- Atlas
- Philosophy
- Grounding And Fundamentality
Grounding And Fundamentality
Grounding is the relation that holds between things when one of them is so because of another.
14 frameworks, from 350 BCE to today · Metaphysics · Philosophy
- Aristotelian priority and dependence 350 BCE-300 BCE
- Foundationalism 350 BCE-Present
- Medieval essence-existence hierarchy 1020-1275
- Reductionism 1930-1980
- Supervenience 1970-2000
- Coherentism 1980-Present
- Grounding Theory 1997-Present
- Infinitism 1998-Present
- Grounding inflationism 2001-Present
- Grounding-essence theory 2001-Present
- Grounding deflationism 2005-Present
- Priority monism 2007-Present
- Priority pluralism 2007-Present
- Grounding as metaphysical explanation 2010-Present
Overview
Grounding is the relation that holds between things when one of them is so because of another1. The glass is fragile because of its molecular structure; the act is wrong because it causes needless suffering; the whole exists because its parts do. Fundamentality is the other side of the same coin: if some facts are grounded in others, the ones that ground without being grounded themselves are fundamental—the stopping points of explanation1. The subfield asks what this "because" relation is, whether it is one relation or many, whether the chain of dependence can end, and what it means to call something basic. The stakes are large. If everything depends on something else, nothing is fundamental and metaphysics loses its traditional subject matter; if some things are fundamental, we need an account of what makes them so. The history of these questions runs from Aristotle's talk of prior and posterior things through medieval hierarchies of being, into twentieth-century debates about reduction and supervenience, and finally to the self-conscious "grounding" literature that began around the turn of the twenty-first century.
Priority and Dependence in Aristotle
Aristotle gave the vocabulary its first systematic shape. In the Categories he distinguishes things that are "prior by nature" from things prior merely to us: the former are what others depend on for their being, the latter what we come to know first. In the Metaphysics he develops the idea of a hierarchy of substances, with primary substances—concrete individuals like this human or this horse—as the basic entities on which everything else depends. Qualities, quantities, and relations are "said of" or "in" substances; they cannot exist apart from them. This is a dependence claim: accidents depend on substances, not the reverse1.
Aristotle also introduced the four causes—material, formal, efficient, final—as answers to "because of what?" questions2. The material cause explains what something is made of, the formal cause what it is, the efficient cause what brought it about, and the final cause what it is for. These are not all "grounding" in the modern sense, but they establish the pattern of explaining one thing by reference to another more basic thing. His distinction between potentiality and actuality adds a further layer: a seed is potentially a tree, and the tree is the actuality toward which the seed is oriented3. Priority in being, for Aristotle, is often priority in actuality.
Medieval Hierarchies of Essence and Existence
Medieval philosophers inherited Aristotle's framework and transformed it into a theology of creation1. Avicenna (Ibn Sina, 980–1037) drew a sharp distinction between essence (what a thing is) and existence (that it is). For Avicenna, created things are "possible in themselves" but "necessary through another"—their existence is borrowed from a necessary being, God. This establishes a hierarchy in which every finite thing depends for its existence on something more fundamental, culminating in the one being whose essence is existence. The structure is a grounding chain: each link explains the next, and the chain terminates in the necessary.
Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) adopted and modified this scheme. In his Summa Theologiae he argues that the world exhibits a hierarchy of causes, and that an infinite regress of essentially ordered causes is impossible—there must be a first cause. This is not merely a causal argument but a claim about ontological dependence: the existence of any contingent thing is grounded in something whose existence is not contingent. The medieval synthesis thus gave the subfield its first sustained treatment of the regress problem and of the distinction between essence and existence as two aspects of a thing's being.
Supervenience, Reduction, and the Analytic Turn
The twentieth century approached dependence through the philosophy of science. In the 1950s and 1960s, debates about the relation between mental states and brain states, or between moral properties and natural properties, generated the concept of supervenience. To say that A-properties supervene on B-properties is to say that there can be no difference in A-properties without a difference in B-properties4. The notion was used by philosophers such as R. M. Hare in ethics and Donald Davidson in the philosophy of mind, and it was formalized in the 1980s by Jaegwon Kim and others. Supervenience captures a kind of dependence—the higher-level facts are fixed by the lower-level facts—but it does not say why or how. It is a modal correlation, not an explanatory relation.
Reduction was the stronger claim: that higher-level properties just are lower-level properties, or that higher-level theories can be derived from lower-level ones. The logical empiricists had hoped for a unified science in which everything would be reduced to physics. By the 1970s, however, multiple realizability—the idea that the same mental state can be realized by different physical states—made simple reduction seem unlikely. Supervenience without reduction became the default position for many philosophers of mind. But this left a gap: if the mental supervenes on the physical without being reducible to it, what exactly is the relation? The question set the stage for the revival of grounding.
The Grounding Revival
The term "grounding" in its contemporary sense entered analytic metaphysics in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Kit Fine's "The Question of Realism" (2001) and "Guide to Ground" (2012), together with work by Gideon Rosen, Jonathan Schaffer, and Fabrice Correia, made grounding a central topic. The core idea is that grounding is a relation of non-causal explanation: when we say that the fact that the glass is fragile is grounded in the fact that its molecules are arranged thus and so, we are saying that the first fact obtains because the second does1. Grounding is fact-to-fact, or entity-to-entity, depending on the theorist, and it is supposed to be irreflexive, asymmetric, and transitive1.
The grounding-essence approach, associated especially with Fine and Correia, ties grounding to essence: a fact is grounded in another when the essence of the first involves the second. On this view, the grounding relation is not a primitive but is explained by the natures of the things involved. The essence of a singleton set, for example, involves its member; the essence of a whole involves its parts. This approach promised to unify grounding with the older Aristotelian notion of essence and to explain why grounding claims are necessary rather than contingent.
Inflationism, Deflationism, and the Regress Problem
Two broad camps emerged. Grounding inflationists (such as Schaffer and Fine) hold that grounding is a genuine, irreducible relation that does real metaphysical work. It is not merely a façon de parler or a stylistic variant of ordinary explanation; it tracks a mind-independent structure of dependence in the world. Grounding deflationists (such as Jessica Wilson and, in a different vein, Ted Sider) are skeptical. They argue that grounding talk can be paraphrased away, that it adds no explanatory power beyond supervenience and essence, or that it is too obscure to earn its keep. The debate turns on whether grounding is a single unified relation or a family of relations, and whether it can be defined without circularity.
The regress problem is as old as Aristotle but took on new urgency. If every fact is grounded in another, we face an infinite regress. Foundationalism holds that the regress terminates in fundamental facts—facts that are not grounded in anything else1. Coherentism denies that there are fundamental facts; instead, facts are grounded in one another in a holistic web, each supporting the others. Infinitism accepts that the regress is infinite and denies that it needs a foundation. Each position has costs: foundationalism must explain what makes a fact fundamental without appealing to further grounding; coherentism must explain how mutual dependence can be explanatory; infinitism must explain how an infinite chain can be completed or why it need not be.
Monism, Pluralism, and the Structure of the Fundamental
A parallel debate concerns the shape of the fundamental level. Priority monism, defended most prominently by Schaffer, holds that the whole cosmos is the one fundamental entity and that all particular things are grounded in it5. This is a modern descendant of Parmenidean and Spinozistic monism6. Priority pluralism holds that there are many fundamental entities—perhaps elementary particles, or facts about them—and that the whole is grounded in the parts. The debate is not merely about count; it is about the direction of grounding. Does the whole depend on the parts, or do the parts depend on the whole? Schaffer argues that quantum entanglement and the relational structure of physics favor monism; pluralists reply that the evidence is ambiguous and that common sense and scientific practice favor a bottom-up picture.
Grounding as Explanation
The most recent strand treats grounding as a species of explanation. On this view, to say that A grounds B is to say that A explains B in a distinctive, non-causal way1. This connects grounding to the broader literature on metaphysical explanation and to questions about what makes an explanation good1. If grounding is explanatory, then the norms of explanation—simplicity, unification, explanatory power—may constrain which grounding claims we should accept1. Critics worry that this makes grounding too epistemic, too dependent on our explanatory practices rather than on the world itself. Defenders reply that metaphysical explanation is objective: it is the world's own structure that makes one fact explain another.
The Present State of the Field
Today the subfield is lively and fragmented. The grounding relation is widely used in metaphysics of mind, ethics, philosophy of science, and social ontology, but its status remains contested1. Inflationists and deflationists continue to argue about whether grounding is primitive or definable. The regress problem has generated sophisticated treatments of foundationalism, coherentism, and infinitism, with no consensus. Priority monism and pluralism are both defended with appeals to physics and to metaphysical principle. The grounding-essence approach has gained ground as a way of unifying grounding with modality and essence. Open questions include whether grounding is factive or sentential, whether there can be grounding loops, whether grounding is hyperintensional (distinguishing necessarily equivalent facts), and how grounding relates to causation and to modality. The history of the subfield is thus a history of attempts to make precise an intuition as old as philosophy: that some things are more basic than others, and that the basic explains the rest.
References
- Metaphysical grounding (introduction, Dependence “in virtue of”, Explanation and hierarchical structure, Medieval perspectives, Partial order constraints, Well-foundedness debate, Unionist vs. separatist views, Explanation scope and norms, Philosophy of mind, Metaethics, Truthmaker theory and metaphysics of science, Other domains), Wikipedia
- Four causes, Wikipedia
- Potentiality and actuality, Wikipedia
- Supervenience, Wikipedia
- Jonathan Schaffer (Priority monism), Wikipedia
- Monism (introduction, History), Wikipedia
The frameworks of Grounding And Fundamentality
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 350 BCE-300 BCE
- 350 BCE-Present
- 1020-1275
- 1930-1980
- 1970-2000
- 1980-Present
- 1997-Present
- 1998-Present
- 2001-Present
- 2001-Present
- 2005-Present
- 2007-Present
- 2007-Present
- 2010-Present

Grounding And Fundamentality is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 14 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Grounding And FundamentalityRelated fields
More in Metaphysics
- Free Will
- Metaphysics
- Modality
- Ontology
- Persistence And Material Objects
- Personal Identity
- Philosophy Of Causation
- Philosophy Of Time
- Properties And Universals
- Social Ontology
See where Grounding And Fundamentality sits on the Map of Human Knowledge