microscope work—until their hands produced reliable results. The historian of science's attention to these routines revealed that scientific competence is largely embodied and transmitted by imitation and drill, not only by reading.

A decisive turn came with laboratory studies in the 1970s and 1980s. Anthropologists and sociologists observed scientists at work and described what they actually did rather than what their published papers said. Karin Knorr Cetina's The Manufacture of Knowledge (1981) and Bruno Latour and Steve Woolgar's Laboratory Life (1979) followed bench work, noting how inscriptions—traces on paper, graphs, printouts—became the objects scientists argued over. Latour and Woolgar's account of "inscription devices" showed that a substance in a test tube becomes a fact only after it has been transformed into a figure or a table that can be circulated and compared. This was a history of practice written from the inside.

Actor-Network Theory and the Symmetry of Actors

Out of laboratory studies grew actor-network theory (ANT), associated above all with Latour, Michel Callon, and John Law. Its central move was to treat human and nonhuman actors symmetrically: the air pump, the electrode, the scallop, and the scientist are all "actants" whose relations make a network hold or fail. Callon's study of scallop cultivation in St. Brieuc Bay (published in 1986) described how researchers, fishermen, and scallops were enrolled into a shared project, and how the network collapsed when the scallops failed to cooperate. Latour's Science in Action (1987) argued that a fact is what holds when the network supporting it is strong—when instruments, colleagues, funders, and texts all reinforce one another.

ANT was influential and contested. Critics asked whether it flattened power and human intention too far; defenders replied that it forced attention to the material arrangements that other approaches ignored. Its legacy is visible in the subfield's habit of following the instrument, the sample, and the data wherever they go.

Practice Theory and the Analysis of Technique

A parallel strand drew on social theory to analyze practice itself. Practice theory—associated with thinkers such as Pierre Bourdieu and, in the history of science, with scholars who studied "science as practice"—treated knowledge as embedded in habitual, socially organized activity3. Bourdieu's concept of the habitus, the durable dispositions acquired through training, helped explain why scientific work looks effortless to the expert and opaque to the outsider. In the history of science, this approach encouraged studies of skill, tacit knowledge, and the reproduction of expertise across generations. It also connected to the study of scientific labor: who does the routine work—technicians, assistants, calculators, field hands—and how is that work credited or erased?

Feminist Histories of Scientific Labor

Feminist historians of science made the question of labor central. They showed that the people who prepared specimens, kept records, computed tables, and maintained instruments were often women whose contributions disappeared from published credit. Studies of nineteenth-century astronomy, for example, documented the women "computers" at observatories who reduced stellar observations to catalogues. Feminist scholarship also examined how gendered divisions of labor shaped what counted as skilled work and whose testimony was trusted. This was not only a recovery of forgotten workers but an argument about the structure of scientific authority: credit, authorship, and credibility are distributed through social arrangements, and those arrangements have histories.

Statistical Design and the Managed Experiment

The twentieth century brought a new kind of practice: the statistically designed experiment. Ronald A. Fisher, working at Rothamsted Experimental Station in England, developed methods of randomization, replication, and analysis of variance, published in The Design of Experiments (1935). His approach addressed a real problem—how to separate the effect of a treatment from the noise of soil variation, weather, and other uncontrolled factors. Randomization gave a principled way to distribute nuisance variation; replication gave an estimate of error. The designed experiment became standard in agriculture, medicine, and industry, and it changed what an experiment was: not a single demonstration but a planned arrangement of many trials whose results could be analyzed statistically. This was practice formalized into method.

Global and Comparative Practice History

The subfield's most recent expansion is global and comparative. Historians have shown that the practices studied in European laboratories were not uniquely European in origin or in kind. Indian, Chinese, Islamic, and African traditions of measurement, metallurgy, medicine, and astronomy had their own standards, instruments, and pedagogies. Comparative work asks how different societies organized the making of knowledge—through guilds, courts, temples, or colonial surveys—and how practices traveled, were translated, or were imposed through empire. The collection and classification of specimens in colonial contexts, for instance, entangled natural history with extraction and administration. This strand insists that a history of scientific practices must not silently equate "science" with one regional tradition.

The Field Today

Contemporary work in the history of scientific practices draws on all these strands. Laboratory ethnography and ANT remain tools for following how facts are assembled; practice theory informs studies of skill and training; feminist and labor histories keep attention on who does the work and who gets credit; statistical and data studies examine how numbers are made and circulated; and global and comparative histories insist on placing European practices alongside others rather than treating them as the default. The open questions are substantial: how to write histories that are faithful to tacit, embodied knowledge that leaves few documents; how to compare practices across cultures without imposing one culture's categories; and how the digital transformation of data collection and analysis is reshaping what counts as a scientific practice. The field's enduring contribution is the insistence that knowledge is made, and that the making is historical.

References

  1. History of science (Approaches to history of science, Scientific societies and journals), Wikipedia
  2. Republic of Letters (History), Wikipedia
  3. Practice theory, Wikipedia

The frameworks of History Of Scientific Practices

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1500-1700

    Artisanal and Workshop Knowledge

    How did craft skill shape reliable knowledge?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  2. 1550-Present

    Collecting and Field Practice

    How is nature made comparable across distant places?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1650-Present

    Instruments and Standardization

    How do instruments make measurements comparable?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1660-1800

    Experimental Philosophy

    What makes an experiment credible to witnesses?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1750-Present

    Inscription and Data Practices

    How does experience become a durable record?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1820-1950
  7. 1925-Present

    Design of experiments

    How should experiments be arranged to yield valid inference?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1970-Present

    Feminist Histories of Scientific Labor

    Whose labor makes scientific knowledge possible?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1970-Present

    Practice Theory

    How is knowledge embedded in habitual activity?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1975-Present

    Laboratory Studies

    What do scientists actually do at the bench?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  11. 1980-Present

    Actor-Network Theory

    How do human and nonhuman actors hold a network together?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  12. 1980-Present

    Global and Comparative Practice History

    How do practices travel and change across the globe?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Artisanal and Workshop KnowledgeCollecting and Field PracticeInstruments and StandardizationExperimental PhilosophyInscription and Data PracticesLaboratory Pedagogy and Disciplined T…Design of experimentsFeminist Histories of Scientific LaborPractice TheoryLaboratory StudiesActor-Network TheoryGlobal and Comparative Practice Histo…

Beyond the field

Where History Of Scientific Practices's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 111 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

History Of Scientific Practices is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 12 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on History Of Scientific Practices

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in History Of Science & Technology

See where History Of Scientific Practices sits on the Map of Human Knowledge