- Atlas
- Philosophy
- Religion And Science
Religion And Science
Religion and science, as a philosophical subject, is the reasoned examination of how two of the most powerful forces in human culture—religious traditions and the natural sciences—relate to one another, and what each implies about the other.
13 frameworks, from 1500 to today · Philosophy Of Religion · Philosophy
- Two Books of Scripture and Nature 1500-1800
- Natural Theology 1650-Present
- Substance Dualism 1650-Present
- Of Miracles 1748-Present
- Conflict Thesis 1874-1930
- Creationism and Intelligent Design 1920-Present
- Divine Action Theory 1950-Present
- Independence 1950-Present
- Theistic evolution 1980-Present
- Cognitive Science of Religion 1990-Present
- Dialogue and Integration Typology 1990-Present
- Non-reductive Physicalism 1990-Present
- Methodological Self-Consciousness 2000-Present
Overview
Religion and science, as a philosophical subject, is the reasoned examination of how two of the most powerful forces in human culture—religious traditions and the natural sciences—relate to one another, and what each implies about the other. The stakes are high: whether the universe has a purpose, whether miracles happen, whether scripture can be reconciled with geology and biology, whether God can act in a world governed by physical law, and whether religious belief is rational in an age of science. The field is not simply "science versus religion." Its history is a long argument about what kind of relationship is even possible.
Two Books and the Pre-Modern Harmony
For most of Western history, the dominant framework was the two books metaphor: God has revealed himself in two "books," the book of Scripture and the book of nature. This idea, given classic expression by figures such as Francis Bacon and Galileo, held that both books come from the same author and therefore cannot truly contradict one another. Where they seemed to conflict, the fault lay in interpretation—either of the biblical text or of nature.
This framework presupposed a harmony that was not merely tolerated but actively pursued. Medieval and early modern natural philosophers—Newton prominent among them—studied nature partly as a way of reading God's creation. Natural theology, the project of reasoning to God's existence and attributes from features of the world, was the intellectual engine of this harmony. William Paley's Natural Theology (1802), with its famous watchmaker argument, is the classic statement: the apparent design of biological organisms, like a watch found on a heath, implies a designer. Natural theology treated science as a support for religion, not a rival.
The Conflict Thesis and Its Critics
The nineteenth century produced a very different picture. John William Draper's History of the Conflict between Religion and Science (1874) and Andrew Dickson White's A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom (1896) popularized what became known as the conflict thesis: the claim that science and religion are engaged in an inevitable, ongoing war, with science progressively winning. The Galileo affair and the Darwinian controversy were presented as representative battles.
The conflict thesis was enormously influential in popular culture, but historians of science later subjected it to sustained criticism1. Scholars such as John Hedley Brooke, in Science and Religion: Some Historical Perspectives (1991), showed that the actual historical relationships were far more varied—sometimes cooperative, sometimes indifferent, sometimes tense—and that the "warfare" narrative distorted complex episodes. The conflict thesis survives more as a popular assumption than as a serious historiographical position, though particular conflicts (over evolution, over the age of the earth) are real enough.
Independence and the Typologies
In the twentieth century, philosophers and theologians tried to map the possible relationships systematically. The most influential scheme was proposed by Ian Barbour in Religion in an Age of Science (1990), which distinguished four positions: conflict, independence, dialogue, and integration.
Independence holds that science and religion answer different questions and operate in different domains—science describes how the world works, religion addresses meaning and value—so they cannot conflict1. This view is associated with the "non-overlapping magisteria" idea later popularized by Stephen Jay Gould (1999), and it echoes earlier Protestant distinctions between the realms of nature and grace. Its appeal is that it defuses conflict; its weakness is that it can seem to trivialize religion by removing it from factual claims altogether.
Dialogue and integration represent more constructive relationships. Dialogue finds points of contact—methodological parallels, boundary questions, ethical implications—without merging the two. Integration goes further, seeking a unified account: either by incorporating science into theology (as in process theology, which uses Whiteheadian metaphysics to conceive of God as acting within, not against, natural processes) or by developing a "theology of nature" informed by science.
Divine Action: The Central Philosophical Problem
Perhaps the deepest philosophical problem in the field is divine action: how can God act in a world described by deterministic or probabilistic physical laws? If nature is a closed causal system, where is there room for God to act? This question drives much of the technical literature.
Classical solutions invoked substance dualism—the view that mind and body, or God and world, are distinct substances—and allowed God to intervene "from outside" as it were, producing miracles. David Hume's critique of miracles, in An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748), posed the enduring challenge: since a miracle is by definition a violation of the laws of nature, and the evidence for uniform natural law is overwhelming, the testimony for any miracle would have to be so strong that its falsehood would be more miraculous than the event itself. Hume's argument remains the starting point for nearly all philosophical discussion of miracles.
Modern approaches try to avoid both interventionism and the reduction of God to a mere spectator. Non-reductive physicalism and related positions in the philosophy of mind hold that mental states are real and causally efficacious without being reducible to physics—a model some theologians use to think about God's causal relation to the world. Others appeal to indeterminacy in quantum mechanics or chaos theory as "gaps" where divine action might occur without violating law, though critics warn against a "God of the gaps" whose role shrinks as science advances.
Creationism, Evolution, and Design
The Darwinian revolution made biological origins the flashpoint. Creationism—the rejection of evolution in favor of a literal reading of Genesis—took organized form in the twentieth century, especially in American Protestant fundamentalism. Its more sophisticated descendant, intelligent design, argues that certain biological structures are "irreducibly complex" and thus best explained by an intelligent cause rather than undirected natural selection. The movement, associated with the Discovery Institute from the 1990s, has been scientifically and legally contested; the 2005 Kitzmiller v. Dover decision in the United States ruled that teaching intelligent design in public schools constituted teaching religion.
Against these, evolutionary creationism (also called evolutionary creation or theistic evolution) holds that God creates through the evolutionary process, treating Genesis as theological rather than scientific literature. This position, defended by figures such as Francis Collins and articulated in the "BioLogos" project, represents a large and growing strand of Christian thought that accepts mainstream science while retaining a doctrine of creation.
The Cognitive Science of Religion
A newer development, emerging from the 1990s, is the cognitive science of religion (CSR). Rather than asking whether religious beliefs are true, CSR asks why they are so widespread and easily acquired. Scholars such as Pascal Boyer, Scott Atran, and Justin Barrett argue that ordinary cognitive mechanisms—agency detection, theory of mind, memory biases—make certain religious concepts "minimally counterintuitive" and thus culturally successful. The philosophical significance is debatable: some take CSR as a debunking explanation that undermines religious belief, while others argue that explaining a belief's origin says nothing about its truth. This debate connects religion-and-science to religious epistemology.
Methodological Self-Consciousness and the Present
Contemporary work is marked by greater methodological self-consciousness: scholars are more careful about what kind of claim they are making—historical, philosophical, theological, or scientific—and about the assumptions each brings. The field has moved away from grand typologies toward fine-grained studies of particular episodes and problems.
Today the main approaches coexist. The conflict thesis persists in popular discourse but is largely rejected by specialists12. Independence remains a live option for those who see science and religion as answering different questions1. Dialogue and integration continue in the work of philosophers and theologians engaging specific sciences—cosmology, evolutionary biology, neuroscience. Divine action remains the most technically demanding open problem, with no consensus solution. The cognitive science of religion has opened new empirical questions about belief. And the older natural theology tradition, though battered by Hume and Darwin, has not disappeared; it has been reformulated in probabilistic and Bayesian terms by contemporary philosophers. What unites the field is the conviction that the relationship between religion and science is not a single question but a family of them, each requiring careful, historically informed, and philosophically disciplined attention.
References
- Relationship between science and religion (Conflict thesis, Independence), Wikipedia
- Conflict thesis, Wikipedia
The frameworks of Religion And Science
Each framework is a way of working the field has used: when it held, and the question it answers.
- 1500-1800
Two Books of Scripture and Nature
How do scripture and nature both reveal God?
- 1650-Present
- 1650-Present
- 1748-Present
- 1874-1930
- 1920-Present
Creationism and Intelligent Design
Does life show evidence of intelligent design?
- 1950-Present
- 1950-Present
- 1980-Present
- 1990-Present
Cognitive Science of Religion
Why are religious beliefs so widespread and natural?
- 1990-Present
Dialogue and Integration Typology
What types of relationship can science and religion have?
- 1990-Present
- 2000-Present
Methodological Self-Consciousness
What kind of claim is each scholar really making?
How the ideas connect
Each arrow runs from an earlier idea to the later one it shaped. The list below says what passed between them.
Natural Theology grew out of Two Books of Scripture and Nature
The two-books framework treated nature as a second revelation whose study could yield knowledge of God; natural theology grew out of this by making the book of nature a source of rational arguments for God's existence and attributes.
Carried by Francis Bacon; Robert Boyle; John Ray.
Theistic evolution reacted against Creationism and Intelligent Design
Theistic evolution developed as a direct alternative to creationism and intelligent design, accepting mainstream evolutionary science while retaining a doctrine of creation.
Carried by Francis Collins; BioLogos.
Dialogue and Integration Typology grew out of Independence
Independence became one of the four positions in Barbour's dialogue-and-integration typology, which systematized the possible relationships between science and religion.
Carried by Ian Barbour; Religion in an Age of Science (1990).
Divine Action Theory reacted against Substance Dualism
Divine action theory emerged as theologians and philosophers sought to move beyond the interventionist picture associated with substance dualism, in which God acts on the world from outside as one substance on another.
Carried by Austin Farrer; Ian Barbour.
Divine Action Theory influenced by Of Miracles
Hume's argument that miracles are violations of natural law set the terms for later divine action debates, forcing accounts of God's action to avoid straightforward interventionism.
Carried by David Hume; An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748).
Independence reacted against Conflict Thesis
The independence view arose partly as a way to defuse the conflict thesis by assigning science and religion separate domains, so that apparent warfare is a category mistake.
Carried by Ian Barbour.
Dialogue and Integration Typology influenced by Conflict Thesis
Barbour's fourfold typology was constructed explicitly to move beyond the conflict thesis, treating conflict as only one of several possible relationships between science and religion.
Carried by Ian Barbour; Religion in an Age of Science (1990).
Non-reductive Physicalism influenced by Divine Action Theory
Non-reductive physicalism was taken up by theologians as a model for divine action, since it allows mental (or divine) causation to be real without competing with physical causes.
Carried by Nancey Murphy; Philip Clayton.
Methodological Self-Consciousness reacted against Dialogue and Integration Typology
Growing methodological self-consciousness led scholars to move away from grand typologies like Barbour's toward fine-grained historical and philosophical studies of particular episodes.
Carried by John Hedley Brooke.
Theistic evolution influenced by Natural Theology
Theistic evolutionists retain a natural-theological conviction that nature reveals God, but they relocate design from special interventions to the created order of the evolutionary process itself.
Carried by Francis Collins.
Beyond the field
Where Religion And Science's ideas came from in other fields, and what they led to there: the strongest 12 of 32 links.
Natural Theology influenced Deism in Philosophy Of Religion
Deism grew out of natural theology: it kept the rational arguments from nature and design while discarding revelation, so that natural religion became the whole of religion. The deists' appeal to the book of nature against scripture is the direct continuation of that project.
Carried by John Toland; Matthew Tindal.
Natural Theology influenced Teleological Argument in Philosophy Of Theism
Paley's Natural Theology (1802) restated the design argument as an inference from contrivance to a designer, and this became the standard form of the teleological argument that later defenders and critics addressed.
Carried by William Paley; Natural Theology (1802).
Of Miracles influenced by Empiricism in Epistemology
Hume's argument against miracles rests on the empiricist principle that all reasonable belief derives from experience, so a report of a violation of experience must be weighed against that experience. Locke's and Berkeley's empiricism supplied the evidential framework he applied.
Carried by John Locke; David Hume.
Creationism and Intelligent Design revived Natural Theology in Philosophy Of Religion
Creationism and intelligent design deliberately revived the design arguments of natural theology, from Paley's watch to the argument from contrivance, against Darwinian explanation. The modern movement reasserts that older reasoning as its core.
Carried by William Paley; Natural Theology (1802).
Theistic evolution influenced by Darwinism in Human Evolution
Theistic evolution is built directly on Darwinian evolutionary theory, accepting common descent and natural selection while adding that God is the ultimate cause of the process. Darwin's account of evolution by natural selection is the scientific content the position incorporates.
Carried by Charles Darwin.
Two Books of Scripture and Nature influenced by Classical Faith and Reason Synthesis in Religious Epistemology
The medieval synthesis of faith and reason, above all in Aquinas, supplied the Two Books tradition with its warrant for reasoning from created nature to God. Early modern natural theologians inherited that scholastic confidence that reason and revelation cannot conflict.
Carried by Thomas Aquinas.
Two Books of Scripture and Nature influenced Special Creation and Catastrophism in Human Evolution
The 'two books' doctrine that nature is a second scripture licensed naturalists to study creation as divine revelation. This framing fed directly into natural theology and into the special-creationist reading of fossils and strata that catastrophist geologists and creationists defended before 1859.
Carried by John Ray; William Paley.
Natural Theology provoked Kantian Philosophy of Religion in Philosophy Of Religion
Kantian philosophy of religion defined itself against natural theology by denying that speculative reason can prove God's existence, replacing natural theology with moral faith.
Carried by Immanuel Kant.
Natural Theology provoked Critique of Religion in Philosophy Of Religion
The critique of religion defined itself against natural theology's attempt to prove God from the world. Feuerbach and later critics argued that natural theology's arguments merely project human attributes onto nature, so the critique arose as a rejection of the natural-theological project.
Carried by Ludwig Feuerbach.
Substance Dualism influenced Occasionalism in Philosophy Of Causation
Occasionalism was developed within a substance-dualist framework: the real distinction of mind and body raised the question of how they interact, and occasionalism answered it by denying any causal commerce between them. Descartes's dualism set the problem Malebranche solved occasionally.
Carried by René Descartes; Nicolas Malebranche.
Substance Dualism led to Occasionalism in Philosophy Of Causation
Occasionalism grew directly out of Cartesian dualism: once mind and body are distinct substances, their interaction needs explaining, and occasionalists such as Malebranche and Geulincx made God the sole cause of the correspondence. It is a branch of the framework's problem.
Carried by Nicolas Malebranche; Arnold Geulincx.
Substance Dualism influenced by Aristotelian Demonstration and Natural Philosophy in Philosophy Of Science
Descartes was schooled in Aristotelian demonstration and natural philosophy and built his dualism partly by rejecting hylomorphism while keeping the demonstrative ideal. His arguments for the real distinction of mind and body are framed against the scholastic account of form and matter.
Carried by Aristotle; René Descartes.

Religion And Science is a planet in Nousfarer
Its city has a tower for each of these 13 frameworks. Land, walk in, and climb one concept at a time.
Land on Religion And ScienceRelated fields
Fields its ideas are linked to
- Philosophy Of Religion 6 links
- Mental Causation And Physicalism 5 links
- Philosophy Of Theism 4 links
- Human Evolution 2 links
- Science And Society 2 links
- Philosophy Of Causation 2 links
- Philosophy Of Mind 2 links
- Anthropology 1 link
- History Of Science & Technology 1 link
- Epistemology 1 link
- Metaphysics 1 link
- Religious Epistemology 1 link
More in Philosophy Of Religion
- Philosophy Of Religion
- Philosophy Of Theism
- Problem Of Evil And Divine Hiddenness
- Religious Epistemology
- Religious Experience
- Religious Pluralism
See where Religion And Science sits on the Map of Human Knowledge