Ethics Of War

The ethics of war asks a question that most moral philosophy tries to avoid: how should human beings behave when they have decided to kill one another?

13 frameworks, from 430 BCE to today · Ethics · Philosophy

still a working view ended · each leads to its entry below

Overview

The ethics of war asks a question that most moral philosophy tries to avoid: how should human beings behave when they have decided to kill one another? It is not the study of war as such but of the moral rules that govern it — when it may be begun, how it may be fought, and what may be done when it is over. The stakes are unusually concrete. A theory of just war can be used to condemn a war of aggression or to excuse one; a rule about noncombatants can protect a village or justify its destruction. Because the answers have been used to send people to their deaths and to restrain those who would kill them, the field has always been as much about power as about principle.

Ancient Foundations: Restraint Before Theory

Long before anyone wrote a treatise on just war, societies developed rules about when and how to fight. The Hebrew Bible contains rules of war — Deuteronomy 20 distinguishes between the treatment of distant cities and nearby ones, and the prophet Amos condemns nations for atrocities in war. The Mahabharata, the great Sanskrit epic of ancient India, contains extended discussions of dharma (righteous duty) in battle, including the famous dilemma of Arjuna on the eve of the Kurukshetra war, which the Bhagavad Gita addresses. In China, the Warring States period produced the Sunzi Bingfa (The Art of War), attributed to Sun Wu, which is less a moral treatise than a strategic one, but the Confucian tradition that followed developed its own account of justified punitive expeditions (zheng) and the ruler's duty to protect the people.

These traditions did not produce a single "just war theory." They produced overlapping ideas: that war should be declared by legitimate authority, that some persons (envoys, the dead, noncombatants in some formulations) should be spared, and that the purpose of war should be the restoration of order rather than conquest for its own sake. The Greek historian Thucydides, writing in the fifth century BCE, gave the field one of its most enduring challenges: in the Melian Dialogue, Athenian envoys tell the islanders of Melos that "the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must." This is the realist position in its purest form — that moral rules in war are either illusions or instruments of the powerful.

Christian Just War and the Scholastic Synthesis

The Christian tradition initially leaned toward pacifism. Early church fathers such as Tertullian and Origen argued that Christians could not serve in the Roman army, and the Sermon on the Mount's injunction to turn the other cheek was taken seriously. But as Christianity became the religion of the Roman Empire, the question changed: could a Christian emperor wage war? Augustine of Hippo, writing in the late fourth and early fifth centuries, answered yes, but only under strict conditions. In The City of God and various letters, Augustine argued that war could be justified only by a wrong received, only by a legitimate authority, and only with the right intention — the aim of peace, not conquest or cruelty. This was not a systematic theory but a set of principles that later writers would develop1.

The systematic development came in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, when European scholars recovered Aristotle's works and began applying his method of logical analysis to moral questions. Gratian's Decretum (c. 1140) collected canon law on war; the Decretists who followed debated whether war could ever be justified and under what conditions. But the decisive figure was Thomas Aquinas, whose Summa Theologiae (written 1265–1274) contained a compact treatise on war that became the template for centuries of Catholic thought. Aquinas asked whether it is always sinful to wage war and answered no, provided three conditions are met: the war must be declared by a legitimate authority, it must be fought for a just cause (the recovery of something wrongly taken or the defense of the realm), and it must be fought with a right intention (the advancement of good and the avoidance of evil)1. Aquinas did not develop a detailed account of how war should be fought — the jus in bello — but his framework of jus ad bellum (the justice of going to war) became the foundation of the tradition.

Alongside this, the natural law tradition — the idea that there are moral principles discoverable by reason, binding on all human beings regardless of their religion — provided the philosophical grounding. Francisco de Vitoria, a sixteenth-century Spanish Dominican teaching at Salamanca, applied natural law to the Spanish conquest of the Americas. In his lectures De Indis (1532), Vitoria argued that the Spanish had no right to wage war on the indigenous peoples simply because they were non-Christians, and that the Indians possessed legitimate dominion over their own lands. This was a radical claim in its context, and it marked the beginning of a more universalistic approach to the ethics of war — one that asked what rules applied between peoples, not just within Christendom.

The Law of Nations and the Secular Turn

The next great turning point came with the Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius, whose De Jure Belli ac Pacis (On the Law of War and Peace) was published in 1625, during the Thirty Years' War. Grotius's innovation was to argue that the law of nations (jus gentium) was binding not because it was revealed by God but because it was grounded in human reason and sociability2. Even if God did not exist, Grotius famously suggested, the natural law would still hold. This secularization of the just war tradition made it possible to speak of moral rules in war that applied to all peoples, Christian or not.

Grotius also developed the distinction between jus ad bellum and jus in bello more fully than his predecessors, and he argued for the protection of noncombatants, the immunity of envoys, and the obligation to keep faith with enemies. His work was taken up by later writers in the natural law tradition, including Samuel Pufendorf and Christian Wolff, and it fed into the development of international law in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. The Swiss jurist Emer de Vattel, in Le Droit des Gens (1758), systematized the law of nations in a form that influenced the founders of the American republic and the early international lawyers.

At the same time, a different strand of thought was developing: the cosmopolitan project of perpetual peace. The Abbé de Saint-Pierre, in the early eighteenth century, proposed a European confederation to abolish war; Jean-Jacques Rousseau commented on his plan; and Immanuel Kant, in Zum ewigen Frieden (Perpetual Peace, 1795), argued that a federation of republican states, combined with universal hospitality and the gradual abolition of standing armies, could create the conditions for lasting peace. Kant's essay was not a work of just war theory but a vision of a world in which the question of war would become moot. It influenced the later development of international institutions, including the League of Nations and the United Nations.

Pacifism and the Realist Challenge

Not everyone accepted that war could be morally justified. The pacifist tradition — the belief that war is always wrong — has deep roots in Christianity, from the early church to the Mennonites, Quakers, and other historic peace churches. In the modern period, pacifism became a self-conscious political and ethical position. Leo Tolstoy, in The Kingdom of God Is Within You (1894), argued that Christians must refuse military service; his writings influenced Mahatma Gandhi, whose philosophy of nonviolent resistance (satyagraha) was developed in the context of the struggle against British rule in India and later inspired Martin Luther King Jr. and others. Pacifism has remained a minority position in the ethics of war, but it has served as a constant challenge to the just war tradition, forcing its defenders to explain why killing in war is sometimes permissible when killing in other contexts is not.

The realist challenge was equally persistent. Realism in international relations — the view that states pursue their interests and that moral rules are either irrelevant or merely rhetorical — has ancient roots in Thucydides and was developed in the modern period by figures such as Niccolò Machiavelli and Thomas Hobbes3. In the twentieth century, the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, in Moral Man and Immoral Society (1932), argued that while individuals could be moral, nations could not, and that the ethics of war had to reckon with the realities of power. The political scientist Hans Morgenthau, in Politics Among Nations (1948), systematized realism as a theory of international politics. Realists have often been skeptical of just war theory, arguing that it either describes what states already do or provides a cover for their interests. But realism has also influenced the ethics of war by insisting that moral reasoning must take account of consequences and the limits of what can be achieved.

The Twentieth Century: Total War, Human Rights, and the Revival of Just War

The two world wars transformed the ethics of war. The scale of destruction — the bombing of cities, the Holocaust, the use of nuclear weapons — made the traditional distinctions between combatants and noncombatants seem fragile. The Nuremberg and Tokyo tribunals after World War II established the principle that individuals could be held responsible for crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, and the Geneva Conventions of 1949 and their Additional Protocols of 1977 codified the laws of war in international humanitarian law. The United Nations Charter (1945) prohibited the use of force except in self-defense or with Security Council authorization, and the subsequent development of human rights law created a new framework for evaluating war.

In philosophy, the just war tradition was revived in the late twentieth century, most influentially by Michael Walzer's Just and Unjust Wars (1977). Walzer argued that the moral reality of war could be understood through the experiences of those who fought it, and he defended the traditional distinction between jus ad bellum and jus in bello, including the principle of noncombatant immunity. His work was widely taught and debated, and it set the terms for much of the subsequent discussion. But it was also challenged. The "revisionist" just war theory that emerged in the 2000s, associated with philosophers such as Jeff McMahan, argued that the traditional distinction between jus ad bellum and jus in bello was too sharp: if a soldier is fighting for an unjust cause, McMahan argued, he is not morally equivalent to a soldier fighting for a just one, even if he follows the rules of war. This "moral equality of soldiers" — the idea that combatants on both sides have the same moral status — had been a cornerstone of the tradition, and the revisionists questioned it4. McMahan's Killing in War (2009) developed a responsibility-based account of liability to attack, arguing that what matters is whether a person is responsible for an unjust threat, not whether he wears a uniform.

Critical, Feminist, and Postcolonial Perspectives

The late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries also saw the rise of critical approaches that questioned the assumptions of the traditional just war framework. Feminist ethics of war, developed by scholars such as Jean Bethke Elshtain, Sara Ruddick, and later Laura Sjoberg, asked how the tradition had been shaped by gendered assumptions — about who fights, who is protected, and what counts as a "just" cause. Ruddick's Maternal Thinking (1989) argued that the experience of mothering provided a distinctive perspective on the ethics of violence, one that emphasized the preservation of life rather than its sacrifice. Feminist scholars also drew attention to the ways in which war affects women differently from men, including through sexual violence, displacement, and the gendered division of labor in war economies.

Postcolonial and critical war ethics examined how the just war tradition had been used to justify colonial conquest and how its categories — "civilized" and "uncivilized" peoples, "legitimate" and "illegitimate" authority — reflected the interests of European powers. The historian and philosopher of law Antony Anghie, in Imperialism, Sovereignty and the Making of International Law (2005), showed how the law of nations had been constructed through the encounter with non-European peoples. Other scholars drew on the work of Frantz Fanon and other anti-colonial thinkers to argue that the ethics of war had to take account of structural violence and the legacies of empire.

Asymmetric War and Emerging Technology

The post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the rise of non-state armed groups such as al-Qaeda and the Islamic State, brought new questions to the fore. The ethics of asymmetric and irregular warfare asked how the traditional rules applied when one side was a state with a professional army and the other was a network of irregular fighters who did not wear uniforms or respect the laws of war. The debate over targeted killing, drone warfare, and the detention of suspected terrorists without trial tested the boundaries of the just war framework. Some scholars argued that the traditional categories were inadequate to the new forms of conflict; others defended the continued relevance of the old rules.

The ethics of emerging military technology — autonomous weapons systems, cyber warfare, and artificial intelligence in warfare — is the newest frontier. The debate over "killer robots" (lethal autonomous weapons systems) asks whether machines should be allowed to make life-and-death decisions without human oversight. The Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, launched in 2012, has called for a preemptive ban, and the United Nations has held discussions on the issue. Cyber warfare raises questions about what counts as an "attack" and how the principles of distinction and proportionality apply in a domain where the effects can be widespread and unpredictable. These debates are still developing, and they draw on the long history of the field even as they challenge its categories.

The Present State of the Field

Today the ethics of war is a lively and contested field. The traditionalist just war theory, descended from Aquinas and Walzer, remains influential, especially in military academies and policy circles. The revisionist approach, associated with McMahan and others, has reshaped the philosophical debate, particularly on the question of who is liable to attack. Feminist, postcolonial, and critical approaches have broadened the field's scope, asking whose experiences and whose voices are represented in its theories. The law of armed conflict, codified in the Geneva Conventions and customary international law, provides a legal framework that both draws on and informs the ethical debate5.

The questions that remain open are the ones that have always driven the field: When is it right to go to war? What may be done to whom in war? And what, if anything, can restrain the violence that human beings inflict on one another? The answers have changed over time, but the questions have not.

References

  1. Just war theory (Saint Augustine, Saint Thomas Aquinas), Wikipedia
  2. De jure belli ac pacis, Wikipedia
  3. Realism (international relations), Wikipedia
  4. Revisionist just war theory, Wikipedia
  5. Geneva Conventions, Wikipedia

The frameworks of Ethics Of War

Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.

  1. 430 BCE-Present
  2. 180-Present
  3. 400-Present
  4. 600-1400
  5. 1532-1800
  6. 1713-Present
  7. 1945-Present
  8. 1977-Present
  9. 1989-Present
  10. 2000-Present
  11. 2000-Present
  12. 2001-Present
  13. 2012-Present
A city in Nousfarer: a red-carpeted stair climbing terraces to a crowned tower on an acropolis, more towers round it, forest and snowy mountains beyond.
A city in Nousfarer, the game played in the browser.

Ethics Of War is a planet in Nousfarer

Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.

Land on Ethics Of War

Related fields

More in Ethics

See where Ethics Of War sits on the Map of Human Knowledge