Philosophical Pragmatics

Philosophical pragmatics is the study of how speakers mean more than, other than, or something different from what their words literally say, and how hearers recover that meaning from context.

10 frameworks, from 1945 to today · Philosophy Of Language · Philosophy

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

Philosophical pragmatics is the study of how speakers mean more than, other than, or something different from what their words literally say, and how hearers recover that meaning from context1. When someone at dinner says "Can you pass the salt?", the literal question is about ability, but the real point is a request2. When a professor writes a letter saying a student's English is excellent and attendance is regular, the reader is meant to notice what is not said. Pragmatics asks how such things work: what a speaker intends, what a hearer infers, what is presupposed rather than stated, and what social business is transacted when someone promises, warns, or apologizes1. The field matters because literal meaning alone almost never tells us what was communicated, and because the mechanisms involved—intention, inference, shared background, social action—touch logic, law, ethics, and the theory of mind1.

Ordinary Language Philosophy and the Priority of Use

Philosophical pragmatics grew out of a revolt against the idea that language could be understood as a formal calculus of meanings. In the 1940s and 1950s, Ludwig Wittgenstein's later work argued that the meaning of a word is its use in the stream of life—in "language games" embedded in practices. Around the same time, J. L. Austin at Oxford began attending closely to what speakers do with words1. In How to Do Things with Words (delivered as lectures in 1955, published 1962), Austin observed that many utterances are not descriptions at all13. Saying "I promise to pay you Tuesday" does not describe a promise; it makes one1. He called such utterances performatives and distinguished them from constatives, which describe1. He later generalized the point: every utterance has an aspect of action.

Austin introduced a threefold distinction that remains foundational1. The locutionary act is the act of saying something with a certain sense and reference24. The illocutionary act is what one does in saying it—promising, warning, ordering, asserting24. The perlocutionary act is the effect produced on the hearer—persuading, alarming, amusing54. The illocutionary level is where pragmatics lives: it is the level of force, not just content. Austin's student John Searle developed this into a systematic speech act theory in Speech Acts (1969), proposing that illocutionary acts are governed by constitutive rules and classifying them into categories such as assertives, directives, commissives, expressives, and declarations. Searle also argued that the hearer's recognition of the speaker's intention is what makes an illocutionary act the act it is—a claim that set the agenda for the next generation.

Grice: Meaning, Intention, and Implicature

The decisive turn came from H. P. Grice, whose 1957 paper "Meaning" distinguished natural meaning (smoke means fire) from non-natural meaning (a word or gesture means something because someone intends it to be recognized as so intended). Grice's analysis of speaker meaning in terms of reflexive intention—the speaker intends the hearer to recognize the intention—gave pragmatics its central explanatory tool.

In "Logic and Conversation" (delivered as lectures in 1967, published 1975), Grice asked how hearers get from what is said to what is meant1. His answer was conversational implicature1. He proposed that conversation is governed by a general Cooperative Principle—make your contribution such as is required at the stage at which it occurs—and by four maxims: Quantity (be as informative as needed, not more), Quality (be truthful), Relation (be relevant), and Manner (be clear)16. When a speaker visibly flouts a maxim, the hearer assumes cooperation and infers an extra meaning16. If A asks "Where's the petrol?" and B replies "There's a garage around the corner," B has said nothing about petrol being sold there; the hearer infers it by assuming relevance. Grice distinguished conventional implicature (attached to particular words, like the contrast carried by but) from conversational implicature (derived from maxims and context), and noted that implicatures are cancellable—one can add "but I don't mean to suggest that" without contradiction, which marks them off from entailments.

Grice's framework made it possible to explain how communication succeeds despite the gap between sentence meaning and speaker meaning, and it did so without abandoning truth-conditional semantics: implicature could be layered on top of literal content.

Presupposition and the Common Ground

A parallel strand concerned what is taken for granted rather than asserted1. Saying "The king of France is bald" seems to presuppose that there is a king of France; saying "Have you stopped beating your wife?" presupposes that you have been beating her. P. F. Strawson's 1950 reply to Bertrand Russell's theory of descriptions argued that such sentences fail to be true or false rather than being simply false, because their presuppositions fail. The 1970s saw intensive work on presupposition—its triggers (definite descriptions, factive verbs like know, change-of-state verbs like stop), its projection behavior in complex sentences, and whether it is semantic or pragmatic. Lauri Karttunen's work on presupposition projection and the "common ground" metaphor, developed further by Robert Stalnaker, reframed presupposition as what speakers assume to be shared background—what is taken for granted by participants in a conversation. This idea fed directly into later dynamic accounts.

Neo-Gricean Pragmatics

From the late 1970s, several theorists sought to simplify and sharpen Grice's maxims. Laurence Horn (1984) reduced them to two competing principles: a Q-principle (say enough—hearers infer that if the speaker had a stronger term available, they would have used it) and an R-principle (say no more than necessary—hearers enrich what is said by assuming stereotypical interpretations). Stephen Levinson developed a related framework with three principles (Quantity, Informativeness, Manner) and applied it to anaphora and other grammatical phenomena. The neo-Griceans shared a conviction that many pragmatic inferences are default or preferred interpretations, computed unless context blocks them. Their debates with context-driven theorists over whether such inferences are default or wholly context-dependent remain live.

Relevance Theory

In Relevance: Communication and Cognition (1986), Dan Sperber and Deirdre Wilson proposed a radical alternative7. They argued that a single principle—relevance—suffices. Relevance is defined in terms of cognitive effects and processing effort: an input is relevant to an individual to the extent that processing it yields positive cognitive effects for relatively little effort. Communicators, they claimed, work on the presumption that an utterance is optimally relevant7. Hearers follow a path of least effort, testing interpretations in order of accessibility and stopping when expectations of relevance are satisfied. This ostensive-inferential model treats all communication as a matter of the speaker making manifest an intention and the hearer inferring it, with implicature as one outcome among several. Relevance theory generated extensive empirical work on lexical narrowing and broadening (how "flat" in "flat tyre" is understood), on irony and metaphor as echoic or loose uses, and on the development of pragmatic abilities in children7.

Dynamic Semantics and the Common Ground

A further development treated meaning as context change rather than static truth conditions8. In dynamic semantics, associated with Irene Heim's file-change semantics (1982) and Hans Kamp's discourse representation theory (1981), the meaning of a sentence is its potential to update the information state of a conversation. This handled pronouns and definiteness across discourse in ways static semantics struggled with8. Robert Stalnaker's notion of the common ground—the set of propositions mutually assumed for the purposes of conversation—and David Lewis's work on scorekeeping in conversations (1979) gave pragmatics a way to model how assertions add to shared information and how presuppositions constrain what can be felicitously said. The common-ground framework now underlies much work on assertion, presupposition, and the social dynamics of conversation9.

Experimental Pragmatics

From the 1990s and 2000s, researchers began testing pragmatic theories with controlled experiments. Experimental pragmatics uses reaction times, eye-tracking, and developmental studies to ask, for instance, how quickly hearers derive scalar implicatures (inferences from "some" to "not all"), whether children compute them as adults do, and how context shapes interpretation. Work by Ira Noveck and others on scalar implicature, and studies of metaphor and irony comprehension, brought pragmatic theory into contact with psycholinguistics and cognitive science, sometimes confirming and sometimes challenging the armchair predictions of the major frameworks.

The Present

Philosophical pragmatics today is a meeting point of philosophy, linguistics, and cognitive science. Speech act theory continues to be developed in work on assertion, on the norms governing what we may say, and on slurs and other socially loaded expressions. Gricean and neo-Gricean accounts compete with relevance-theoretic and game-theoretic models of communication. Presupposition and common ground remain central to debates about assertion, accommodation, and the ethics of what is taken for granted. Experimental methods increasingly test long-standing theoretical claims. Open questions include how far pragmatic inference is automatic versus deliberate, how pragmatic abilities develop and break down, how the social and normative dimensions of speech acts should be modeled, and whether a single unified theory of communication is achievable or whether pragmatics is irreducibly plural.

References

  1. Pragmatics (introduction, Areas of interest, History, The performative), Wikipedia
  2. Illocutionary act, Wikipedia
  3. Performative utterance, Wikipedia
  4. Locutionary act, Wikipedia
  5. Perlocutionary act, Wikipedia
  6. Cooperative principle, Wikipedia
  7. Relevance theory, Wikipedia
  8. Dynamic semantics, Wikipedia
  9. Common ground (linguistics), Wikipedia

The frameworks of Philosophical Pragmatics

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 1945-1975
  2. 1950-Present

    Presupposition

    What is taken for granted rather than said?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  3. 1955-Present

    Speech act

    What actions do utterances perform?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  4. 1957-Present

    Gricean Intention-Based Semantics

    How does intention fix what a speaker means?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  5. 1967-Present

    Gricean Conversational Implicature

    How do hearers infer what is meant beyond what is said?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  6. 1974-Present

    Common Ground and Scorekeeping

    How does shared background shape conversation?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  7. 1979-Present

    Neo-Gricean Pragmatics

    Which pragmatic inferences are default?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  8. 1981-Present

    Dynamic Semantics

    How does meaning change the context?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  9. 1986-Present

    Relevance Theory

    What single principle explains communication?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

  10. 1995-Present

    Experimental Pragmatics

    How do hearers actually compute pragmatic meaning?

    Fly to its tower in Nousfarer

How the ideas connect

Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.

Ordinary Language PhilosophyPresuppositionSpeech actGricean Intention-Based SemanticsGricean Conversational ImplicatureCommon Ground and ScorekeepingNeo-Gricean PragmaticsDynamic SemanticsRelevance TheoryExperimental Pragmatics

Beyond the field

Where Philosophical Pragmatics's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 35 links.

A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Philosophical Pragmatics is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 10 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Philosophical Pragmatics

Related fields

Fields its ideas are linked to

More in Philosophy Of Language

See where Philosophical Pragmatics sits on the Map of Human Knowledge